Carbon Steel Vs. Cast Iron: The Ultimate Pan-Off

Carbon steel and cast iron pans have a lot in common. They're both durable, versatile, and require similar care. However, there are some key differences to consider when choosing between the two. One of the most significant differences is weight—cast iron is typically heavier than carbon steel due to its higher carbon content, making carbon steel easier to manoeuvre and better suited for outdoor cooking setups. Cast iron takes longer to heat up and cool down, making it ideal for cooking techniques that require sustained heat, such as braising or baking. On the other hand, carbon steel heats up and cools down faster, making it a better choice for cooking methods like sautéing or flash frying.

Carbon steel pans are lighter and easier to manoeuvre

The lighter weight of carbon steel pans makes them easier to lift, flip, and sauté with. They are also better suited to being transported, making them a perfect choice for outdoor cooking setups. The longer handles on carbon steel pans also aid in lifting and make them great for cooking outdoors over an open flame.

The lighter weight of carbon steel pans also means they heat up and cool down faster than cast iron. This makes carbon steel pans more responsive to changes in temperature, which is ideal for cooking techniques that require precise temperature control, such as grilling or cooking over an open fire. However, it is important to note that carbon steel pans can warp if heated or cooled too quickly, so they should always be warmed slowly and never run under cold water.

The lighter weight and thinner construction of carbon steel pans also make them more energy-efficient, as they require less energy to heat up and cool down. This can lead to energy savings in the kitchen.

Carbon steel pans heat up and cool down faster

Carbon steel pans are formed by spinning and stamping, which makes them lighter and thinner than cast iron. This is the main reason why carbon steel pans heat up and cool down faster than cast iron pans. The slight bow in the carbon steel cookware also allows the pan to cool down quickly, making it ideal for cooking delicate foods such as flash-fried or sautéed vegetables.

The faster heat-up time of carbon steel pans is a significant advantage for hungry or impatient cooks. This also means that carbon steel pans respond quickly to changes in temperature. You don't have to worry about residual heat when changing the heat from medium to low. This makes carbon steel pans ideal for grilling or cooking over an open fire, as you can get a perfect sear without the risk of overcooking.

However, the slower heat-up time of cast iron pans means they retain heat for longer. This makes cast iron pans better for cooking techniques that require sustained heat, such as braising, baking, or shallow or deep frying.

Both types of pans are tough and can withstand high heat, making them great for searing meats. They can also be used on any kitchen stovetop, in the oven, on the grill, and even over a campfire.

Cast iron pans have better heat retention

Cast iron pans are renowned for their heat retention. Their ability to retain heat for long periods makes them ideal for cooking techniques that require sustained heat, such as pan-frying, roasting, braising, baking, and shallow or deep frying. This characteristic is due to cast iron's high volumetric heat capacity, which allows it to stay hot for extended periods.

The superior heat retention of cast iron pans is attributed to their heavy-bottomed construction, which takes longer to heat up and respond to temperature changes. While this may be a disadvantage when quick heat is required, it becomes an advantage when cooking dishes that demand consistent and prolonged heat.

Additionally, cast iron pans have a high emissivity rating, which means they effectively expel heat energy from their surface in the form of radiation. This high emissivity ensures that not only the surface of the food in contact with the pan is heated but also a significant portion of food above it. This attribute makes cast iron pans ideal for cooking techniques like making hash or pan-roasting chicken and vegetables.

Cast iron pans are also versatile in terms of compatibility with heat sources. They can be used on various cooktops, including electric, induction, and gas stoves, as well as gas grills, charcoal grills, and campfires. Their ability to withstand high temperatures (up to 650˚ F) makes them a versatile option for almost any heat source.

Furthermore, cast iron pans are highly durable and virtually indestructible. Their thickness and weight contribute to their exceptional heat retention capabilities, making them a preferred choice for cooks who require sustained and consistent heat for their culinary creations.

In summary, cast iron pans are valued for their exceptional heat retention, which is essential for specific cooking techniques and heat sources. Their heavy-bottomed construction, high emissivity, durability, and compatibility with various heat sources make them a preferred choice for cooks seeking sustained and even heat distribution.

Carbon steel pans have a smooth surface, ideal for sautéing

Carbon steel pans are a popular choice for professional chefs. They are lighter and less brittle than cast iron, with a smoother surface that is ideal for sautéing. This is because carbon steel pans heat up more quickly and evenly than cast iron, with fewer hot spots. They are also more responsive to changes in temperature, making them perfect for sautéing vegetables or preparing fish.

The smooth surface of carbon steel pans also makes them ideal for cooking eggs, omelettes, and crepes. The combination of the smooth surface and seasoning is what makes carbon steel so slippery. In addition, carbon steel pans are lighter than cast iron, making them easier to manoeuvre and better suited for sautéing.

Carbon steel pans are made from a combination of approximately 99% iron and 1% carbon. They are designed for high-heat cooking and are oven-safe up to 1200°F, making them ideal for grilling, searing, and charring. They are also capable of reaching temperatures high enough to thoroughly sear meat and can be used on the stovetop, in the oven, and on the grill.

Like cast iron, carbon steel requires seasoning to upkeep its naturally non-stick patina. However, carbon steel pans usually need to be seasoned by the user following the manufacturer's instructions, whereas cast iron pans often come pre-seasoned.

Carbon steel pans are more expensive

Carbon steel pans are generally lighter and thinner than cast iron pans, which affects their performance. Carbon steel pans heat up and cool down much faster than cast iron, making them ideal for cooking delicate foods such as eggs, omelettes, crepes, and fish. The smooth surface of carbon steel pans also makes them perfect for sautéing vegetables. However, carbon steel pans are more reactive than cast iron, so they can undergo a chemical change when they come into contact with acidic ingredients like tomatoes or wine. This means that carbon steel pans require more careful maintenance, including regular seasoning, to upkeep their non-stick patina.

Despite being more expensive and requiring more maintenance, carbon steel pans are a popular choice among chefs and home cooks due to their lightweight, durable properties, quick heat response, and non-stick cooking surface. They are also versatile and can be used on any heat source, including induction cooktops, as well as in the oven and on the grill.

Frequently asked questions