The Truth About Cast Iron: Coated Or Not?

Cast iron pans are a common feature in many kitchens, but there are a lot of misconceptions about how to use and care for them. One common question is whether cast iron pans are coated. The answer is that it depends. Some cast iron pans are coated with enamel, while others are pre-seasoned with a non-stick film made of polymerised fats. This coating gets better and more non-stick with use and proper care. Wagner skillets, for example, typically come with a coating to prevent rusting, which wears off over time and is replaced by proper seasoning.

Cast iron pans are not coated in the same way as non-stick pans

The process of seasoning a cast iron pan involves applying a thin layer of oil or fat to the surface and heating it repeatedly. This causes the oil to break down and polymerize, bonding to the metal and creating a non-stick coating. While this coating may not be as slick as Teflon, it is still effective at preventing food from sticking and can improve with use and proper care.

One of the main advantages of cast iron pans is their durability. Unlike non-stick pans, which can be easily scratched or damaged with metal utensils, cast iron pans are tough and long-lasting. With proper care, a cast iron pan can last for decades. Additionally, cast iron pans can withstand higher temperatures than non-stick pans, making them suitable for a wider range of cooking techniques.

Another difference between the two types of pans is their heat distribution properties. Cast iron pans have a high volumetric heat capacity, which means they retain heat well and are excellent for searing and frying. However, they do not distribute heat evenly, and hot spots can form on the pan's surface. Non-stick pans, on the other hand, typically have better heat distribution due to the material's higher thermal conductivity.

In terms of safety, there have been concerns about the potential health risks associated with non-stick coatings like Teflon. While modern non-stick pans are PFOA-free, there are still questions about the safety of other substances used in their manufacturing. Cast iron pans, on the other hand, are generally considered safe, although they can leach small amounts of iron into food, which may be beneficial for those with iron deficiencies.

Cast iron pans are not delicate

Cast iron pans are made of iron, which is virtually indestructible. They are highly durable and can withstand very high cooking temperatures. They are also excellent at retaining heat, which makes them ideal for long-cooking stews or braised dishes.

While cast iron pans do require seasoning to protect them from rust and create a non-stick surface, they are not as fragile as some may believe. You can wash a cast iron pan with soap and even scrub it with the rougher side of a sponge if needed. Just be sure to dry it completely afterward and rub it with a small amount of oil.

If something is really stuck to your cast iron pan, you can soak it in water and then scrub it. The key is to avoid using anything too abrasive, as this could damage the surface. It's also important to avoid letting the pan sit wet for too long, as this can lead to rust.

While it's best to avoid cooking acidic ingredients in cast iron pans for extended periods, a quick exposure to something acidic is not a problem. The food is not coming into direct contact with the cast iron but rather the polymerized, plastic-like layer created by the seasoning process.

So, while cast iron pans do require some care and maintenance, they are not delicate. With proper use and cleaning, they can last for generations.

You can use soap on cast iron

There are a lot of misconceptions about cast iron pans, and one of the most common is that you shouldn't use soap to wash them. This is because, historically, soaps were made with lye or borax, which would strip the seasoning and damage the pan. However, this is no longer the case. While you don't need to use soap, it won't ruin your pan. In fact, it's perfectly fine to wash cast iron with soap these days. Modern dish soap is much milder and won't affect the non-stick coating.

If you're still hesitant, you can always use other methods to clean your cast iron. For example, you can fill your pan with hot water and let it simmer to release any stuck-on food. You can also use a chainmail scrubber, salt, steel wool, or crumpled aluminium foil to scrub your pan. Just be sure to dry it thoroughly and apply a thin layer of oil after washing to prevent rust.

If you do decide to use soap, simply pour a small amount into the pan, add some warm water, and use a nylon brush or sponge to clean the pan, inside and out. Then, dry the pan with a paper towel or tea towel, and place it back on the stove over medium heat for about three to five minutes. Let the pan cool completely, then rub a light layer of cooking oil on the surface and wipe away any excess.

So, whether you use soap or not, the most important thing is to keep your cast iron pan clean, dry, and seasoned to prevent rust and maintain its non-stick properties.

You can cook acidic foods in cast iron

When cooking acidic foods in cast iron, it is best to avoid long simmering times. Acidic ingredients such as tomatoes, citrus juices, and wine can be used in cast iron, but they should not be left in the pan for more than 30 minutes to an hour. The longer the acidic food is in contact with the pan, the higher the risk of unwanted flavours and damage to the seasoning. Therefore, it is recommended to use cast iron for quick-cooking acidic dishes and to opt for enameled cast iron or a different type of pan for longer-simmering acidic recipes.

Additionally, it is important to clean and dry your cast-iron pan promptly after cooking acidic foods. Proper cleaning and drying will help prevent rust and maintain the seasoning. A well-maintained cast-iron pan can be used for a variety of dishes and will provide excellent heat retention and durability.

In summary, while you can cook acidic foods in cast iron, it is crucial to follow certain guidelines to ensure the best results and protect your cookware. A well-seasoned pan, brief cooking times for acidic ingredients, and prompt cleaning and drying will allow you to take advantage of the benefits of cast iron while minimizing any potential drawbacks.

You can use regular utensils on cast iron

Cast iron pans are valued for their heat retention, durability, and ability to maintain high temperatures for longer. They are also prized for their non-stick cooking capabilities when properly seasoned and cared for.

There is a common misconception that cast iron pans are delicate and that you should avoid using metal utensils on them. However, this is a myth. Cast iron pans are incredibly durable, and the seasoning is resilient and chemically bonded to the metal. Unless you are gouging out the surface of the metal, using regular utensils will not damage your cast iron pan.

The seasoning on a cast-iron pan is a layer of polymerized oil, achieved by rubbing oil into the pan and heating it repeatedly. This process creates a plastic-like substance that bonds to the surface of the metal, giving the pan its non-stick properties. The seasoning is not a thin layer of oil that can be easily removed by soap or scrubbed away with a sponge. In fact, it is sturdy enough to withstand the use of metal utensils.

That being said, there are some metal tools that are better suited for cast iron than others. For example, a slotted turner is ideal for gently scraping food residue off the cooking surface before cleaning. A solid, non-slotted turner is perfect for smash burgers or other dishes where you need to apply firm downward pressure. Metal tongs are also useful for cooking larger proteins, such as steaks or chops, as they provide a strong grip for flipping and transferring food.

While it is safe to use metal utensils on cast iron, there are some tools and techniques you should avoid. Highly abrasive cleaning tools like steel wool can remove the seasoning and even damage the underlying cast iron. Metal spoons and spatulas can also cause trouble if used for chopping or scooping food near the side walls of the pan. In these cases, wooden utensils are the better option.

In conclusion, cast iron pans are durable and resilient, and regular utensils will not harm the seasoning or the pan itself. Proper maintenance, including regular cleaning and re-seasoning, will ensure that your cast iron cookware remains in top condition for years to come.

Frequently asked questions