Non-Stick Pan Splurge: Worth The Money?

Non-stick pans are a handy tool to have in the kitchen, but are the expensive ones worth it? Non-stick pans are convenient for cooking sticky foods like eggs and pancakes, and for searing fish without worrying about it sticking to the pan. However, non-stick pans have a short lifespan and will need to be replaced every few years. This is because the non-stick coating will eventually wear off, and the pan will lose its non-stick qualities. Therefore, it is recommended to buy cheaper non-stick pans and replace them as needed.

Non-stick pans are disposable by design

Non-stick pans are best when they are brand new. Age is the true test of value. The surface on a brand-new non-stick pan is the slickest it will ever be before it makes the slow march toward ineffectiveness through use and wear. Even with proper care, any non-stick skillet has a shorter lifespan than other cookware because the non-stick coating will inevitably wear off.

Non-stick pans are notorious for their short lifespans. They are prone to losing their non-stick qualities more quickly and more thoroughly than standard PFOA-free pans. Ceramic non-stick surfaces, in particular, are not known for their longevity, with the non-stick qualities of the sol-gel surface degrading with each use.

Non-stick pans are also prone to scratching and chipping. Teflon can easily be nicked, chipped, or scratched. And once that happens, the non-stick qualities are compromised. These pans are also sensitive to heat—if you heat them above 500ºF, the molecules can start to break down and release harmful gases.

Because of their short lifespans, it is not worth spending a fortune on a single non-stick skillet. A good non-stick pan should not cost more than $60 or $70.

Non-stick pans are not an irreplaceable piece of cookware

Non-stick pans have a coating that eventually wears off, and the pans need to be replaced. This is because the non-stick coating can get scratched or chipped, compromising its non-stick properties. The coating can also start to fade and break down over time, even with proper care and use. Therefore, it is recommended to replace non-stick pans every few years, or when food starts to stick to the surface.

There are also some safety concerns associated with non-stick pans. The coatings used on non-stick pans contain chemicals that can be harmful to human health and the environment. While these chemicals are no longer used in the manufacturing process, they may still be present in older non-stick pans. Additionally, if non-stick pans are overheated, they can release harmful gases. Therefore, it is important to use non-stick pans properly and replace them regularly to minimise any potential health risks.

In conclusion, non-stick pans can be a convenient tool for cooking certain types of food, but they are not an essential piece of cookware. They have a short lifespan and need to be replaced frequently, and there are alternative options available that may be more durable and safer. Therefore, it is not necessary to invest in expensive non-stick pans, as they are ultimately disposable items.

Non-stick pans are safe to use

It is important to note that PTFE coatings can break down if heated above 500°F (260°C), releasing harmful gases. Therefore, non-stick pans should not be heated above 400°F (204°C). Additionally, metal utensils should not be used with non-stick pans, as they can scratch the coating and cause it to flake into food. Instead, wooden, plastic, or silicone utensils are recommended.

To prolong the life of a non-stick pan, it is best to hand-wash and dry it before use, and then rub a small amount of vegetable oil onto the cooking surface. Non-stick pans should also be washed by hand, as the harsh soaps and high temperature and pressure of dishwashers can damage the coating. It is also important to avoid stacking pans when storing them, as this can scratch the coating.

Non-stick pans are not long-lasting

Non-stick pans are coated with polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), commonly known as Teflon. The coating can easily be nicked, chipped, or scratched, and once that happens, the non-stick qualities are compromised. These qualities also begin to fade with use. You'll begin to notice changes, and once food begins to stick, either in scratches or to the whole pan, it's time to toss it and get a new one.

Non-stick pans typically last between one and five years. Pans with multi-layer PTFE coating or reinforced non-stick coating last the longest. In general, the more layers of non-stick coating, the more resistant the cookware is to scratching, and the longer it will last. The extra layers of coating prevent minor scratches from degrading the cooking surface and exposing the bare aluminum base.

There are ways to extend the lifespan of your non-stick pans. For example, avoid metal utensils and drastic temperature changes, and don't put your non-stick pans in the dishwasher. However, despite your best efforts, the non-stick coating will eventually wear off, and you will need to replace your non-stick pan.

Non-stick pans are not worth the cost

Non-stick pans are also disposable by design, which is why it is suggested to think twice before buying an expensive non-stick pan. The point of this cookware is its non-stick quality. When that quality is gone, there's no point in keeping it. You can spend a fortune on higher-end non-stick cookware, and it may last a bit longer. But not a lot. It will eventually scratch and chip and lose its qualities just like the cheap ones, and you’ll still need to replace it frequently enough.

Non-stick pans are also not safe. While non-stick and Teflon are safe to use, the answer was not always the case. The harmful chemical previously used in Teflon non-stick coating, PFOA, is banned in the US and was phased out in 2014. The caveat is if you're still using a non-stick skillet made and sold before 2014, it might be time to chuck it and bag a new one.

Non-stick pans are also not easy to maintain. You should never use metal on non-stick skillets since they will scrape and scratch the coating and cause the skillet to lose its non-stick surface much faster. Non-stick cooking spray is also not recommended for PTFE-coated pans. It can lead to a filmy buildup over time. You should also never use high heat when cooking with your non-stick skillet. Scorching temperatures will damage the sensitive non-stick surface. Always hand-wash your non-stick pan. Some skillets are technically "dishwasher-safe", but exposing them to that much hot water and soap for long periods will erode the non-stick surface over time. Plus, quality non-stick pans generally don't take more than a few soft wipes with a wet sponge and hot water to get clean.

In conclusion, non-stick pans are not worth the cost. They are not built to last, are not safe, and are not easy to maintain.

Frequently asked questions