Griswold Pans: Old Vs New, Which Is Better?

are new griswald pans as good as the old ones

Griswold cast iron pans are highly sought after by collectors and cooks alike. The vintage pans are known for their smooth surfaces, with some claiming that the older pans are of better quality than newer versions. The heritage and history of the Griswold company also add to the appeal of their cookware, which includes skillets, griddles, Dutch ovens, and gem pans. While some prefer the newer pans for their lighter weight, others appreciate the unique characteristics and performance of the vintage Griswold pans.

Characteristics Values
Vintage appeal Nostalgic, heritage and history of the company, unique
Smooth cooking surface Holds seasoning better, perfect for searing steak
Weight Heavier than modern pans, dense
Price Affordable, especially for smooth-bottomed skillets
Quality No significant decline in quality over time

cycookery

The heritage and history of Griswold pans

Griswold Manufacturing was an American manufacturer of cast-iron kitchen products, founded in Erie, Pennsylvania, in 1865. The company was in business until 1957 and had a worldwide reputation for its high-quality cast-iron cookware.

The company was founded by Matthew Griswold and his cousins, the Selden brothers, J.C. and Samuel Selden. Initially, the company was called the Seldon-Griswold Manufacturing Company, and it produced light hardware products such as separable butt hinges, stovepipe dampers, and thimbles. In the 1870s, Griswold began manufacturing skillets, pots, grinding mills, and waffle irons. The company was then renamed the Selden & Griswold Manufacturing Company in 1873.

Over the years, Griswold expanded its product line to include a variety of cookware, such as Dutch ovens, roasters, griddles, gem pans, muffin pans, and waffle irons. They also produced enameled cast iron and electrical items. The company gained a reputation for quality, and its products were sold worldwide.

Griswold's cast-iron cookware is known for its distinctive brand markings and logos, which have evolved over time. The company's first trademark, known as the "'Griswold's Erie Diamond," appeared on a few pieces in the 1880s. The iconic "slant logo," which featured a slanted, italicized "Griswold" at the centre of a cross, was introduced in the early 1900s and continued into the 1920s. This logo is considered one of the best representations of Griswold-made iron. The logo was modified several times, with the lettering style changing to block lettering in the 1920s and the overall weight of the logo becoming bolder. In the 1930s, the logo was reduced in size, and inscriptions like "CAST IRON SKILLET" were eliminated. During the early 1940s, Griswold changed its logo again to a much smaller size, known as the "small logo" Griswold.

Today, Griswold pieces are highly sought-after by collectors, who appreciate the age, quality, and distinctive brand markings of these items. The history and heritage of the company, as well as the unique characteristics of its cast-iron cookware, contribute to the appeal and value of Griswold pans.

cycookery

The appeal of vintage Griswold pans

Heritage and History

Griswold, as a company, has a rich history, and its vintage pans embody this legacy. The brand is associated with a range of cookware, including skillets, griddles, Dutch ovens, and gem pans. The older pans, especially those with early logos, are coveted by collectors and enthusiasts.

Smooth Cooking Surfaces

Vintage Griswold pans are known for their exceptionally smooth cooking surfaces, which are often smoother than those of newer cast iron pans from other manufacturers. This smoothness is a desirable trait and contributes to their appeal.

Performance and Characteristics

Vintage Griswold cast iron offers a unique blend of cast iron and carbon steel qualities. They are thinner than modern pans, making them excellent for searing steak. Additionally, they hold seasoning well and are less prone to warping compared to other vintage cast iron pieces.

Nostalgia and Collectibility

There is a sense of nostalgia associated with vintage Griswold pans. Many cooks are drawn to the idea of using the same smooth cast iron pans their grandmothers might have used. The collectibility of Griswold pans is also a factor, with some pieces being very old, unique, or in excellent condition, making them highly sought-after by collectors.

Uniqueness and Variation

Vintage Griswold pans exhibit a ton of variation, with each pan having distinct quirks and traits. This uniqueness adds to their charm and makes them stand out in a cook's arsenal.

Linking PAN with Aadhaar: Free or Fee?

You may want to see also

cycookery

The quality of Griswold pans over time

Griswold cast iron pans are known for their quality, which has attracted many collectors. The company's heritage and history are also a draw for buyers. Vintage Griswold pans are sought-after items, with their very smooth surfaces being a unique selling point compared to other brands.

Some people claim that newer Griswold pans are not as good as the old ones. However, others disagree, stating that they have not noticed a decline in quality over time. In fact, some of the newer Griswold pans with small logos are still considered great for cooking and can be purchased at a bargain.

Griswold pans have a long history, with the company producing skillets, griddles, Dutch ovens, and gem pans. The vintage pans, especially those with early logos, are considered a good entry point for those interested in vintage ironware. These older pans are known for their smooth surfaces, which can be a result of the manufacturing process of the time.

Over time, Griswold pans have had some variations in their designs. For example, the smooth-bottomed skillets with the large Griswold slant logo were produced between 1939 and 1944. More recently, the addition of "U S A" to the logo is believed to have occurred in the 1960s. Despite these changes, the quality of Griswold pans has remained consistent for many collectors.

Overall, the quality of Griswold pans has stood the test of time, with many collectors seeking out both older and newer pieces for their unique features and cooking capabilities.

cycookery

The design and manufacturing of Griswold pans

Griswold Manufacturing was an American manufacturer of cast-iron kitchen products, founded in Erie, Pennsylvania, in 1865 by Matthew Griswold and his cousins, the Selden brothers. Initially, the company produced door hinges and hardware, but they soon expanded their product line to include skillets, pots, grinding mills, and waffle irons. The company was renamed the Selden & Griswold Manufacturing Company in 1873.

Over the years, Griswold added a variety of products to their lineup, including kettles, Dutch ovens, roasters, and various other pots and pans. They became well-known for their high-quality cast-iron cookware, which was sold worldwide. The company also acquired many patents, with one of their earliest and most successful products being the cast-iron stovetop waffle iron, manufactured into the 1930s.

The design of Griswold pans evolved over time, with the company using different logos throughout its history. The distinctive "Griswold cross" logo was first used in the 1910s, with a slanted, italicized "Griswold" name at the centre. In the 1920s, the logo was changed to block lettering, and in the early 1940s, it was modified again to a much smaller size, known as the "small logo" Griswold.

The manufacturing process for Griswold pans involved established casting techniques, with each piece featuring the Griswold logo and manufacturing details. Griswold pans were known for their smooth cooking surfaces, and the company's early pans were also noted for being thinner and having a smoother surface compared to other cast iron pans.

Today, Griswold pans are considered collectors' items, with their history and quality being sought after by vintage cookware enthusiasts. The age and quality of Griswold pans, particularly those with the "Griswold cross" logo, make them desirable among collectors, often commanding high prices at antique malls and fairs.

cycookery

The variations in Griswold pans

Griswold pans are a popular vintage cast iron cookware option. The company manufactured a full range of cookware, including skillets, griddles, Dutch ovens, and gem pans. Griswold pans are known for their heritage and history, with the brand being one of the best vintage options for those looking to start collecting cast iron.

One of the main variations in Griswold pans is the logo. The logo on a Griswold pan can indicate the date of manufacture, with some logos being more sought-after by collectors than others. For example, the Griswold small logo is less collectible than other logos, making these pans more affordable. On the other hand, skillets with the large Griswold Slant logo, manufactured between 1939 and 1944, are highly prized. Smooth-bottomed skillets with a block logo are also popular and often priced similarly to other vintage pans.

Another variation in Griswold pans is their weight. Some Griswold pans are known for being extremely heavy, which can make them cumbersome to work with. However, this weight can also be advantageous for certain cooking techniques, such as searing steak. Thinner Griswold pans are also available and are preferred by some cooks.

The condition of Griswold pans can vary significantly, with some being in excellent condition while others may have warping, pitting, or other signs of wear. The cooking surface of a Griswold pan is an important consideration, with vintage pans known for having smoother surfaces compared to newer cast iron options.

Overall, the variations in Griswold pans include the logo, weight, condition, and cooking surface. These factors can influence the price, performance, and desirability of a Griswold pan for collectors and cooks alike.

Frequently asked questions

Griswold pans are sought-after vintage items, with some arguing that older pans are of better quality. However, there is no concrete evidence that newer Griswold pans are of lesser quality, and the company's heritage and history remain appealing to collectors.

Vintage Griswold pans are known for their smooth surfaces, which newer pans may not have. Older pans are also thinner and lighter, making them easier to handle.

Newer Griswold pans may be more accessible and affordable for those who are new to vintage cast iron cookware. They can also be a good option for those who prefer a textured surface, as some newer pans have a less smooth finish.

When collecting vintage Griswold pans, it's important to do your research and identify the age and authenticity of the pan. Look for logos, markings, and variations to determine the approximate date of manufacture. You can also find vintage Griswold pans at yard sales and thrift stores, but be aware of reproductions and counterfeits.

Yes, there are newer companies like Butterpat, Finex, Field, and Smithey that offer premium cast iron cookware. These modern options may even be priced higher than common Griswold pans, but they provide a similar cooking experience to vintage cast iron.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment