Pano Sunroofs: Crash Safety Risk?

Pano sunroofs have become a common feature in modern cars, but are they less safe in a crash? While it's natural to assume that a large glass window in the roof would make a car less safe, government crash tests have shown that the effect of a sunroof is insignificant to the overall strength of the roof. In fact, it's the car's steel frame that keeps occupants safe in a rollover crash, not the roof itself.

Government crash tests show that sunroofs have an insignificant effect on the overall strength of the roof

While it may seem counterintuitive, government crash tests have shown that sunroofs have no significant effect on the overall strength of a car's roof in the event of a crash. This is because the structure of a car consists of a strong steel frame wrapped by relatively thin metal panels. In a crash, it is the high-strength steel used in the pillars (called A, B, C, and D pillars, based on their location) that absorbs the energy, not the centre of the roof.

The steel frame is what keeps you safe in a rollover crash, not necessarily the roof itself. These pillars are made from ultra-high-strength steel and do an excellent job of absorbing any forces applied to the roof. Smaller lateral strengthening beams also span the car's roof for added structural integrity, but they have to deal with very little force due to the dissipation to the main pillars. It is between these beams that a sunroof sits, replacing what would be sheet metal with a pane of retractable glass.

With this in mind, a sunroof has no tangible effect on the structural rigidity or strength of a car, even during a rollover. The pillars and beams absorb almost all of the forces induced during a roll, so the stiffness of a car is not affected by a sunroof.

That said, glass is less strong than metals like aluminium or steel. Glass has a small Young's Modulus of 65 GPa, while steel has a much stronger Young's Modulus of 200 GPa. This means that a glass section absorbs less energy before it fractures compared to a metal section.

However, car manufacturers take steps to ensure that sunroofs do not compromise the structural integrity of the car. They use specially crafted laminated glass, which is designed to resist shattering upon impact, delivering a degree of protection in the event of an accident. Laminated glass uses two panes of glass that are fused together by a sheet of plastic, ensuring that the glass stays intact when shattered and reducing the risk of passengers being ejected from the car.

The steel frame of a car is what keeps you safe, not the roof itself

When it comes to car safety, the structural integrity of the vehicle is paramount. While the roof of a car may seem like an important protective barrier, it is, in fact, the steel frame that provides the most crucial support in the event of a collision. This steel frame is wrapped by thin metal panels, which form the exterior of the car.

The steel frame of a car is designed to absorb and distribute the impact energy during a crash. Specifically, the high-strength steel pillars (called A, B, C, and D pillars) that hold up the roof play a critical role in crash safety. These pillars are strategically positioned at different locations within the car and act as crucial load-bearing structures, ensuring that the force of impact is directed away from the occupants and absorbed by the frame. This transfer of kinetic energy from the passengers to the frame significantly reduces the risk of injury or fatality.

In contrast, the roof itself, whether it has a sunroof or not, plays a relatively minor role in crash safety. Government crash tests have revealed that the presence of a sunroof has an insignificant effect on the overall strength of the roof. This finding underscores that it is the underlying steel frame, rather than the roof itself, that provides the critical support and protection during a collision.

It is important to note that modern vehicles undergo rigorous testing to meet stringent federal safety standards. Engineers employ stringent performance standards and testing protocols to ensure that vehicles offer adequate protection in various crash scenarios. The government also conducts crash tests to identify structural weaknesses and ensure that all production vehicles provide the required level of safety.

In summary, while the roof of a car may provide a sense of security, it is the steel frame that truly keeps occupants safe in the event of a crash. The steel pillars absorb the impact energy, protecting the passengers and reducing potential harm. Therefore, when assessing the safety of a vehicle, it is essential to focus on the strength and integrity of its steel frame rather than solely on the roof's composition.

Laminated glass is used in sunroofs to prevent shattering and reduce the risk of passenger ejection

Laminated glass is a type of safety glass designed to hold its form even when shattered. It consists of two panes of glass fused together by a sheet of plastic. This design ensures that the glass stays intact when it breaks, reducing the risk of passengers being ejected from the car in the event of a crash.

Laminated glass is commonly used in windshields and is now being used by some automakers in sunroofs as well. While tempered glass, which is used in side and rear windows, is safer than regular windowpane glass as it breaks into small pieces rather than shards, it can still explode suddenly, causing thousands of pieces of glass to rain down at once.

Laminated glass in sunroofs helps to prevent shattering and reduce the risk of passenger ejection in the event of a crash. It provides superior protection in rollover situations, as it is less likely to shatter than tempered glass. This is especially important as studies have shown that a greater number of passengers are ejected through the sunroof or moonroof compared to side windows during a rollover.

Some automakers, such as Tesla and Volvo, use laminated glass in all their sunroofs, while others use it in only some models. It is recommended that consumers research the type of glass used in a vehicle's sunroof before purchasing and, when possible, choose a vehicle with laminated glass for added safety.

In addition to laminated glass, other safety features of sunroofs and moonroofs include tempered glass, anti-pinch technology, rain sensors, wind deflectors, manual operation, UV-blocking glass, reinforced frames, pinch protection, and child locks. These features work together to provide a balance between enjoyment and protection for drivers and passengers.

Seat belts are the most effective way to prevent ejection from a vehicle during a crash

While panoramic sunroofs may raise safety concerns, they are stronger than you might think. Crash test results have shown that sunroofs have an insignificant effect on the overall strength of the roof. In fact, it is the car's steel frame that keeps occupants safe in a rollover crash.

That being said, passenger ejection is a very real danger during a crash. The most important thing you can do to prevent being ejected from a vehicle is to ensure that you and all passengers are wearing a seat belt. Data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) shows that unbelted occupants are up to 10 times more likely to be ejected from a vehicle during a crash.

Seat belts are the most effective way to prevent ejection from a vehicle and keep people from colliding with the interior during a crash. They are designed to manage forces on the body and spread crash forces across the stronger bony parts of the body, including the shoulder, rib cage, and pelvis. Worn properly, seat belts can also prevent serious injuries to the shoulder and chest area.

Seat belts also reduce the risk of fatal injury. For drivers and front-seat passengers, using a lap and shoulder belt reduces the risk of fatal injury by 45% in a car and by 60% in an SUV, van, or pickup. In the center rear seat, lap and shoulder belts reduce the risk of fatal injury by 58% in cars and 75% in SUVs, vans, and pickups.

The benefits of seat belts are clear. Seat belts saved an estimated 14,955 lives in 2017 and could have saved an additional 2,549 lives if everyone had been buckled up. Buckling up helps keep you safe and secure inside your vehicle, while not buckling up can result in being ejected from the vehicle, which is almost always deadly.

Airbags and roof-mounted airbags can also help to prevent ejection

Airbags are one of the most important safety innovations of recent decades. They are normally hidden but inflate instantly when a crash begins, providing crucial cushioning for people during a collision. Both front and side airbags save lives.

Front airbags have been required in all new passenger vehicles since the 1999 model year, and they reduce driver fatalities in frontal crashes by 29% and fatalities of front-seat passengers age 13 and older by 32%. Side airbags that protect the head reduce a car driver’s risk of death in driver-side crashes by 37% and an SUV driver’s risk by 52%.

In addition to front and side airbags, there are also rear-window curtain airbags, far-side airbags, inflatable seat belts, panoramic sunroof airbags, and more.

Side curtain airbags, for example, are designed to deploy in a rollover crash. They typically inflate within the first 10-20 milliseconds of a rollover and can remain inflated for 10 or more seconds to protect during multiple-roll crashes. They usually cover the window opening and inflate more stiffly than regular side curtain airbags to prevent ejection of the occupant.

The government doesn’t specifically require side curtain airbags, but automakers have been using them to meet a requirement that all 2018 or newer vehicles prevent occupant ejection through side windows. This is crucial because ejection greatly increases the risk of injury and fatality in a rollover crash. Seatbelt use is the most effective countermeasure against ejection, but side curtain airbags can also help to prevent it.

In 2017, Hyundai Mobis introduced the first panoramic roof curtain airbag, which is designed to prevent ejection of occupants through the sunroof during rollovers. NHTSA has identified 260 occupants ejected through sunroofs from 2000-2015, and the problem is expected to grow as panoramic sunroofs become more popular.

Anti-ejection roof airbags are another type of airbag that can help to prevent ejection. These airbags deploy due to a side impact or rollover incident and remain inflated for six seconds or more by design. They have thicker, bulging portions where protection of a seated occupant is most likely needed, and thinner sections along the length of the bag. Rescue and medical personnel need to be able to quickly and efficiently remove these airbags at a crash scene to access patients, which can be done by cutting into or puncturing any “fat” section of the airbag to release the internal gas pressure.

Overall, airbags are a crucial safety feature that can help to prevent ejection in a crash, and roof-mounted airbags are specifically designed to address the risk of ejection through windows and sunroofs. However, it's important to remember that seatbelt use is the most effective way to prevent ejection.

Frequently asked questions