Air Fryer Vs Oven: Can One Appliance Rule Them All?

Air fryers have become increasingly popular in recent years, with some people even considering getting rid of their oven altogether. But can an air fryer really replace a conventional oven?

There are several factors to consider when comparing the two appliances. Firstly, there is the difference in size – while an oven can handle multiple dishes or larger portions, an air fryer typically cooks one dish at a time. Secondly, the cooking method differs; air fryers circulate heated air to cook and crisp up food, while conventional ovens use still air or heating elements to cook. Additionally, air fryers are known for their speed and convenience, often requiring no pre-heating and producing faster results than a conventional oven.

So, while an air fryer may be perfect for those seeking convenience, speed, and crispy results, it may not offer the same versatility as a traditional oven, especially when cooking for larger groups or preparing multiple dishes.

Air fryers are faster and more energy-efficient than ovens

Air fryers are also more energy-efficient because they work faster. For example, the Ninja Speedi can cook an entire meal in less time than a conventional oven. This means that you can save money on your electricity bill by using an air fryer instead of an oven.

In addition to being faster and more energy-efficient, air fryers are also more versatile. They can be used to cook a variety of dishes, including chicken wings, cookies, and even cakes. Air fryers with multi-cooker capabilities can also steam, slow cook, and sauté.

Another advantage of air fryers is that they produce crispy results. While you can cook chips and chicken wings in a conventional oven, they won't have the same golden crunch as those made in an air fryer.

However, it's important to note that air fryers have some limitations. They are typically designed to cook one dish at a time, while ovens can handle multiple dishes or larger portions. Additionally, air fryers may not be suitable for baking delicate items or recipes that call for liquid batters.

Overall, air fryers offer a convenient, fast, and energy-efficient alternative to traditional ovens. They are perfect for small households or individuals who want to cook quick and easy meals without using a full-sized oven.

Air fryers are smaller and can usually only cook one dish at a time

One of the most obvious differences between an air fryer and an oven is size. Air fryers are smaller and can usually only cook one dish at a time, while ovens are full-sized appliances that can handle multiple dishes or larger portions.

Air fryers are countertop appliances, which means they take up valuable space in the kitchen. They are also heavier and more cumbersome to move than other countertop appliances, so they are not as easy to store in a cupboard and bring out when needed.

However, their compact size means they heat up quickly, which is one of their key benefits. Because they have a smaller cooking chamber and use an intense fan to blow heat over the food, they achieve faster results than a conventional oven. This also means they are more energy-efficient and potentially more cost-effective.

While air fryers are great for preparing one pan of food, if you're cooking multiple dishes or larger portions, you'll need to use the oven. For example, if you're cooking a large Christmas dinner for 28 people, you'll need the extra capacity of an oven.

So, if you're deciding between an air fryer and an oven, consider how much food you typically cook and how much space you have in your kitchen. If you often cook for a large group, you may be better off sticking with an oven. But if you're mostly cooking for yourself or one other person, an air fryer could be a great space-saving option that delivers speedy results.

Ovens are better for baking delicate items and recipes that call for liquid batters

Ovens with air fry capabilities are ideal for serving large amounts of food, which is helpful when serving platters of crispy hors d'oeuvres during dinner parties. They are also better for baking delicate items and recipes that call for liquid batters.

While some air fryers come with a bake option, not all ovens feature air fry capabilities. Select KitchenAid wall ovens feature Air Fry Mode, which circulates hot air around the oven cavity to help you achieve crispy results. Most even come with a dishwasher-safe air fry basket, so air can completely circulate around your food, and clean-up can be hassle-free.

Air fryers are usually limited to the convection-like air frying function, while a toaster oven or countertop oven can offer a wider range of functions such as broiling, roasting, and baking. If you're making multiple dishes or batches of food, a convection oven can help prepare them all at once.

If you're looking to bake delicate items or recipes that call for liquid batters, an oven with air fry capabilities is a better option than an air fryer. The oven's larger capacity and ability to handle multiple dishes or larger portions make it a more suitable choice for baking delicate items.

Additionally, the oven's static air environment, created by heating elements on the top and bottom of the cooking cavity, is better suited for these types of recipes. The perforated basket of an air fryer, on the other hand, exposes all sides of the food to heat, which may not be ideal for delicate bakes or liquid batters.

Air fryers are easier to clean than ovens

Air fryers are much easier to clean than ovens. The Ninja Speedi, for instance, has a removable cooking pot that can be cleaned in a dishwasher or by a quick rinse and wipe down. The Ninja Speedi can also be steam cleaned. The Ninja Foodi Dual Zone, on the other hand, has a dishwasher-safe Air Fry basket, so air can completely circulate around the food and clean-up is hassle-free.

The ease of cleaning an air fryer is one of its main selling points. One user, who would "rather do anything" than clean their oven, is "obsessed with how easy it is to clean" their air fryer. Another user says that cleaning their air fryer is a "pleasure".

The fact that air fryers are easier to clean than ovens is one of the reasons why some people prefer to use them for cooking instead of an oven. One user says that they "rarely use the oven now" and that their air fryer is "too heavy/greasy" to move around. Another user says that they "hate cleaning" their oven and that they will "never go back to using an oven again".

In addition to being easier to clean, air fryers also offer several other advantages over ovens. Air fryers are faster, more energy-efficient, and more cost-effective than ovens. They also guarantee crispy results and can be used to cook a wider range of dishes than ovens.

Air fryers are not suitable for cooking liquid dishes

If you want to cook liquid dishes, you will need to use a different appliance, such as a slow cooker, a hob, or an oven. A slow cooker cooks food at a low temperature and requires some liquid to roast, steam, braise, or simmer ingredients. An oven, on the other hand, uses heating elements at the top and bottom of the cooking cavity, leaving the air fairly static, making it better suited for baking delicate items and recipes that call for liquid batters.

Frequently asked questions