Air Fryer Vs Toaster Oven: What's The Difference?

Air fryers and toaster ovens are countertop kitchen appliances that act as mini ovens. While they are similar, there are some key differences between the two. Air fryers are small convection ovens that use a high-powered fan to circulate hot air around food in a perforated basket, resulting in crispy browned exteriors and tender juicy interiors. Toaster ovens, on the other hand, cook food using concentrated radiant heat and are good for cooking things that need to be laid flat. So, can an air fryer replace a toaster oven? The answer depends on what you're cooking or reheating. While some people find that their air fryer can do everything their toaster oven can, others prefer to have both appliances.

Air fryer toaster ovens are messier than air fryers

Additionally, air fryer toaster ovens often have larger cooking chambers, which can accommodate racks, trays, and fry baskets. The increased surface area within the chamber provides more opportunities for food particles and grease to accumulate, making it messier overall. Cleaning a larger oven is also more challenging and time-consuming than cleaning a compact air fryer basket.

Furthermore, air fryer toaster ovens may not have the same non-stick interior linings as some air fryers, making it more difficult to remove caked-on food residue. This can be especially true for models with wire fry baskets, which often require hand washing.

Another factor contributing to the messiness of air fryer toaster ovens is the need for tossing and flipping certain foods to ensure even cooking. For example, when making fries or leftovers in a toaster oven, you may need to flip them over to prevent sogginess. This additional handling of food within the oven can lead to increased mess and grease buildup.

Lastly, air fryer toaster ovens tend to be used for a wider variety of cooking tasks, including baking and roasting, which can result in more splatter and residue compared to the more targeted use of air fryers for crisping and browning foods.

Air fryer toaster ovens are larger than air fryers

The Instant Omni Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven, for example, boasts a size of 19 quarts and can fit a 4-pound chicken, six slices of bread, nine cookies, or a whole bag of French fries. Similarly, the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro, a popular choice for air fryer toaster ovens, is noted for its roomy cooking chamber.

If you're looking to cook for a large family or prepare big batches of food, the extra size of an air fryer toaster oven could be a deciding factor. They offer more versatility in terms of cooking capacity while still providing the benefits of air frying technology.

Air fryer toaster ovens are more expensive than conventional toaster ovens

Air fryer toaster ovens are designed with a basket drawer, which makes it easy to shake items while cooking to maximize crispiness on all sides. They are also equipped with a powerful fan that circulates hot air efficiently, resulting in crispier food and faster cooking times. On the other hand, conventional toaster ovens use concentrated radiant heat to cook food, which can create hot spots.

The additional features and functionality of air fryer toaster ovens come at a higher cost. They may also require preheating and take up more space than conventional toaster ovens. If you are looking for a more spacious and versatile appliance, an air fryer toaster oven could be a good choice, but it will likely come with a higher price tag.

It's important to consider your specific needs and budget when deciding between an air fryer toaster oven and a conventional toaster oven. If you require the additional functions and convenience of an air fryer toaster oven, it may be worth the extra cost. However, if you are primarily looking for a basic toaster oven for toasting and simple cooking tasks, a conventional toaster oven might be a more cost-effective option.

Air fryer toaster ovens are slower than air fryers

The larger cooking chamber of an air fryer toaster oven means that there is more space between the heating elements and the racks. This can result in longer cooking times, especially for foods that need to be toasted or browned evenly, such as toast or bagels.

Additionally, the fan in an air fryer toaster oven may not be as powerful as the one in an air fryer. A less powerful fan will result in slower cooking times, as the air is not circulated as efficiently.

The design of an air fryer toaster oven can also impact cooking times. Some models have a door that opens downwards, which can make it awkward to access the food and require more time to check on the progress of the dish.

Overall, while air fryer toaster ovens offer the convenience of combining two appliances into one, they may take longer to cook food compared to a dedicated air fryer.

Air fryer toaster ovens are not as good at making toast as toasters

While air fryer toaster ovens are versatile and can perform a wide range of cooking tasks, they are not as effective as standalone toasters when it comes to making toast. Here are a few reasons why:

• Size and Design: Air fryer toaster ovens have larger chambers than traditional toasters to accommodate their multiple functions. This extra space means that there is more distance between the heating elements and the racks, resulting in longer toasting times. Additionally, the design of the air fryer toaster oven, with its powerful fan and air circulation system, is optimised for crisping and browning foods, which may not be ideal for achieving the perfect shade of golden brown on your toast.
• Toasting Quality: In some cases, air fryer toaster ovens may struggle to produce evenly browned toast. The powerful fan and heating elements can lead to hot spots, resulting in toast that is darker in some areas and lighter in others. This issue is less common in standalone toasters, which are specifically designed for even browning.
• Convenience: Standalone toasters are typically more convenient for making toast. They are smaller, easier to use, and faster at toasting than air fryer toaster ovens. With a toaster, you can quickly pop in a slice of bread and have your toast ready in a matter of minutes, without having to deal with the bulk and complexity of an air fryer toaster oven.
• Specialisation: Standalone toasters are designed with one primary function—to toast bread products. As such, they are optimised for this task and often have specific settings for different levels of browning. Air fryer toaster ovens, on the other hand, are designed to perform multiple functions, so they may not deliver the same level of specialisation and precision when it comes to toasting.

While air fryer toaster ovens offer the convenience of multiple functions in one appliance, they may not be the best choice if you prioritise perfectly toasted bread above all else. Standalone toasters are designed specifically for that task and are generally more efficient, effective, and convenient for making toast.

Frequently asked questions