Steam Oven Vs Air Fryer: Which Is The Better Option?

Air fryers and steam ovens are two of the most popular kitchen appliances right now, but they serve different purposes. An air fryer is a small, convection oven that uses dry heat to cook food, while a steam oven uses wet heat (steam) to cook. This means that you can't 'fry' food in a steam oven, but it is possible to use a convection oven as an air fryer if you have a crisper tray.

Air fryers are dry heat, steam ovens are wet heat

Air fryers and steam ovens are fundamentally different in the way they cook food. Air fryers are small convection ovens that use dry heat, circulating hot air around the food to cook it. This produces a crispy, crunchy texture, similar to deep-fried food. Steam ovens, on the other hand, use wet heat (steam) to cook food. While a steam oven won't give you the same fried texture as an air fryer, it has its own advantages.

The dry heat of an air fryer is ideal for cooking foods you'd like to be crispy. For example, French fries, chicken wings, and bacon come out very well in an air fryer. You can also cook baked goods like calzones and cookies, as well as roast vegetables. Air fryers are also useful for cooking frozen, pre-cooked foods like chicken nuggets, tater tots, and fish sticks.

Steam ovens, on the other hand, are good for cooking foods that you want to retain moisture in. For example, they're excellent for baking bread and roasting meat. They're also good for cooking foods that require the addition of water, like certain types of bread. Steam ovens are also more versatile than air fryers, as they can be used for a wider variety of cooking methods, including broiling, grilling, baking, roasting, and steaming.

In terms of convenience, air fryers and steam ovens each have their own advantages. Air fryers are small and can be left out on the countertop, so they're very accessible. They also preheat and cook faster than conventional ovens. However, they take up counter space and can be bulky to store. Steam ovens, on the other hand, don't take up counter space and can cook larger batches of food at once.

Air fryers are compact, steam ovens are full-size

Air Fryers vs Steam Ovens

Air fryers and steam ovens are two very different appliances, each with its own advantages and drawbacks. One of the most notable differences is their size. Air fryers are typically compact and suitable for small batches of food, while steam ovens are full-size appliances that take up more counter or cabinet space.

Air fryers are designed to cook food with circulated, heated air and little-to-no oil, resulting in crispy and cooked food. They are ideal for those who want to cook smaller portions quickly and without heating up the entire kitchen. Countertop air fryers are also great for reheating food and cooking frozen ingredients. However, they may not be suitable for big-batch cooking or larger items like a whole turkey.

On the other hand, steam ovens use steam to cook food, which can be beneficial for certain types of dishes. They are full-size ovens that offer more cooking area and can be used for a variety of cooking methods, including broiling, grilling, baking, roasting, and reheating. While they may take up more space, they can be a good option for those who want to cook larger quantities or a wider variety of dishes.

When deciding between an air fryer and a steam oven, it's important to consider your specific needs and requirements. If you're looking for a compact appliance for quick, small-batch cooking, an air fryer might be a better option. However, if you need a full-size oven with more versatility and the ability to cook larger quantities, a steam oven could be the right choice.

Additionally, it's worth noting that some full-size ovens on the market now offer an air fryer setting, providing the benefits of both types of appliances in one machine. These combination ovens can be a great way to save space and money while still enjoying the convenience of air frying.

Air fryers are faster to preheat

The Typhur Dome air fryer, for example, heats up 30% faster than regular air fryers. Smaller air fryers may only need two to three minutes of preheating, while larger models may require five minutes or more.

Preheating an air fryer can speed up cooking time, enhance crispiness, and improve cooking results. It is especially beneficial for frozen ingredients, baked goods, large pieces of meat, and foods that need a crispy exterior while staying moist inside, such as chicken wings, French fries, and breaded items.

However, it is important to note that not all air fryers require preheating, and it may even be detrimental for certain foods. Thick cuts of meat, for example, may burn on the outside before cooking on the inside if placed in a preheated air fryer. In such cases, it is recommended to place the meat in the air fryer before turning it on to ensure even cooking.

Additionally, certain foods that do not require a crispy texture, such as reheating leftovers or cooking dense vegetables, may be cooked evenly without preheating the air fryer.

Therefore, while air fryers offer the convenience of faster preheating compared to conventional ovens, the decision to preheat ultimately depends on the specific food being cooked and the desired cooking results.

Air fryers are cheaper to run

Air fryers are ideal for preparing smaller amounts of food for one or two people. They heat up in half the time it takes for an oven to heat up, and often less, so you can start to see how the savings quickly add up. If you use an air fryer to replace your oven, it could pay for itself in about six months.

However, because the most efficient air fryers have a small chamber, they work best for small households. If you have a large family or regularly cook big batches of food, you’ll need to do multiple rounds of cooking in your air fryer, which could negate your energy savings.

In addition to being more energy-efficient, air fryers are also healthier than deep frying. They simulate deep frying without the use of oil, and fatty foods like bacon or chicken wings can cook in their own fat.

Air fryers are less versatile

Air fryers are a "unitasker", a term used to describe a tool that is useful for only one task. They are designed to cook small amounts of food quickly and efficiently, but their limited functionality means they are not suitable for more complex or creative cooking.

Air fryers are typically used for cooking frozen, processed foods like french fries, onion rings, chicken nuggets, and sweet potato fritters. While they can also be used to cook meat and vegetables, their small size means they are not ideal for cooking large quantities of food.

In contrast, a steam oven offers greater versatility and can be used for a wider range of cooking methods, including broiling, grilling, baking, reheating, and toasting. It is better suited for cooking fresh ingredients and encourages a healthier diet. The larger capacity of a steam oven also means you can cook larger quantities of food at once, making it a more practical option for families or those who like to cook in bulk.

Additionally, air fryers can be cumbersome to clean, especially if you are cooking messy, saucy foods. The basket-style design of air fryers can make it difficult to access all areas for cleaning, and the grease and crumbs that collect in the basket can be a hassle to deal with.

While an air fryer may be useful for those who want to cook small portions of food quickly, it is not a necessity in the kitchen. A steam oven, on the other hand, offers more versatility and can be used for a wider range of cooking tasks, making it a more valuable addition to your kitchen arsenal.

Frequently asked questions