Turkey Roasting: To Add Water Or Not?

Whether or not to add water to the roasting pan when cooking a turkey is a matter of some debate. Some sources claim that adding water can lead to spotty browning, less flavourful meat and drippings, and even cause a mess in your oven. However, others argue that adding water or stock to the pan can keep the oven moist and the turkey juicy, and is necessary to prevent drippings from burning.

You can add water to the roasting pan to prevent the turkey from drying out

While some sources advise against adding water to the roasting pan when cooking a turkey, others suggest that adding a small amount of water can help keep the turkey moist and juicy.

If you're making gravy, it's best to add about a cup of water to the roasting pan. However, keep in mind that the turkey will also release drippings as it cooks.

Adding water to the roasting pan can lead to spotty browning and may make the meat less flavorful. It can also cause the meat to separate from the bones, resulting in a less-than-ideal presentation. Additionally, the drippings may be less concentrated, affecting the taste of the gravy.

An alternative to adding water is to use a flat rack or a V-rack to lift the turkey off the bottom of the pan, allowing for better heat circulation. This method is recommended by experts like the Butterball Turkey Talk-Line and is more likely to result in a golden-brown, juicy, and flavorful turkey.

Adding water can also help with making the gravy

While it is not recommended to add water to the roasting pan when cooking a turkey, some people do it anyway to prevent the drippings from burning. However, adding water can also help with making the gravy.

When roasting a turkey, it will produce its own juices, which can be used to make gravy. However, if you add water to the roasting pan, you will end up with more liquid to make gravy with. This can be especially helpful if you are serving a large group of people and need to make a lot of gravy.

If you are making gravy, it is best to add about a cup of water to the roasting pan. This will give you more liquid to work with when making the gravy. The water will mix with the turkey drippings, creating a flavorful base for your gravy. You can then add flour and butter to thicken the mixture and season it with salt and pepper to taste.

Keep in mind that if you add water to the roasting pan, your turkey drippings will be less concentrated and flavorful. This means that your gravy may not be as tasty as it would be if you had used only turkey drippings. To compensate for this, you can extend the turkey's juices with broth or wine and add it to your gravy for extra flavor.

However, it may cause spotty browning and make the meat look underdone

While it is not recommended to add water to the bottom of the pan when roasting a turkey, doing so will not hurt as long as you cook the turkey to a safe temperature. However, adding water to the roasting pan can cause spotty browning and make the meat look underdone, even when it is fully cooked. This is due to the steam created by the water, which can also make the meat less flavorful.

To avoid spotty browning and ensure a golden-brown turkey, it is best to use the open pan, flat rack method. This method involves placing the turkey on a flat rack in a roasting pan, so it is lifted off the bottom of the pan. This allows for better heat circulation and helps to produce more even browning.

Additionally, you can cover the turkey with aluminium foil for the first two-thirds of the roasting time to prevent over-browning. Removing the foil for the last third of the cooking time will allow the skin to brown.

Another tip to achieve even browning is to brush the turkey with butter or oil and season it generously with salt and pepper before placing it in the oven. This will not only add flavour but also help keep the meat moist.

The drippings will be less concentrated and may affect the taste of the gravy

When roasting a turkey, adding water to the pan can affect the taste of the drippings and, subsequently, the gravy. The drippings are less concentrated and flavorful when water is added to the roasting pan, which can result in lackluster gravy that fails to enhance the overall taste of the dish.

The drippings collected from roasting a turkey without adding water to the pan are rich and full of flavor. These concentrated juices are essential for creating a gravy that steals the show and elevates the entire meal. By forgoing the addition of water, you allow the natural juices of the turkey to shine, resulting in a gravy that is packed with flavor and depth.

Moreover, the drippings from a water-added roasting pan tend to be less distinct in taste. The steam created by the water can dilute the flavor of the drippings, leading to a milder flavor profile. This can impact the overall taste of the gravy, making it less intense and less likely to complement the roasted turkey.

To ensure your gravy is as flavorful as possible, it is best to avoid adding water to the roasting pan. Instead, opt for the open pan, flat rack method, which allows the turkey to roast and produce its own flavorful juices. These juices can then be extended with broth or wine and added to your gravy for that extra punch of flavor.

Adding water can lead to spattering or popping during the roasting process

While roasting a turkey, adding water to the roasting pan can lead to spattering or popping during the roasting process. This happens as the turkey fat begins to melt and drip into the water. This may cause a mess in your oven that you will have to clean up later.

To avoid this, you can use a flat rack or a V-rack with a stable base to keep the turkey lifted off the bottom of the pan. If you don't have a rack, you can crush a long piece of foil into a 'rope' and form a ring, or use whole raw vegetables like carrots and celery to keep the turkey off the bottom of the pan.

Additionally, you can opt for a shallow open roasting pan, no more than 2½ -3 inches deep, and spray the turkey rack with non-stick cooking spray to prevent the turkey from sticking to the bottom of the hot pan.

By following these tips, you can avoid the spattering or popping that can occur when water is added to the roasting pan and ensure a more enjoyable and mess-free cooking experience.

Frequently asked questions