Smoking Chicken Legs: Water Pan Or No?

Smoking chicken legs is a great way to get that delicious, smoky flavour. But do you need a water pan to do it? Well, it depends. Using a water pan in your smoker can bring several benefits, including stabilizing the cooking temperature, keeping the meat moist and tender, and enhancing the smoke flavour. However, it can also prevent the skin of the chicken from getting crispy, which some people may not want. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference—if you want to experiment with different levels of moisture and crispiness, try smoking your chicken legs with and without a water pan and see which method you prefer!

Chicken legs can be smoked without brining, but brining helps the meat retain moisture and adds flavour

Brining is an important step in the smoking process as it ensures the chicken legs remain moist and flavourful. However, it is not mandatory, and chicken legs can be smoked without brining. If you want to brine your chicken, a simple brine solution can be made with water, salt, onion powder, garlic powder, and rubbed sage. The chicken legs should be submerged in this solution and left to brine for 4 to 6 hours. After brining, the chicken should be rinsed and patted dry before proceeding with the smoking process.

Smoking chicken legs without brining can result in drier meat, but there are ways to mitigate this. One way is to cook the chicken legs at a higher temperature of around 325°F and remove them from the heat just before they are fully cooked. This will help ensure juicy meat with crispy skin. Additionally, using a water pan during the smoking process can also help to regulate temperature and moisture levels, resulting in more tender and moist chicken legs.

Whether you brine or not, there are several key steps to follow when smoking chicken legs. First, it is important to preheat your smoker to a temperature of 250°F to 275°F. Then, drizzle the chicken legs with olive oil and season them generously with your preferred spice rub. Smoke the chicken legs for approximately 1.5 hours, or until they reach an internal temperature of 165°F to 175°F. If desired, you can brush the chicken legs with BBQ sauce during the last 10 degrees of cooking to add a nice glaze. Finally, allow the chicken legs to rest for a few minutes before serving.

A water pan is not necessary when cooking at high heat for a short period, like searing a steak

Water pans are used in smoking to help maintain a steady temperature, keep the meat moist, and catch juices that can be used for basting or making sauces. They are placed between the heat source and the meat, creating a moist environment that slows cooking and prevents burning.

However, a water pan is not always necessary. If you are cooking at a high heat for a short period of time, such as searing a steak, the water in the pan will rapidly boil and evaporate, providing little benefit to your meat. In this case, the water pan may be unnecessary and could even be detrimental to your desired outcome.

When deciding whether or not to use a water pan, consider the type of meat you are cooking, the desired cooking temperature and time, and the level of moisture you want in your final dish. For example, if you are cooking skin-on poultry and want crispy skin, a water pan may not be the best choice as it can prevent the skin from getting crispy.

Additionally, if you are using a kamado grill, a water pan is typically unnecessary as these grills are highly sealed and create a moist cooking environment from the evaporation of the meat alone.

In summary, while water pans can be beneficial in certain smoking scenarios, they are not always needed and can sometimes even hinder your desired results. It is important to understand the benefits and drawbacks of using a water pan to make an informed decision based on your specific cooking needs.

Water pans will add moisture to what you are smoking

Water pans also aid in temperature control. Water works best for maintaining lower temperatures due to a process known as evaporative cooling. As the water heats up and approaches boiling, it begins to evaporate, putting water vapour (or steam) into the air. Since the water temperature won't exceed 212°F before it evaporates, this evaporative cooling helps to keep the rest of the cooking chamber operating at a lower temperature.

Water also helps increase the humidity of your smoker. As water evaporates when it reaches its boiling point, it releases water vapour into the air. This water vapour, known as humidity, serves several purposes. Some of the water vapour will condense onto the meat, helping to cool it down while it cooks. The longer cook time allows for more connective tissue and fats to break down, providing a more tender and moist product. Some of the water vapour will also mix with a chemical in the smoke, which then sticks to the meat and adds even more flavour.

However, it is worth noting that water pans are not always necessary. They are not needed when cooking at high heat for a short period, like searing a steak. They may also prevent the skin of poultry from getting crispy.

A water pan is ideal when cooking at a constant, low temperature for a long period

When smoking chicken legs, a water pan is ideal when cooking at a constant, low temperature for a long period. Using a water pan is one way to create the indirect cooking surface needed for low and slow BBQ. Water helps to regulate temperature, evens out the temperature in your smoker, and increases humidity.

Water is an excellent tool for temperature control because it maintains lower temperatures through evaporative cooling. As the water heats up and approaches boiling, it begins to evaporate, putting water vapour into the air. Since the water temperature won't exceed 212°F before it evaporates, this process helps keep the rest of the cooking chamber at a lower temperature. This is especially useful for longer cooks at lower temperatures.

Water also serves as a heat sink, helping to even out the temperatures in your smoker. It takes longer to rise and fall in temperature than other materials, so your smoker will be less prone to temperature fluctuations and will be more stable. This is ideal when cooking at a constant, low temperature for a long period.

Additionally, water vapour mixes with chemicals in the smoke, which then sticks to the meat and adds flavour. The water vapour also aids in bark formation by dissolving the water-soluble ingredients in the rub, such as salt and sugar.

However, it's important to note that using a water pan is a matter of personal preference, and there are other options for creating an indirect cooking surface. Some drawbacks to using a water pan include the cleanup and the fact that water takes longer to heat up, so you'll use more charcoal.

Water pans are not necessary with kamado grills

The water pan is used to create an indirect cooking surface, aid in temperature control, even out temperatures in the smoker, and increase humidity. However, these are not necessary with kamado grills due to their design and heat/moisture retention.

Some owners use a water pan to catch the drippings of the meat, which can be reused as a sauce to tenderize the meat as it continues cooking. This is not to produce moisture or anything of that sort, but it is a valid use of a water pan.

Frequently asked questions