Pots, Pans, And Nucleation: The Science

Nucleation is the process where droplets of liquid can condense from a vapour, or bubbles of gas can form in a boiling liquid. Nucleation sites are points where phase transitions are favoured, such as the formation of a solid from a fluid. In the context of pots and pans, nucleation sites are important for boiling liquids as they provide locations for bubbles to form, which is necessary for boiling to occur. These nucleation sites can be tiny crevices or spots on the heating surface with lower wetting properties. In the absence of nucleation sites, liquids can become superheated and exceed their boiling points, which can lead to explosive boiling when the liquid is disturbed. To prevent this, it is recommended to use utensils with scratches or imperfections that can serve as nucleation sites, or to add substances like salt that provide rough surfaces for bubbles to form.

Nucleation sites and boiling water

Nucleation is the process by which bubbles of gas form in a boiling liquid. This process is necessary for boiling to occur, as without it, the vapour region would start as a very small bubble that would collapse. Nucleation sites are points where phase transitions are favoured, and in the case of boiling water, these are the points where bubbles can form and boiling can begin.

Nucleation sites are often found on the surfaces of containers, where there are tiny crevices that maintain a free gas-liquid surface, or spots with lower wetting properties. These sites can also be found on suspended particles or minute bubbles in the liquid. This is known as heterogeneous nucleation, which is much more common than homogeneous nucleation. Homogeneous nucleation occurs away from a surface and requires superheating or supercooling of the medium.

The density of nucleation sites affects the boiling temperature of a liquid. For example, water usually boils at 100 °C, but in the absence of enough nucleation sites, it can reach temperatures of up to 120 °C. This is because a large number of nucleation sites promote a lower superheat for the liquid.

To prevent superheating and the associated dangers, it is recommended to provide nucleation sites when boiling water. This can be done by using a wooden spoon or adding salt to the water. Even a strand of pasta or a small rock can provide the necessary nucleation sites to prevent superheating.

Nucleation sites and superheating

Nucleation sites are points where a phase transition is favoured, such as the formation of a solid from a fluid. Nucleation is the first step in the formation of a new thermodynamic phase or structure via self-assembly or self-organisation within a substance or mixture. In the context of pots and pans, nucleation sites are relevant to the process of boiling.

Nucleate boiling is a process where bubbles of steam nucleate at points on a metal surface, and minute concentrations of solids develop at the interface of the bubbles and water. This process is of great practical significance as it can remove enormous quantities of heat per unit time and area from a hot surface.

Nucleation can be either heterogeneous or homogeneous. Heterogeneous nucleation occurs at nucleation sites on surfaces in the system, while homogeneous nucleation occurs away from a surface. Heterogeneous nucleation is much more common than homogeneous nucleation. Heterogeneous nucleation occurs when there is a large number of nucleation sites, which promote a lower superheat for a fluid. For example, water normally boils at 100°C at normal atmospheric pressure, but if there are not enough nucleation sites, the boiling point may reach a temperature up to 120°C.

The presence of nucleation sites is important in preventing superheating. Superheating occurs when steam bubbles are unable to form, and the water temperature gets hotter than the boiling point. This can be due to the use of pure water, which lacks impurities or minerals that can act as nucleation sites. It can also be due to the use of a smooth pot or pan, which does not have any scratches or imperfections that can act as nucleation sites.

To prevent superheating, it is recommended to create nucleation sites by adding something like a wooden spoon to the water, as the rough surface will provide a place for bubbles to form. Other methods to create nucleation sites include rubbing the bottom of the pot with steel wool, adding salt to the water, or using a small rock in the pot.

Homogeneous vs heterogeneous nucleation

In the context of pots and pans, nucleation sites are the locations where bubbles can easily form. This can be on the surface of the cookware or within the liquid itself. Nucleation is the first step in the formation of a new thermodynamic phase or structure via self-organisation or self-assembly within a substance or mixture.

There are two types of nucleation: homogeneous and heterogeneous. Homogeneous nucleation occurs away from the surface of the system, while heterogeneous nucleation occurs at the surface. Heterogeneous nucleation is much more common than homogeneous nucleation. This is because heterogeneous nucleation occurs at nucleation sites, whereas homogeneous nucleation does not.

The presence of nucleation sites facilitates the formation of bubbles, which is essential for boiling liquids and preventing superheating. Superheating occurs when steam bubbles are unable to form, causing the liquid to exceed its boiling point. In the context of pots and pans, nucleation sites can be created by using certain utensils, such as wooden spoons, or by adding substances to the liquid, such as salt or oil.

Heterogeneous nucleation, which occurs at the surface of the system, has a lower free energy barrier for nucleation compared to homogeneous nucleation. This is because the surface area of the nucleus that is in contact with the surrounding fluid is reduced, which speeds up the nucleation process exponentially. In contrast, homogeneous nucleation occurs away from the surface, and the nucleus resembles a sphere with a larger surface area, leading to a higher energy barrier and a slower nucleation process.

In summary, heterogeneous nucleation occurs at the surface of the system and involves nucleation sites, while homogeneous nucleation occurs away from the surface and does not involve nucleation sites. Heterogeneous nucleation is faster and more common than homogeneous nucleation due to the reduced free energy barrier.

Nucleation sites and the Diet Coke and Mentos eruption

The Diet Coke and Mentos eruption is a well-known experiment that has been popularised by viral videos on the internet and televised demonstrations. The experiment involves dropping Mentos mints into a bottle of carbonated beverage, usually Diet Coke, resulting in a violent eruption as the beverage is expelled from the bottle. This reaction is caused by the creation of nucleation sites, which allow carbon dioxide gas to escape the liquid and form bubbles.

Nucleation sites are locations where nucleation, the formation of new crystals or particles, is most likely to occur. In the context of the Diet Coke and Mentos experiment, nucleation sites are spots on the surface of the Mentos mints where gas bubbles can form. These spots are created by the tiny bumps and imperfections on the surface of the mints. When the Mentos are dropped into the carbonated beverage, the gas bubbles escape from the liquid through these nucleation sites, leading to the rapid release of carbon dioxide and the subsequent eruption.

The number of nucleation sites on a Mentos mint is estimated to be between 50,000 and 300,000, with the entire surface of the mint containing millions of cavities that can act as nucleation sites. The physical characteristics of Mentos, such as their surface roughness, drastically reduce the activation energy required for carbon dioxide bubble formation, resulting in a very high nucleation rate. This high number of nucleation sites and the reduced activation energy allow for the rapid escape of carbon dioxide gas, leading to the impressive eruption observed in the experiment.

The Diet Coke and Mentos eruption is a physical reaction rather than a chemical one. This means that all the pieces of the reaction are present, but they are simply rearranged. The carbon dioxide gas is already present in the carbonated beverage and is released through the nucleation sites on the Mentos mints. The Mentos act as a catalyst, speeding up the process of carbon dioxide release without being consumed in the reaction.

The experiment has been modified and studied by scientists to understand the factors that affect the height of the eruption. These factors include the temperature of the beverage, the number of Mentos used, and the type of beverage. It has been found that warmer beverages result in a more energetic reaction, as the carbon dioxide gas particles have more energy and are able to escape the liquid faster. Additionally, using a larger number of Mentos provides more nucleation sites, increasing the rate of carbon dioxide release. While Diet Coke is the most commonly used beverage, other carbonated drinks can also be used, although the presence of sugar in regular sodas can slow down the reaction and reduce the height of the eruption.

Nucleation sites and the freezing of water

In thermodynamics, nucleation is the first step in the formation of a new thermodynamic phase or structure via self-assembly or self-organization within a substance or mixture. Nucleation is typically defined as the process that determines how long an observer has to wait before the new phase or self-organized structure appears. For example, if a volume of water is cooled (at atmospheric pressure) below 0 °C, it will tend to freeze into ice. However, volumes of water cooled only a few degrees below 0 °C often stay completely free of ice for long periods. This phenomenon is called supercooling. At these conditions, nucleation of ice is either slow or does not occur at all. However, at lower temperatures, nucleation is fast, and ice crystals appear after little or no delay.

Nucleation is often very sensitive to impurities in the system. These impurities may be too small to be seen by the naked eye but can still control the rate of nucleation. There are two types of nucleation: heterogeneous and homogeneous. Heterogeneous nucleation occurs at nucleation sites on surfaces in the system, for example, in the nucleation of ice from supercooled water droplets. Homogeneous nucleation occurs away from a surface and is less common than heterogeneous nucleation. For instance, purifying water to remove all or almost all impurities results in water droplets that freeze below around −35 °C, whereas water that contains impurities may freeze at −5 °C or warmer.

Pure water cooled below the freezing point can remain a supercooled liquid until it is disturbed. Striking a water bottle can provide a site for ice crystals to form, or in other words, a site for nucleation. Nucleation is a process where the molecules in a liquid start to gather into tiny clusters, arranging in a way that will define the crystal structure of the solid. The presence of nucleation sites adds more bonds formed with water molecules, allowing freezing to occur at less extreme temperatures.

In summary, nucleation sites facilitate the freezing of water by providing a surface for ice crystals to form and by increasing the number of bonds formed with water molecules, thereby enabling freezing at less extreme temperatures.

Frequently asked questions