Water In Pan: Why Bother?

Whether or not to put water in a pan depends on what you're trying to achieve. For example, when smoking meat, water in the pan controls the temperature, creates a humid environment to help smoke adhere to the meat, and enhances flavour. However, some people argue that water in the pan is unstable and doesn't work. It's important to refer to the instructions of your specific pan, as some brands explicitly state not to put water in the pan. In terms of cleaning, it's best to avoid putting a hot pan under cold running water, as this can cause thermal shock, warping, and cracking. Instead, it's recommended to let the pan cool down first and then wash it with warm, soapy water.

Water in the pan helps to control temperature and manage fire

Water in the pan is an effective way to control temperature and manage fire. This method is foolproof and helps you get a feel for your barbecue, how it works, and how to manage your fire without worrying about burnt food.

Water in the pan can also help you achieve a nice smoke ring for your turkey. It creates a humid environment within the cook chamber, helping smoke adhere to the surface of the meat and enhancing the smoky flavour. It is recommended to fill the water pan three-quarters of the way up with hot water and place it in the first stacker with a grill above it. As long as there is a healthy fire with sufficient fuel and at least an inch of water in the pan, your smoker should sit happily in the low-and-slow temperature range.

If you are using a gas or charcoal grill, adding a litre of water, beer, apple juice, or wine to the drip pan is a good idea. This helps to collect the drippings for gravy, as without a bit of water in the pan, the drippings will become crispy and unusable. If you are using a smoker, you will want to put 2-3 litres of liquid in the water pan.

Overall, water in the pan is a valuable tool for controlling temperature and fire management, enhancing the flavour of your food, and creating a humid environment for smoking meat.

Water can be used to clean a hot pan, but it can cause thermal shock and warping

Water can be used to clean a hot pan, but it's not advisable. Doing so can cause thermal shock and warping. Thermal shock occurs when different parts of an object, like a pan, expand or contract unevenly due to sudden temperature change, whether from hot to cold or cold to hot. This unexpected expansion or contraction puts strain on the object, to the point that it may crack, warp, or even shatter, depending on the object's tensile strength.

A representative from the Calphalon brand development team told HuffPost: "If a hot pan is placed under cold water, thermal shock, which can ruin a pan, may occur. By rapidly lowering the temperature of a pan, warping and cracking may occur. If warping occurs, the bottom of the pan will become uneven, and the pan will not sit evenly on the stovetop."

Philicia Frasson, product manager for All-Clad, explained the science behind thermal shock: "Metals expand in tiny amounts when they are heated, and they shrink when they are cooled. This phenomenon is called thermal expansion and thermal contraction." She noted that a 10-inch fry pan will grow to approximately 10.05 inches when heated to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, then shrink back to 10 inches when it cools to room temperature.

To avoid thermal shock and potential warping, it's best to let a hot pan cool to room temperature before washing it with cold water. This allows the pan to return to its original condition gracefully. While the warpage is sometimes temporary, with the pan returning to its original shape as it cools, repeated quenching of hot pans under cold water risks damaging the pan.

Water can be added to a hot pan to deglaze

To deglaze a pan, first cook meat or vegetables in a hot pan. Then, transfer the cooked food to another dish, leaving the fond in the pan. If there is a lot of fat in the pan, spoon it out or pour it through a strainer, returning any brown solids to the pan. Next, add a liquid such as wine, stock, or water to the pan. As a rule of thumb, use one cup of liquid for an entree serving four people. The liquid will reduce down to about half its volume, creating an intense flavour. Add the liquid slowly or in stages to keep the pan hot, which will help the fond dissolve faster.

Then, heat the liquid over medium-high heat while scraping the bottom of the pan with a wooden or rubber tool to dissolve the fond. Continue heating until the liquid is boiling and the fond has dissolved. If you are deglazing with wine or another alcoholic beverage, continue cooking until the alcohol has cooked off. You will know it is cooked off when the liquid becomes syrupy and the alcohol smell has disappeared.

Finally, pour the leftover liquid over the cooked food to add extra flavour. Alternatively, you can add aromatic ingredients such as garlic or herbs to the liquid and reduce it further to create a pan sauce.

Water in the pan is necessary for a smoke ring when cooking meat

Water in the pan is necessary to create a smoke ring when cooking meat. A smoke ring is a pink layer that sits just under the surface of the meat, and is considered an "emblem of great barbecue".

The smoke ring is caused by a chemical reaction between a protein called myoglobin, and the gases nitric oxide (NO) and carbon monoxide (CO), which are produced when wood or charcoal is burned. Myoglobin is a protein that holds oxygen in muscle cells and contains iron pigments. When NO and CO envelop the meat, they prevent the myoglobin from oxidising, keeping it a bright pink colour.

To create a smoke ring, it is important to keep the exterior of the meat moist. This can be done by spritzing the meat or using a water pan in your smoker. The moisture helps the smoke ring in several ways. Firstly, as the water evaporates from the meat's surface, it cools the meat and enhances the condensation of NO. Secondly, the water makes the surface of the meat "sticky", allowing smoke particles and flavour to adhere more easily. Finally, the moisture delays the formation of a thick bark on the meat, which can impede the absorption of smoke chemicals.

Water pans are ideal when cooking at a constant, low temperature for a long period, such as when smoking ribs, pork shoulder, brisket, or prime rib. They are not necessary when cooking at high heat for a short period, like searing a steak, or when cooking poultry with the skin on, as the moist environment can prevent the skin from becoming crispy.

When using a water pan, it is recommended to use hot water, fill the pan halfway, avoid placing fatty foods over the pan, and allow the water to cool before removing the pan.

Water in the drip pan is needed to collect drippings for gravy

When using a drip pan, it is important to start with at least a quarter-inch of liquid (water, wine, stock, or beer) to prevent the drippings from burning. You should also keep an eye on the pan to ensure it doesn't dry out and burn the drippings. It is recommended to keep the liquid at least one to two inches deep and to use hot water, as cold water will cool the oven down.

In addition to collecting drippings for gravy, a drip pan can also be used to regulate temperature. The water in the pan absorbs heat, reducing the grill temperature and levelling out fluctuations. This can be particularly useful if you are using a smoker, as it helps to keep the temperature down to the recommended 225°F. The water in the pan will never go above the boiling point of 212°F, and it takes longer for water temperature to rise and fall than air temperature, helping to stabilize the cooking temperature.

A drip pan can also be used to block direct flame when cooking with indirect heat and to even out hot spots. The water vapour mixes with combustion gases to improve flavour and condense on the meat, making it "sticky" and allowing more smoke to adhere. This enhances the flavour, and the sodium nitrite in the smoke creates the smoke ring.

Overall, using water in the drip pan is an effective way to collect drippings for gravy, regulate temperature, and improve the flavour of the food.

Frequently asked questions