Kamado Grills: Water Pan Necessity?

There are a variety of opinions on whether or not a water pan is necessary in a ceramic kamado. Some people believe that it is not necessary due to the airtight design and ceramic insulation of the kamado, which retains heat and moisture. Others find that it helps to create and retain moisture, resulting in better cooking environments and less dryness. It is also said to help with softening meat and adding a rubbery feeling to meat.

Water pans are not necessary for Kamado grills due to their airtight, ceramic design

The airtight design of the Kamado means that there is very little airflow, so adding a water pan will only extend the cooking time. The moisture created by the water pan is not necessary in the Kamado as the grill already provides a humid cooking environment. This is due to the reduced airflow through the grill, which has the opposite effect of a windy day drying out washing on a clothesline.

However, some people still choose to use a water pan with their Kamado grill. This is usually to catch drippings from the meat, which can be reused as a sauce to tenderise the meat as it continues cooking. It can also be used to prevent burnt meat and unpleasant aromas from burnt fat.

For those who want to use a water pan with their Kamado grill, it is important to ensure that the pan is placed above the heat deflectors and is large enough to sit on one end and reach the other. The temperature inside the Kamado will need to be stabilised, and it is important not to overfill the water pan.

Water pans can be used to catch drippings and prevent unpleasant aromas

Water pans are used in kamado grills to catch drippings and prevent unpleasant aromas. They are placed between the firebox and the food on the grates, acting as a barrier to eliminate direct heat, flames, and potential flare-ups caused by dripping fat. The water in the pan evaporates, creating a moist environment in the cooking chamber, which prevents the meat from drying out. This results in moister and more tender meat.

The water in the pan also helps to regulate temperature. Since water takes longer to change temperature than air, it can radiate heat upwards if the air temperature falls or absorb excess heat if the grill gets too hot. Additionally, as water boils at 212 °F, a large pan of water can keep the smoker at a low temperature even if the fire becomes too large and hot.

When deciding whether to use a water pan, it is important to consider the type of food being cooked and the cooking temperature. Water pans are ideal for cooking at a constant, low temperature for a long period, such as when smoking ribs, pork shoulder, or brisket. They are not necessary when cooking at high heat for a short period, like searing a steak, as the water will rapidly boil and evaporate. Water pans can also prevent the skin of poultry from becoming crispy, so they are not recommended when cooking chicken or turkey.

For kamado grills specifically, water pans are not necessary as these grills are already highly sealed and efficient at holding heat, resulting in a moist cooking environment. However, if you do choose to use a water pan with a kamado grill, place it below the grates on top of the heat deflectors, between the heat and the meat.

Water pans can be used to create a moist atmosphere for meats

The kamado's ceramic shell acts as a "super insulant", making it easy to maintain cooking temperatures regardless of external weather conditions. The reduced airflow within the kamado has the opposite effect of hanging laundry out on a windy day, where a breezy day quickly dries clothes. The kamado's controlled airflow keeps food moist.

Water pans are particularly useful when cooking ribs, brisket, or other large cuts of meat "hot and fast". The water pan adds moisture and protects the meat from direct heat and unintended temperature spikes. It also helps to prevent the outer bark of the meat from getting too crunchy.

However, some people choose not to use a water pan in their kamado. One reason is that the kamado is already very good at retaining moisture due to its design. The kamado's airtight seal means that moisture from the meat is trapped inside, creating a moist cooking environment without the need for a water pan.

Additionally, using a water pan can extend the cooking time, as it takes longer to bring the water up to temperature. A water pan is also unnecessary when cooking foods that benefit from dry heat, such as chicken or salmon, where a crispy skin is desired.

When using a water pan, it is recommended to use hot water, fill the pan only halfway, and avoid placing fatty foods directly over the pan, as this can prevent evaporation. Water is the only liquid recommended for the water pan, as other liquids like beer or juice do not add any flavour to the meat.

Water pans are not necessary for chicken or smoked salmon

Water pans are not necessary when cooking chicken or smoked salmon in a ceramic kamado. In fact, for chicken, a continuous dry heat is preferable to achieve crispy skin. Similarly, a drier heat is recommended when smoking salmon.

Kamado grills are highly efficient at retaining heat and moisture. Their airtight design means that there is little airflow through them, and the cooking chamber remains moist due to the evaporation of moisture from the food. Therefore, a water pan is not required to maintain moisture levels.

Additionally, kamado grills are not designed for high-heat cooking, and water pans are typically used for high-temperature cooking to prevent burning and enhance flavour.

However, some people choose to use a water pan in their kamado grill to regulate temperature. Water has a higher heat capacity than air, so it can help to stabilise temperature fluctuations. When the grill temperature rises, the water will absorb excess heat and use it for evaporation, cooling the grill. Conversely, if the temperature drops, the water will radiate heat upwards, warming the grill.

For those who want to use a water pan in their kamado grill, it is recommended to place it below the grates on top of the heat deflectors, between the heat source and the food. It is important to use only water in the pan, as other liquids will not add flavour to the food and are likely to be wasted.

Water pans can be used to prevent temperature spikes

Water pans are a common accessory for kamado grills, but their use is somewhat controversial. Some people believe that they are unnecessary and can even extend cooking times. However, others find them useful for preventing temperature spikes and adding moisture to the cooking chamber.

Water pans can indeed be used to prevent temperature spikes in kamado grills. Water boils at 212°F, so if the grill temperature rises above this, the water will start to boil, absorbing excess heat energy and preventing the temperature from rising further. This can be particularly useful when cooking thin cuts of meat, like ribs, which are more susceptible to temperature spikes.

To use a water pan for temperature control, simply fill a disposable aluminium pan with water and place it on top of the heat deflectors in your kamado. As the water boils, it will produce steam, which will also help to keep your meat moist during the cooking process.

However, it's important to note that using too much water can lead to soggy meat. To avoid this, some people recommend using a small amount of water and placing the pan between two sets of deflector plates to prevent the steam from reaching the meat directly. Additionally, make sure to use a spacer to raise the pan about an inch above the heat source to prevent direct heat transfer.

In summary, while water pans are not necessary for kamado grills, they can be a useful tool for preventing temperature spikes and adding moisture to the cooking chamber. However, it's important to use them correctly to avoid soggy meat and extended cooking times.

Frequently asked questions