Pan Size: Baking's Unsung Hero

Whether you're a novice or an expert baker, it's important to know that pan size matters when baking. Using the wrong size pan can lead to a cake that doesn't cook evenly, resulting in a thin and burnt cake or a cake that takes longer to bake and burns on the edges and top. The key to successful baking is to use the same size pan as specified in the recipe to ensure the best results.

However, there is some flexibility when it comes to pan sizes. For example, brownies, blondies, denser fruit cakes, pound cakes, and coffee cakes are forgiving and can be baked in an 8-inch or 9-inch pan without significant changes to the recipe. On the other hand, delicate sponge cakes, such as genoise or angel food, are calculated to work in specific pan shapes and sizes, and altering the pan size can lead to undesirable results.

When changing pan sizes, it's crucial to consider the volume and shape of the pan. The batter depth should remain the same as the original recipe to ensure even cooking. If the batter is shallower, the centre will dry out faster, requiring a decrease in baking time and an increase in temperature. Conversely, if the batter is deeper, the centre will be undercooked, necessitating a lower temperature and longer baking time.

Additionally, the shape of the pan can affect whether you can use all the batter. Heavier batters, such as quick breads, can fill up to 2/3 of the pan, while lighter, spongier cakes need more room to expand. It's also important to note that even a small difference in pan diameter, such as an inch, can impact the outcome.

In summary, while pan size does matter in baking, there is room for adjustments and adaptations. By understanding the principles of batter depth, volume, and shape, bakers can successfully modify recipes to suit different pan sizes and create delicious treats.

A bigger pan means a thinner cake that cooks faster

When it comes to baking cakes, the size of the pan matters a lot. A bigger pan means a thinner cake that cooks faster. If the pan is too big, the cake will be too thin and cook too quickly. The cake batter will be spread out more thinly in a larger pan, and the cake will bake faster as a result.

The baking time and temperature are calculated based on the depth of the batter in the pan. If you use a bigger pan, the batter will be shallower, and the centre will dry out faster. To compensate for this, you should decrease the baking time and raise the temperature so that the outside of the cake can brown in the shorter time.

The volume of the pan is also important to consider when changing its size. A larger pan will have a bigger volume, and the batter will spread out more. This can result in a lighter-textured cake but may also lead to a coarse feeling on the tongue.

Additionally, the shape of the pan can affect whether you can use all the batter or not. Heavier batters, such as those for quick breads, can come up to 2/3 of the way in the pan, but lighter, spongier cakes need more room to expand without overflowing.

When using a bigger pan, you may need to adjust the recipe as well. Depending on whether your layer of batter is shorter or taller, you may need to reduce or increase the baking time. Cupcakes and muffins, for example, might be done in as little as half the time as their larger counterparts.

A smaller pan means a thicker cake that cooks slower

If you're using a smaller pan, you'll need to lower the temperature and increase the baking time. The exact amount of change will depend on how much the depth of the batter has changed. For example, if a recipe calls for baking in an 8x8 pan (64 square inches) but you use a 6x6 pan (36 square inches), the batter will be twice as deep. In this case, you should lower the temperature by 25 degrees and increase the baking time by around 25%.

It's important to keep in mind that the volume of the pan matters more than the surface area when it comes to baking. This is because the baking time is designed for a specific batter thickness. If you use a smaller pan, the batter will be thicker, and it won't cook evenly. The top and edges may burn before the middle is done.

Additionally, the shape of the pan can also affect whether you can use all the batter or not. Heavier batters, such as quick breads, can fill up to 2/3 of the pan, but lighter, spongier cakes need more room to expand without overflowing.

To avoid any issues, it's best to use the pan size specified in the recipe. However, if you need to use a different size, make sure to adjust the temperature and baking time accordingly.

Volume is more important than surface area

When it comes to baking, the general consensus is that pan size does matter. However, it is important to note that not all baked goods are equally affected by alterations in pan size. Some recipes are more forgiving than others when it comes to changing the size of the pan. For example, brownies, blondies, denser fruit cakes, pound cakes, and coffee cakes can usually be baked in either an 8-inch or 9-inch pan without significant issues.

That being said, the most important consideration when changing pan size is volume, not surface area. While surface area takes into account the length and width of the pan, volume considers all three dimensions: length, width, and height. This is crucial when dealing with larger amounts of batter and pans of different heights. A taller pan with the same length and width as a shallower pan will be able to hold more batter. Therefore, if you are using a taller pan, you may need to adjust the amount of batter or use multiple pans.

Additionally, the shape of the pan can also affect the outcome of your bake. Heavier batters, such as those for quick breads, can fill up to 2/3 of the pan, while lighter, spongier cakes need more room to expand, so it is recommended to fill those pans only halfway.

If you are set on using a pan of a different volume than what the recipe calls for, you may need to scale the ingredients up or down accordingly. For example, if you are using a pan that is 1 inch larger in diameter than the recommended size, your cake will turn out thinner and may be drier. In this case, you could consider scaling up the ingredients by 25% to compensate.

It is worth noting that changing the pan size will likely affect the baking time and temperature. If you are using a larger pan with the same batter depth as the original recipe, you may not need to adjust the temperature. However, if the batter depth is shallower, the centre will dry out faster, so it is recommended to decrease the baking time and raise the temperature. On the other hand, if the batter is deeper, the centre may be undercooked, so lowering the temperature and increasing the baking time is advised.

A different-shaped pan can still work

While the general rule of baking is to follow the recipe, there is some flexibility when it comes to pan sizes. If you don't have the right size pan, you can still bake your desired recipe in a different-shaped pan, but you will need to make some adjustments to the recipe.

The most important thing to consider when changing a pan size is the volume of the pan. If you are using a pan with a different volume than the one specified in the recipe, you will need to adjust the amount of batter accordingly. You can calculate the volume of a pan by multiplying its length, width, and height.

For example, if you are using a 9-inch square pan instead of an 8-inch square pan, the volume of the 9-inch pan is 25% greater than that of the 8-inch pan. Therefore, you should scale up the ingredients by 25% to compensate for the larger pan.

In addition to adjusting the volume of batter, you may also need to adjust the baking time and temperature. If you are using a larger pan, the batter will be shallower, and the centre will dry out faster. To compensate, you should decrease the baking time and raise the temperature. On the other hand, if you are using a smaller pan, the batter will be deeper, and the centre will be underdone. In this case, you should lower the temperature and increase the baking time.

It is important to note that not all recipes are amenable to alterations in pan size. Delicate sponge cakes, such as genoise or angel food, are calculated to work in a specific shape pan for a specific amount of time to generate the desired amount of lift. Therefore, it is best to avoid changing the pan size for these types of cakes.

On the other hand, brownies, blondies, denser fruit cakes, pound cakes, and coffee cakes are all pretty forgiving when it comes to pan size. You can easily use a 9-inch pan instead of an 8-inch pan (or vice versa) for these types of recipes without making any significant adjustments.

When adapting a recipe to a different-shaped pan, it is crucial to pay attention to the shape of the pan as well. Even if the volume of the pan is the same, the shape might affect whether you can use all the batter or not. Heavier batters, such as quick breads, can come up to 2/3 of the way up the sides of a pan, while lighter, spongier cakes need more room to expand. Therefore, it is best to stick to having the pan half full for recipes with lighter batters to avoid overflow.

In summary, while it is best to follow the recipe and use the specified pan size, it is possible to bake in a different-shaped pan with some adjustments. Just be sure to consider the volume of the pan, adjust the amount of batter accordingly, and make any necessary changes to the baking time and temperature.

You may need to adjust the recipe

If you're using a different-sized pan than the one specified in the recipe, you may need to adjust the recipe. The most important thing to consider is volume. If you're using a pan with a different volume than the one specified, you may need to scale the ingredients up or down. For example, if you're using a 9-inch square pan instead of an 8-inch square pan, you may need to scale the ingredients up by 25%.

In addition to adjusting the volume of the ingredients, you may also need to adjust the baking time and temperature. If you're using a larger pan, the batter will be shallower, and the centre will dry out faster. To compensate, decrease the baking time and raise the temperature. On the other hand, if you're using a smaller pan, the batter will be deeper, and the centre will be underdone. In this case, lower the temperature and increase the baking time.

It's important to note that not all recipes are equally amenable to alterations. Delicate sponge cakes, such as genoise or angel food, are calculated to work in a specific shape pan for a specific amount of time. As a result, they may not turn out well if you change the pan size. On the other hand, brownies, blondies, denser fruit cakes, pound cakes, and coffee cakes are more forgiving and can be baked in different-sized pans with minimal adjustments.

Frequently asked questions