Steaming Vs Boiling: Which Cooks Faster?

Steaming and boiling are two different cooking methods that use water in distinct ways. Boiling involves submerging food in hot water, where it is heated by simple conduction. In steaming, food is placed above water, allowing the steam produced to cook it. Steaming is considered faster and more energy-efficient than boiling as it requires less water and leverages the excellent thermodynamic heat transfer properties of steam. The steam carries extra energy due to the latent heat of vaporization, which is released when it condenses on the cooler food surface. This results in more efficient heat transfer compared to boiling water.

Steaming requires less water

Steaming and boiling are two different cooking methods that use water in distinct ways. When steaming, a splash of water is used, and the food is cooked on all angles by the steam produced. In contrast, boiling involves totally submerging the food in a much larger amount of water.

Additionally, the reduced water usage in steaming results in less leeching of colour, nutrients, and flavour from the food into the water. This is especially relevant for vegetables like broccoli, cabbage, spinach, peas, beans, and kale, which contain water-soluble vitamins. By preserving these nutrients, steaming is considered a healthier cooking method than boiling.

The use of less water in steaming also means that there is less water to heat, resulting in greater energy efficiency. This is further enhanced by the thermodynamic heat transfer properties of steam. Steam is still at 100 °C, but it contains extra energy due to the latent heat of vaporization absorbed during the phase change from water to steam. When steam comes into contact with cooler food, it condenses, releasing this extra energy in the form of heat, resulting in more efficient cooking.

In summary, steaming requires less water than boiling, leading to reduced cooking times, improved nutrient retention, and increased energy efficiency. These advantages make steaming a popular and recommended cooking method, particularly for vegetables.

Steam is hotter than boiling water

Steam at 100°C can cause worse burns than boiling water at the same temperature because it transfers both the energy from the phase change and the additional energy it possesses as a vapour. Steam can also reach much higher temperatures than boiling water because, as a gas, it has more space to store energy.

Steaming food is often faster and more energy-efficient than boiling it because it requires less water and takes advantage of the excellent thermodynamic heat transfer properties of steam. However, the cooking time also depends on the food item's thermal conductivity and the arrangement of the cooking vessel. A closed pot used for steaming results in less heat loss during cooking compared to an open pot used for boiling.

In summary, steam is hotter than boiling water due to the additional energy it carries from the phase change, and it can reach higher temperatures because it is in a gaseous state. Steaming food is often faster and more efficient due to the superior heat transfer properties of steam and the use of less water.

Boiling dilutes the taste of food

Boiling water is a common method used to cook food, but it can have some drawbacks when compared to other cooking techniques, such as steaming. One of the main concerns with boiling is that it can dilute the taste of food. This is because, during boiling, the food is fully submerged in water, which can cause osmosis between the cells of the food and the water. As a result, the food absorbs some of the water, and the water also absorbs some of the flavourful components from the food. This can lead to a loss of flavour and nutrients in the cooked dish.

When boiling food, especially for extended periods, there is a risk of overcooking, which can further contribute to the dilution of flavours. This is because prolonged boiling can cause the food to release more of its flavourful components into the water, resulting in asection of the food's natural taste. Additionally, boiling can make the broth or stock cloudy by mixing all the precipitates, which may not be aesthetically pleasing.

In contrast, steaming is a gentler cooking method that uses steam to cook food. During steaming, the food is not fully submerged in water but is cooked by the steam surrounding it. This allows for more even cooking without the food absorbing excess water. Steaming also helps retain the flavour and nutrients in the food. Since the food is not in direct contact with the water, there is less leeching of colour, nutrients, and flavour into the cooking liquid. This results in a more flavourful and nutritious dish.

The type of cooking vessel used can also impact the effectiveness of steaming and boiling. For example, using a pressure cooker can increase the temperature and speed up the cooking process for both methods. However, it is important to note that boiling may still result in some dilution of flavours due to the food being submerged in water.

Overall, when comparing steaming and boiling, it is essential to consider the potential impact on the taste and nutritional content of the food being cooked. While both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, steaming may be preferred when aiming to preserve the flavour and nutrients in the food. Boiling, on the other hand, can be useful when trying to create a broth or soup, as it allows for the extraction of flavours into the cooking liquid.

Boiling can remove a lot of nutrition from food

Additionally, fat-soluble vitamins such as vitamins A, D, E, and K, as well as minerals like potassium, magnesium, sodium, and calcium, are also reduced during cooking.

However, there are ways to minimise nutrient loss when boiling food. Using as little water as possible, consuming the liquid left in the pan, and cooking vegetables for only a few minutes can help retain more nutrients.

Steaming is a gentler cooking method that generally preserves more nutrients than boiling. For example, steaming broccoli, spinach, and lettuce reduces their vitamin C content by only 9-15%.

Overall, it is recommended to enjoy a mix of both raw and cooked vegetables to get the best of both worlds in terms of nutrient retention and digestibility.

Steaming is a gentle cooking method

Steaming is considered gentle because it takes less time, lower temperatures, and less liquid to cook vegetables. It is also a healthier option, as it preserves more nutrients. A 2009 study showed that steaming vegetables maintained the highest nutritional value compared to boiling, microwaving, stir-frying, and stir-frying/boiling.

Additionally, steaming does not require the use of oil or butter, making it a good option for weight loss. It is also suitable for cooking chicken breasts, shellfish, and fish fillets without drying them out.

However, it is important to note that steaming requires specialized equipment, such as a steamer basket or bamboo steamer, which may not be readily available in all kitchens.

Frequently asked questions