Vanilla Extract: Perfecting The Brownie Pan

Vanilla extract is an optional ingredient when making brownies, but it is commonly used to bring out and enhance the other flavours in the bake. The amount of vanilla extract used in a pan of brownies can vary depending on the recipe and the desired strength of the vanilla flavour. Some recipes suggest adding 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract to a pan of brownies, while others recommend using up to 1 tablespoon. It is also possible to substitute vanilla extract with other ingredients such as maple syrup, almond extract, or orange extract to add a different flavour profile to the brownies.

Vanilla is an optional ingredient

When it comes to brownies, the chemistry of the ingredients and their ratios is important. Clemence Gossett, co-owner of the Gourmandise School of Sweets & Savories, explains that all chocolate, except for cocoa powder, contains vanilla. Therefore, when vanilla extract is added to a brownie recipe, it can mute the chocolate flavour. As brownies are all about showcasing the flavour of chocolate, some bakers choose to omit the vanilla extract to let the chocolate shine through.

However, vanilla extract can be added to brownies to enhance their flavour. For those who enjoy a stronger vanilla taste, ground vanilla beans can be used instead of vanilla extract. Additionally, vanilla extract can be substituted or complemented by other extracts, such as orange extract, to create chocolate orange brownies.

Ultimately, the decision to include vanilla extract in brownies is a matter of personal preference. While it can enhance the flavour and give it more depth, it may also mute the chocolate flavour, which is the star of the show in brownies.

Maple syrup as a substitute

Maple syrup is a great substitute for vanilla extract in brownies. It has a similar colour and flavour profile to vanilla—it is light brown, sweet, and slightly caramelised.

To substitute maple syrup for vanilla extract, use a 1:1 ratio. That is, replace every tablespoon of vanilla extract in the recipe with a tablespoon of maple syrup. This will ensure that the flavour is not too overpowering.

Using maple syrup in place of vanilla extract will also change the calorie content of your brownies. A few tablespoons will not make much of a difference, but larger amounts will be more notable.

You can also try other substitutes for vanilla extract, such as almond extract or orange extract. However, these may alter the flavour profile of your brownies more drastically.

Vanilla enhances the flavour

Vanilla is a prized addition to brownies and other baked goods. Its comforting, toasty, musky, floral, or even smoky and earthy flavours enhance nearly any dessert, making it endlessly versatile. Vanilla's caramelly richness makes warm, deep flavours—like coffee, chocolate, hazelnut, brown butter, and cinnamon—cozier and bright flavours, like citrus, hibiscus, rosemary, and berry—sharper and more pronounced.

Vanilla extract is typically added to brownie batter to enhance the flavour of the chocolate. The amount of vanilla extract added to a 13" x 9" pan of brownies can vary from 1 teaspoon to 1 tablespoon. The amount used will depend on the desired intensity of the vanilla flavour and the strength of the extract. Some recipes may also substitute vanilla extract with vanilla beans or vanilla bean paste.

Vanilla is also known to potentiate sweetness. Sugar delivers a sweet taste perception to the palate, and when combined with vanilla extract, the expressive nature of natural vanilla flavour comes alive. Vanilla's characterizing aromatics are perceived by our brains as sweet, even though vanilla itself is not sweet. This is why vanilla is often used in reduced-sugar applications to enhance sweet tastes and disguise bitter ingredients and off-notes.

Vanilla is a versatile ingredient that can be used in both sweet and savoury applications. It can add a wonderful back note or perfume to dishes like steamed lobster. The tiny black seeds from a vanilla bean can be added to dishes like pudding to impart a strong vanilla flavour.

Vanilla is the salt of the baking world

Vanilla is to baking what salt is to cooking. It enhances the flavour of other ingredients and brings out their best qualities. A small amount of vanilla goes a long way in elevating the taste of baked goods. Just as salt is used to season dishes without overpowering their complex flavours, vanilla provides a subtle creamy note and a luscious aroma that complements and accentuates the other ingredients in a recipe.

Vanilla, like salt, is incredibly versatile. It can be used in a wide range of baked goods, from brownies and cookies to cakes and pastries. It is also an essential ingredient in frostings, ice cream, and even savoury dishes. A pinch of vanilla salt can take a dish from ordinary to extraordinary, adding a unique twist to both sweet and savoury treats.

When it comes to choosing the right vanilla extract, there are several options to consider. Pure vanilla extracts, made from higher-quality vanilla seed pods, tend to be pricier and offer different flavour profiles and consistencies compared to lab-synthesised extracts. The origin of the vanilla beans also makes a difference, with notable sources being Madagascar, Tahiti, Mexico, and Indonesia. Each region's beans have distinct flavour profiles, from the rich and high-quality Madagascar beans to the woody and spiced Mexican variety.

Vanilla, like salt, is an essential ingredient in any baker's pantry. It adds depth and complexity to flavours, enhances the taste of chocolate, and can even be used to create unique derivatives like vanilla salt or vanilla sugar. So, the next time you're whipping up a batch of brownies or experimenting with a new dessert recipe, don't forget to add a touch of vanilla—it's the secret ingredient that will take your creations to the next level.

Vanilla vs. orange extract

Vanilla extract is a common ingredient in baking, adding a touch of flavour and sweetness. It is made by soaking vanilla beans in a mixture of water and ethyl alcohol. The extract gets its signature vanilla flavour from a molecule called vanillin found in vanilla beans. Pure vanilla extract is generally more expensive than vanilla essence.

Vanilla essence, also known as artificial vanilla extract, is typically made using water, ethanol, propylene glycol, emulsifiers, and chemically produced flavours and colours. Like the extract, vanilla essence gets its flavour from vanillin, but it is a lab-made (synthetic) version that is much less expensive than using vanilla beans.

While vanilla extract is a common ingredient in brownies, some people choose to use orange extract instead. Orange extract will give brownies a different flavour, but the two extracts can be used interchangeably in baking. However, it is important to note that orange is a strong flavour, so you may want to use less extract than you normally would when substituting it for vanilla.

If you are looking for a more cost-effective option, vanilla essence can be used in baked goods where vanilla is not the key flavour. However, for uncooked dishes or items cooked at low heat that require a powerful vanilla punch, pure vanilla extract is the better choice.

In addition to vanillin, vanilla beans contain more than 200 compounds that contribute to their flavour and aroma. As a result, pure vanilla extract has a deeper, more complex flavour profile. This difference is more noticeable in dishes that are either uncooked or cooked over low heat, such as puddings, custards, pastry creams, and icings.

So, when it comes to brownies, if you are looking for a traditional vanilla flavour, pure vanilla extract is the best choice. However, if you want to experiment with a different flavour, orange extract can be used as a substitute, keeping in mind that it has a stronger flavour.

Frequently asked questions