Unveiling The Secrets Of Cast Iron: A Guide To Identifying Your Pan's Potential

Cast iron pans are highly durable and can last for decades, or even centuries, if maintained well. But how can you tell if a pan is made of cast iron? The first giveaway is its weight—cast iron pans are heavy, with a thick bottom and sides. If you can lift the pan comfortably with one hand, it's not cast iron. Cast iron pans are also usually black or dark grey in colour, with a smooth, shiny surface. They are often seasoned to create a protective coating, which gives them non-stick properties. Another distinguishing feature is the handle—if the handle is screwed on, it's probably not cast iron. Cast iron pans are typically manufactured in a one-piece mould, so the handle is included in the mould.

Check the weight: cast iron pans are heavy

One of the most obvious ways to determine whether a pan is made from cast iron is to check its weight. Cast iron pans are renowned for being extremely heavy, so if you can lift the pan comfortably with one hand, it is unlikely to be made from cast iron. Authentic cast iron pans have thick bottoms and sides, which accounts for their weight.

Cast iron skillets typically weigh between 4 and 12 pounds, depending on their size. For example, a mini 8 or 9-inch skillet weighs around 4 pounds, while a 12-inch skillet weighs around 8 pounds. An extra-large 15-inch skillet can weigh up to 12 pounds.

When compared to stainless steel and aluminium skillets, cast iron skillets weigh around twice as much. For instance, a 12-inch cast iron skillet weighs 8 pounds on average, whereas a 12-inch stainless steel or aluminium skillet weighs around 4 pounds.

Cast iron skillets are made significantly thicker than steel skillets to ensure they are durable and can withstand wear and tear in the kitchen. As a result, cast iron skillets carry a lot more weight.

Look for markings: manufacturers often display their brand, size or range name

When it comes to identifying cast iron pans, markings are an important feature to look out for. Manufacturers often display their brand, size, or range name on their pieces. These markings can be in the form of letters, numbers, or a combination of both, and they may be embossed, recessed, or carved onto the pan. Sometimes, the markings are subtle, such as a single letter or number, which can indicate the pan's size or model. Other times, the markings are more obvious, like a brand name or logo.

In addition to the markings themselves, the location of the markings can also be indicative of the manufacturer. For example, some brands mark their pans with letters or numbers on the handle, while others mark the bottom of the pan. Some pans may even have markings inside the bowl of the pan.

If you're trying to identify an unmarked cast iron pan, don't worry! Even if there are no visible markings, you can still look for ghost markings, which are faint impressions left by original brand molds. These ghost markings can be identified by looking for rough file marks on the pan's surface. Additionally, you can study the texture, shape, and decorative details of the pan, especially the handle, to help identify its maker.

It's also worth noting that some pans were deliberately left unmarked because they were sold directly to stores. For example, a pan intended for a specific store like Woolworth's might not have the manufacturer's label on it. In such cases, studying the distinctive features of different brands and memorising their silhouettes can help with identification.

Lastly, if you're able to find even the slightest marking on the pan, such as a fragment of a brand name or a number, this can be a helpful clue. You can use image search tools to look up this information and potentially find similar images that can provide vital clues about your pan's manufacturer.

Examine the colour: cast iron is black to dark grey

When it comes to identifying cast iron, the colour is a key indicator. Cast iron is black to dark grey in colour and has a smooth, shiny surface if it is in good condition. The colour of cast iron is a result of the traditional process of quenching the iron in oil, such as linseed oil, while it is still hot. This forms a coating, often called 'seasoning', which is just a fancy name for oil that has been heated to form a polymerized coating.

Cast iron skillets will also develop a natural non-stick surface over time and with use. This happens as the pan develops many thin, interlocking layers of seasoning on its surface. Each time you cook in a cast iron skillet, it will gain and lose seasoning in different spots, which can cause some discolouration. However, as you develop more and more seasoning across the surface of the pan, you will notice that the colour evens out and darkens overall.

Cast iron skillets are prized for their durability and longevity. Even if the surface looks slightly off-colour, such as orange or rusty, it can be restored through a process of re-seasoning. This involves scrubbing the pan to remove any rust or loose seasoning, drying it, and then coating it with a thin layer of seasoning oil. With time and continued use, the protective shiny patina will build up, protecting the iron and improving its non-stick properties.

In summary, when examining a pan to determine if it is made of cast iron, the colour is an important factor. Cast iron will have a distinct black to dark grey colour and may develop a patchy or uneven colour with use. However, this discolouration can be rectified by continuing to cook with the pan and building up more layers of seasoning.

Check the handle: cast iron handles are included in the mould

When it comes to determining whether a pan is made of cast iron, there are several tell-tale signs to look out for. One of the most distinctive indicators is the weight; cast iron is heavy, typically weighing three pounds or more. If you can lift the pan comfortably with one hand, it is unlikely to be made of cast iron. Cast iron pans also tend to have thick bottoms and sides, contributing to their weight.

Another feature unique to cast iron pans is the handle. As cast iron pans are typically manufactured in a one-piece mould, the handle is included in the mould rather than being attached separately. Therefore, if the handle on your pan is screwed on, it is likely not made of cast iron, or at least not of good quality cast iron. Due to the weight of the material, a screwed-on handle would be a weak point and could be dangerous when the pan is full.

Additionally, cast iron pans usually bear markings from the manufacturer, often displaying the brand, size, or range name. The colour of a cast-iron pan is typically black to dark grey, and when in good condition, it should have a smooth, shiny surface.

Inspect the spout: older pans have larger spouts and two pour spouts

Inspecting the spout of a pan is a great way to identify if it is a cast iron pan. The spout is one of the distinguishing markers of a pan. Older cast iron pans have larger spouts than newer ones because spout-making tools were not as advanced in the past. Therefore, dips in older pans were more defined.

Older cast iron pans also have two pour spouts, whereas newer ones have only one. Modern-day cast iron pans may also have a helper handle and non-stick coatings.

When buying a cast iron skillet, it is important to check its insides. For example, Wagner's skillets have spiral grooves inside, while Griswold's are flat. Lodge skillets have a pebbly texture and are rough. A cast iron pan with a dimpled or hammered finish is a younger model. A skillet with two short handles and a dimpled lid is likely made by Birmingham.

Frequently asked questions