Air Fryer Uncrustables: Quick, Easy, And Delicious

Air-frying Uncrustables is a simple way to enjoy a grilled version of the classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich. The air fryer gives the sandwich a golden, toasty exterior with a gooey, melted filling. The process is straightforward: spray or spread butter on the frozen sandwich, air fry for 6-8 minutes, and serve. The result is a delicious, indulgent treat that can be enjoyed by both kids and adults.

How to make Uncrustables in an air fryer

Uncrustables are a fun, tasty snack that can be made in an air fryer in a matter of minutes. This guide will take you through the process step by step, so you can enjoy warm, gooey, melty Uncrustables whenever the craving strikes!

Step 1: Prepare Your Uncrustables

First, take your Uncrustables out of the freezer. You can use either thawed or frozen Uncrustables for this recipe, but don't worry about letting them sit out to thaw—they cook better when they're still frozen!

Step 2: Butter or Spray Your Uncrustables

For the best flavour and texture, brush or spread a thin layer of butter on both sides of your Uncrustables. You can also use cooking spray if you prefer. This step is optional, but it will give your Uncrustables a golden, crispy exterior.

Step 3: Place in the Air Fryer

Place your Uncrustables in the air fryer basket, leaving a little space between each one to allow for proper air circulation. If you're using a rack, place it inside the air fryer so that both sides of the Uncrustables cook evenly.

Step 4: Set the Temperature and Time

Set your air fryer to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. If your Uncrustables are frozen, cook them for 7 to 8 minutes. For thawed Uncrustables, 5 to 6 minutes should be enough. Don't forget to flip them halfway through the cooking time!

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy!

Remove your Uncrustables from the air fryer and let them rest for a couple of minutes before serving. This will allow the peanut butter and jelly to fully melt and settle, so you get that perfect, gooey texture. Enjoy your warm, crispy Uncrustables as a snack or a fun breakfast treat!

Tips for making the best Uncrustables in the air fryer

Air-frying Uncrustables is a simple and quick way to enjoy a grilled version of the classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Here are some tips to help you make the best Uncrustables in your air fryer:

Butter or Cooking Spray

While not necessary, spreading butter or spraying cooking spray on both sides of the Uncrustables will give them a golden colour and a crisp texture. This step also adds flavour and makes the bread softer.

Temperature and Timing

The ideal temperature for air-frying Uncrustables is between 350 to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Frozen Uncrustables will need 7 to 8 minutes to cook, while thawed ones will only need about 5 minutes. Remember to flip the sandwiches halfway through the cooking process.

Spacing

When placing the Uncrustables in the air fryer basket, leave a little space between each one to ensure proper air circulation. This will help ensure even cooking and prevent the sandwiches from becoming soggy.

Garnishes and Flavour Boosts

For an added boost of flavour, sprinkle cinnamon or powdered sugar on the Uncrustables right after they come out of the air fryer. You can also get creative with other garnishes, such as warmed jelly or chopped peanuts.

Storage

Uncrustables should be stored in the freezer, and it is recommended to use them frozen for the air fryer. There is no need to thaw them before cooking.

Whether you need to thaw Uncrustables before cooking

One recipe suggests that you spread soft butter on both sides of the frozen sandwich and do not thaw before cooking. The recipe also suggests that you let the sandwich rest for 2 minutes after cooking to allow the peanut butter and jelly to melt and settle.

Another recipe suggests that you brush the tops of the frozen Uncrustables with melted butter and then place them in the air fryer basket, leaving space around them for the air to circulate. This recipe also suggests that you do not need to thaw the Uncrustables before cooking.

What to serve with this tasty treat

Air fryer Uncrustables are a delicious treat, but what can you serve with them? Here are some ideas to elevate your meal or snack:

Sweet Treats

If you're looking for something indulgent to satisfy your sweet tooth, try serving your air fryer Uncrustables with some of these sweet treats:

• Air-fried Oreos with crescent rolls: A crispy, indulgent treat that's sure to be a crowd-pleaser.
• Air-fried peanut butter and jelly: Take your PB&J to the next level by frying it! A fun twist on the classic sandwich.
• Air fryer jelly donuts: Because who doesn't love a warm, sugary donut? These will be a perfect match for your Uncrustables.
• Air fryer cookie cake: A soft, gooey cookie cake is a perfect complement to the crispy Uncrustables.
• Instant Pot strawberry applesauce: A fruity, sweet treat to balance out the richness of the Uncrustables.

Savory Sides

If you're looking for something more savory to balance out the sweetness of the Uncrustables, try these options:

• Air fryer tater tots: Crispy and salty, tater toots make a great side dish, especially for those who want a break from the sweetness of the Uncrustables.
• Air fryer frozen chicken nuggets: Chicken nuggets are a classic, crowd-pleasing option that pairs well with just about anything, including Uncrustables!
• Air fryer lava cakes: While lava cakes are typically thought of as a dessert, they can also be a savory treat. Try a cheese or meat-filled lava cake for a delicious contrast to the sweet Uncrustables.
• Air fryer avocado fries: Crispy, creamy, and salty, avocado fries make a great side dish or snack. They're a fun and unique option to serve alongside your Uncrustables.

Creative Twists

Want to get a little creative and think outside the box? Try these unique ideas:

• French toast: Dip your Uncrustables in an egg and milk mixture, then pan-fry them for a sweet and fluffy treat. Don't forget the syrup!
• Waffles: Use a waffle maker to turn your Uncrustables into sweet and crispy waffles. Top them with butter, syrup, or even a scoop of ice cream!
• Doughnuts: Turn your Uncrustables into doughnuts by frying them and coating them in cinnamon sugar. A sweet and crispy treat that's hard to resist!
• Uncrustable "pancakes": Cut your Uncrustables into rectangles, dip them in batter, and fry them up like pancakes. Sprinkle with powdered sugar for an extra sweet touch.
• Ice cream sandwiches: Fry your Uncrustables, then split them open and fill them with your favorite ice cream flavor. A sweet and creamy treat that's perfect for a hot day.

How to make Uncrustables at home

Uncrustables are a cult classic in the US, and they are super easy to make at home. They are essentially a pre-made peanut butter and jelly sandwich without crusts, crimped down to seal the filling and cut into a circle. You can also make them with chocolate-hazelnut spread.

Ingredients

• Bread (white or whole-wheat)
• Peanut butter
• Jelly (strawberry or grape)
• Butter or cooking spray
• Cinnamon sugar mixture (optional)
• Chopped peanuts (optional)

Method

• Make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich.
• Place a sandwich cutter and sealer on top, and press down to seal and crimp the crusts.
• If you want to cook the Uncrustables straight away, spread soft butter on both sides of the sandwich or spray with cooking spray.
• Place the Uncrustables in the air fryer basket, leaving a little space between each one.
• Turn your fryer to 350–375°F and cook for 6–8 minutes, flipping halfway through.
• If desired, sprinkle with a cinnamon sugar mixture and chopped peanuts.
• Let the sandwiches sit for 2 minutes before serving.

Frequently asked questions