Broiler Vs Roasting Pan: What's The Difference?

Broiling pans and roasting pans are two very different types of cookware, each specialising in a different cooking method. While they are made from the same materials and can be used to cook the same types of food, there are some key differences between the two.

Broiler pans are shallower, like a baking sheet, with a slotted base

Broiler pans are shallower than roasting pans, resembling a baking sheet. They have a slotted base, which allows the drippings from the food to drain onto a lower pan. This two-piece design is a key difference between broiler and roasting pans. The upper pan, with a slotted base, is where the food cooks. The lower pan collects the drippings from the meat, preventing flare-ups and allowing for easier cleaning.

The slotted base of the broiler pan also ensures that the meat is not sitting in its juices, allowing it to develop a better sear and caramelisation. This is particularly useful when cooking meats like steaks, where the ability to drain excess fat is desirable. The shallow design of the broiler pan also means food cooks more quickly, and the high heat can produce a nice sear without overcooking the inside of the food.

The broiler pan's design and functionality are well-suited for cooking various cuts of meat, vegetables, poultry, and seafood. It is also a good option for cooking foods that benefit from a crispy texture, such as chicken wings.

While a broiler pan can be used as a substitute for a roasting pan, it is important to note that its low walls may not effectively contain the juices from a roast. Additionally, the height of a broiler pan can be advantageous as it lifts the meat closer to the heat source.

Broiler pans cook food quickly, allowing meat drippings to drain

Broiler pans are designed to cook food at very high temperatures, with heat distributed from the top of the oven. This direct exposure to intense heat means food cooks much more quickly in a broiler pan than in a roasting pan.

Broiler pans are also shallower than roasting pans, with a slotted base that allows meat drippings to drain onto a lower pan. This means that meat cooked in a broiler pan will drain excess fat, while a roasting pan allows meat to cook in its own juices, resulting in a more tender and juicy texture.

The slotted base of a broiler pan also allows for a better sear on the food, as the high heat can more easily caramelize the surface of the food. This is especially useful for achieving a crispy texture on the outside of meat, while keeping the inside soft and tender.

The ability of broiler pans to cook food quickly and allow for effective fat drainage makes them ideal for cooking various cuts of meat, as well as vegetables, poultry, and seafood. However, for foods that need to baste in their own juices, a roasting pan would be a better option.

Roasting pans are deeper and cook meat in its own juices

Roasting pans and broiler pans are very similar types of cookware, but there are some key differences. While both are used for cooking meats, such as whole chickens, and vegetables, roasting pans are deeper in size and allow meat to cook in its own juices.

The design of roasting pans means they can hold larger cuts of meat and cook food more slowly than a broiler pan. Roasting pans are deeper and have high walls to capture the juices that fall from cooking meat, keeping the meat moist and tender. This is ideal for cooking meat that needs to baste in its own juices. The juices are also important for making gravy.

The high walls of roasting pans also lock in heat, allowing them to cook food at higher temperatures without the risk of uneven cooking. Roasting pans are usually a single deep pan that sometimes comes with a metal oven rack for elevating the meat.

Broiler pans, on the other hand, are more shallow, like a baking sheet, and have a slotted base. This allows the drippings of the meat to drain underneath the meat, which helps to create a better sear on the food from the high heat. Broiler pans are usually made up of two separate pieces: a lower drip pan and an upper slotted pan.

The heat distribution also differs between the two types of pans. Broiler pans cook food under very high temperatures from heat coming from the top of the oven, while roasting pans use high temperatures distributed from the bottom of the oven.

Broiler pans are placed under high heat from the top of the oven

Broiler pans are designed to cook food under very high heat from the top of the oven. Broiling involves exposing food to direct heat from the oven's heating element, which is typically located near the top of the oven. This direct heat can cook, brown, char, or caramelize food, similar to grilling.

To use a broiler, it is recommended to preheat it for around five minutes. Most broilers only have an “On” setting, but some have a Low and High setting. However, since broiling involves direct heat, it is generally recommended to use the High setting for optimal results.

When using a broiler pan, it is important to ensure that the oven rack is adjusted to the correct height. The distance between the broiler and the food can impact the cooking results. For thinner cuts of meat and foods that require heavy browning or caramelization, placing them closer to the broiler element, typically 3-5 inches away, is ideal. For thicker cuts or bone-in meats that take longer to cook, moving them slightly farther from the broiler element can help prevent burning.

Broiler pans are typically made of materials such as stainless steel or hard anodized aluminum, similar to roasting pans. However, broiler pans have a distinct design with a slotted base and a shallower depth compared to roasting pans. This design allows for quick cooking and helps drain excess fat from the food, resulting in a better sear and caramelization.

In summary, broiler pans are designed to withstand high heat from the top of the oven, utilizing direct heat to cook food quickly and create desirable textures and flavors through browning, charring, or caramelization.

Roasting pans use high heat from the bottom of the oven

Roasting pans are designed to cook food using high heat from the bottom of the oven. They are large, oven-safe pans with tall, straight walls that trap heat inside, ensuring food cooks evenly and crisps nicely while maintaining moisture.

Roasting pans are made of heavy-duty metal, such as stainless steel, hard anodized aluminum, or cast iron. They are thicker than other pans to ensure even heat distribution. They are also deeper than broiler pans, with high sides designed to capture the juices that fall from cooking meat, and to lock in heat.

When cooking with a roasting pan, the oven is set to the desired temperature, and the heat cooks the food from the bottom of the oven. This is different from a broiler pan, which uses very high heat from the top of the oven.

Roasting pans are best for cooking foods that baste in their own juices, such as large cuts of meat like whole chickens or turkeys. The high sides of the pan prevent juices from spilling over, and the rack that comes with the roasting pan keeps the meat from sitting in the juices, allowing it to cook evenly.

Frequently asked questions