Ceramic Non-Stick Cookware: Worth The Hype?

Ceramic non-stick cookware has gained popularity due to its stylish and sleek design, and claims that it is safer and more natural than traditional non-stick pans. Ceramic cookware is made with different water- and grease-repelling materials than traditional non-stick cookware. It typically handles higher temperatures than PTFE (Teflon) cookware but wears faster, losing its non-stick properties quicker. Ceramic cookware is often marketed as a more sustainable alternative to traditional non-stick cookware as it does not contain harmful chemicals like PFOA, PFAS, PTFE, lead or cadmium. However, it is more expensive than traditional non-stick pans and is not the best option for high-heat cooking techniques like searing and browning.

Ceramic cookware is more prone to chipping and cracking than cast iron or steel

Ceramic cookware is a popular choice for home cooks and professional chefs alike, thanks to its sleek design and non-stick properties. However, one of its main drawbacks is that it is more prone to chipping and cracking than other materials like cast iron or steel. This fragility is due to the nature of the ceramic coating, which tends to be more delicate and susceptible to scratches and wear and tear.

The susceptibility of ceramic cookware to chipping and cracking can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, the coating itself is often quite thin and can be fragile. High-heat cooking can accelerate the breakdown of the ceramic coating, as can the use of metal utensils. Additionally, sudden temperature changes, such as placing the dish directly from the fridge to the oven, can also increase the risk of cracking.

While ceramic cookware offers the advantage of a non-stick surface, this property tends to diminish over time. As the coating wears down, food begins to stick more easily, and the cookware becomes more susceptible to scratches and chipping. This is in contrast to cast iron or steel cookware, which can develop natural non-stick properties over time with proper seasoning and care.

It's important to note that while ceramic cookware may chip or crack, it doesn't pose a significant health risk. Ingesting small amounts of the non-stick coating is generally not harmful. However, breathing in fumes released from overheating non-stick cookware can be dangerous. Therefore, it's recommended to avoid using high heat when cooking with ceramic or non-stick pans.

To prolong the lifespan of ceramic cookware and reduce the risk of chipping and cracking, proper care and maintenance are essential. This includes hand-washing the cookware with gentle tools and soap, avoiding abrasive materials like steel wool, and refraining from using it in the dishwasher. Additionally, using utensils made from softer materials like nylon, silicone, or wood can help prevent scratches and preserve the coating.

Ceramic pans are not always dishwasher-safe

The lifespan of ceramic cookware is shorter than that of other options due to the nature of the coating, which releases every time the pan is heated. The coating tends to be more fragile than other types, making it susceptible to scratches and other forms of wear and tear. Therefore, it is important to use soft utensils like nylon, silicone, or wood when cooking with ceramic pans and to avoid high heat, as sustained use over high heat can cause the coating to break down more quickly.

While ceramic cookware offers a smooth non-stick finish that makes cleanup easier and requires less oil or cooking fat, it is important to note that its non-stick properties may diminish over time. Food may start to stick more easily, and cleanup may become more difficult. To maintain the non-stick properties of ceramic pans, it is crucial to avoid non-stick cooking sprays and burning oil or food, as these can leave stains and build-up on the coating.

Additionally, when purchasing ceramic cookware, it is essential to do your research to ensure you are getting a durable and relatively long-lasting product. While you can find high-quality ceramic cookware made of cladded stainless steel or hard-anodized aluminum, many ceramic pans are made with an aluminum base, which can warp and scratch more easily.

Ceramic cookware is less durable than steel or cast iron

The coating on a ceramic pot or pan is more fragile than other types of coatings, which means it is more susceptible to scratches and other forms of wear and tear. This also applies to high-heat cooking; while some ceramic pans are marketed as safe for high-heat cooking, sustained use over high heat can cause the ceramic coating to break down more quickly. Therefore, it is recommended to use ceramic cookware with soft utensils, such as those made of nylon, silicone, or wood, and to keep the heat setting at medium or lower.

Additionally, the exterior surface of painted ceramic cookware is likely to chip, especially if it rubs against the rough grates of a stove. The ceramic coating on the cooking surface will also break down over time, and once this happens, the pan will need to be replaced.

Ceramic cookware is also susceptible to warping if exposed to drastic temperature changes. This can be a problem if you are looking for cookware that is dishwasher-safe, as the high temperatures and abrasive cleaning detergents can cause warping and decrease the non-stick properties of the cookware.

While ceramic cookware offers many benefits, such as being non-toxic, eco-friendly, and promoting healthy cooking, its inferior durability compared to steel or cast iron is a significant downside. If you are looking for cookware that will last for many years, you may want to consider other options.

Ceramic pans are not the best for searing meat

While ceramic pans have their advantages, they are not the best option for searing meat. Here are some reasons why:

Heat Requirements for Searing

To get a good sear on meat, a high temperature is required. Ceramic pans are not ideal for this as they have a lower heat threshold compared to other materials like cast iron or stainless steel. Ceramic pans start to break down at temperatures above 800°F (450°C), and while this is a high temperature, it is not hot enough for a proper sear.

Durability

Ceramic pans are known to have a shorter lifespan than other options. The coating tends to be more fragile and susceptible to scratches and wear and tear. This is especially true if the pan is heated to high temperatures, which is necessary for searing.

Non-Stick Properties

One of the main selling points of ceramic pans is their non-stick coating. While this makes them excellent for cooking delicate foods like eggs and fish, it is not ideal for searing meat. When searing, you want the meat to form a crust and stick slightly to the pan, which is how the flavour develops. With a non-stick pan, you won't get the same depth of flavour.

Weight

Ceramic pans are typically lighter than cast iron, which can be an advantage for some cooks. However, the weight of cast iron is beneficial for searing as it helps the pan retain heat. The thicker and heavier cast iron stays hot even when you add a cold piece of meat, which is essential for getting a good sear.

Smoke

Searing meat, especially in a hot, dry pan, can produce a lot of smoke. While this is true for most pans, the non-stick coating on ceramic pans can make it worse. The coating may start to break down and produce toxic fumes if exposed to high temperatures and smoke for prolonged periods.

Alternative Options

If you're looking for the perfect sear, consider using a cast iron skillet. Cast iron is thick, heavy, and retains heat well, making it ideal for searing steaks. Stainless steel and anodized aluminium are also good alternatives as they can withstand high temperatures and provide a nice sear.

Ceramic cookware is susceptible to warping

Ceramic cookware is a beautiful addition to any kitchen, with its designer colours and sleek, minimalist shapes. However, it is susceptible to warping, which can be caused by thermal shock or clay memory.

Thermal shock occurs when a hot object is subjected to a drastic drop in temperature, or vice versa. This sudden temperature change causes the object to fracture, split, or even explode. Warping is a common result of thermal shock, and it can affect the performance of your cookware. To prevent thermal shock, it is important to let hot cookware cool to room temperature before washing it and to avoid high heat during cooking.

Clay memory is another cause of warping in ceramic cookware. Clay has a memory, or clay particle orientation, that can cause warping as the clay particles tend to return to their initial orientation when they dry out. High-plasticity clays, such as porcelain, are more prone to clay memory issues. The addition of water during forming can also increase the likelihood of memory issues. To prevent warping caused by clay memory, it is important to control the rate of drying and ensure uniform moisture content across the entire piece.

While ceramic cookware is susceptible to warping, it offers several benefits, including a smooth non-stick finish, ease of cleaning, and compatibility with induction cooktops. However, it is important to carefully source high-quality ceramic cookware and handle it with care to minimise the risk of warping.

Frequently asked questions