Greenpan: Eco-Friendly Or Greenwashing?

GreenPan is a cookware brand that claims to be eco-friendly and non-toxic. The company uses a patented Thermolon™ ceramic non-stick coating that it has advertised as completely toxin-free, healthy, and free of PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium. However, the company has faced scrutiny and lawsuits for these claims, with accusations of misrepresentation and greenwashing.

In 2012, the National Advertising Division (NAD) criticised GreenPan for making untrue claims in its advertisements, and the company was asked to change its wording. In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against GreenPan, alleging false advertising and the presence of toxins in the Thermolon coating. The lawsuit was settled and the claims dismissed without prejudice, meaning they can be brought again but with no decision on the merits.

While GreenPan's products may be safer than traditional non-stick coatings, there are concerns about the accuracy of their eco-friendly and non-toxic claims. The company has been criticised for a lack of transparency and independent testing of its products. Some users have also reported issues with the non-stick coating wearing off over time.

GreenPan's Thermolon coating

The Thermolon coating is created by spraying a solution onto the walls of the pan, which is then baked in an oven to harden the layer. This process emits 60% less CO2 than the production of traditional non-stick PTFE pans. The coating also has excellent heat conductivity, allowing users to cook at lower temperatures and save energy.

While GreenPan claims that its Thermolon coating is non-toxic, there have been lawsuits and accusations of greenwashing against the company. Lawsuits have alleged the presence of toxins in the Thermolon coating, including silane, aluminum oxide, and potassium titanate. GreenPan has also faced criticism for its advertising claims, with the National Advertising Division asking the company to stop marketing its cookware as "healthy" and "eco-friendly."

Overall, while GreenPan's Thermolon coating offers a non-stick, heat-resistant, and environmentally-friendly alternative to traditional non-stick coatings, there are concerns about the accuracy of the company's marketing claims and the potential presence of toxins.

GreenPan's eco-friendly claims

GreenPan is a global forerunner in the cookware industry, founded in Belgium in 2007. The company claims to be eco-friendly and non-toxic, with its products being free of PFAS, PFOA, lead, and cadmium. However, there have been lawsuits and accusations of greenwashing against GreenPan, casting doubt on its eco-friendly claims.

GreenPan asserts that its products are not only beneficial for the culinary experience but also for the planet. The company's commitment to a PFAS-free future is a cornerstone of its eco-friendly claims. By excluding PFAS from its products, GreenPan positions itself as a leader in the movement towards safer, more sustainable ceramic non-stick cookware.

GreenPan also states that its Thermolon coating, a significant part of its eco-friendly claims, is made from a sand derivative and does not require the use of toxic chemicals like PFOA or PFAS during production. This makes it safer for both consumers and the environment. Additionally, Thermolon is heat-resistant, ensuring that it won't blister or release toxic fumes even if the pan is accidentally overheated. Moreover, Thermolon is an excellent heat conductor, allowing users to cook at lower heat settings, thereby saving energy.

GreenPan further claims that its products are eco-friendly due to their production practices. The company states that their manufacturing process emits up to 60% less carbon dioxide during the curing phase of the Thermolon coating compared to its competitors. However, GreenPan has been criticized for not substantiating this claim or specifying which brands it is competing against.

Lawsuits and Accusations of Greenwashing

Despite GreenPan's eco-friendly claims, the company has faced legal action and accusations of greenwashing. In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against GreenPan, alleging false advertising and the presence of toxins in their Thermolon coating. The lawsuit pointed out substances such as silane, aluminum oxide, and potassium titanate, all of which are associated with adverse health outcomes.

This was not an isolated incident, as GreenPan's advertising claims have been challenged on multiple occasions. In 2012, the National Advertising Division (NAD) criticized the company for making untrue claims in its advertisements. Additionally, in 2013, the NAD asked GreenPan to stop marketing its cookware as "healthy, eco-friendly," and free of "potentially dangerous chemicals." These incidents highlight the need for transparency and independent testing to verify the safety and eco-friendliness of GreenPan's products.

GreenPan's lawsuit

GreenPan, a cookware brand, has faced scrutiny for its advertising claims, with accusations of misrepresentation and greenwashing. The company has been sued multiple times for false advertising, with plaintiffs claiming that the marketing of GreenPan cookware as completely toxin-free was misleading.

The 2019 Lawsuit

In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against The Cookware Company, the manufacturer of GreenPan. The lawsuit was brought by a consumer, Anna Saldivar, who claimed she was misled by GreenPan's advertising to spend more on a pan she was promised would be healthier and more environmentally friendly. Saldivar's claims were dismissed with prejudice, meaning she couldn't file the same lawsuit again. However, the case was also dismissed "without prejudice" in terms of the class action, meaning any similar consumer could bring those claims and others against GreenPan again.

The National Advertising Division's Intervention

In 2012, the National Advertising Division (NAD) of the Council of Better Business Bureaus criticised GreenPan for making untrue claims in its advertisements. After the NAD's intervention, GreenPan changed the wording within its ad campaigns. However, the new wording could still be seen as misleading.

Other Interventions

In 2013, the NAD asked GreenPan to stop marketing its cookware as "healthy, eco-friendly," and free of "potentially dangerous chemicals." The NAD agreed with DuPont, the manufacturer of Teflon, which had petitioned the NAD to review GreenPan's claims, stating that these claims were misleading.

The Presence of Toxins

According to the 2019 lawsuit, GreenPan's Thermolon™ coating contains several toxins, including:

• Silane – a colorless, flammable gas that is toxic to breathe in and known for irritating the skin, eyes, and mucous membranes
• Aluminum oxide – exposure can lead to lung damage
• Tetraethoxysilane – respiratory and skin irritation
• Methyltrimethoxysilane – serious eye, skin, and respiratory irritation
• Potassium titanate – harmful if inhaled; potential carcinogen

GreenPan's Response

In response to the lawsuits and interventions, GreenPan continues to market its products as safe and non-toxic. The company states that its Thermolon coating is made from a sand derivative and does not require the use of toxic chemicals during production. GreenPan also claims that its products are eco-friendly due to their production practices, such as emitting up to 60% less carbon dioxide during the curing phase of the Thermolon coating than its competitors.

GreenPan's competitors

Caraway

Caraway is a startup cookware brand founded in 2018. It offers a modern and colourful design, with a core design available in several colours. Caraway's primary base material is heavy-gauge aluminium, and it has a ceramic non-stick coating. The brand is transparent about testing results and claims to be non-toxic and eco-friendly.

Xtrema

Xtrema is a pure ceramic cookware brand, free from lead and other heavy metals. The brand is committed to sustainability and durability, minimising waste in its manufacturing processes and creating products that last for decades.

De Buyer

De Buyer is a French brand that has been manufacturing carbon steel cookware for almost two centuries. Their products are long-lasting if treated with care, but they require careful seasoning.

Lodge

Lodge is an American brand that has been making cast iron cookware since 1896. Their products are virtually indestructible and have a naturally non-stick surface if treated correctly. Lodge uses cast iron from two foundries on the Tennessee River, making it an attractive choice for those wanting to support local businesses.

Cuisinart

Cuisinart's Multiclad offers triple-ply stainless steel construction with a magnetised stainless steel, aluminium core, and 18/10 stainless steel. It is oven-safe and dishwasher-safe, and easier to handle than cast iron.

CorningWare

CorningWare is a traditional, non-toxic, and thermal shock-resistant ceramic cookware brand. While most of their products cannot be used on a stovetop, they have a stovetop-safe line manufactured in France.

Emile Henry

Emile Henry is a French ceramic cookware company that does not use glazes containing cadmium and other heavy metals. Their products are resistant to thermal shock and can be put in the oven directly from the freezer.

Bialetti

Bialetti is an Italian brand that specialises in espresso machines and coffee products.

Kyocera

Kyocera offers a ceramic-coated non-stick pan with a thick aluminium base. However, the ceramic coating has been reported to stop working after a few months.

GreenPan's safety

GreenPan is a cookware brand that claims to be eco-friendly and non-toxic. The original GreenPan cookware uses a patented Thermolon ceramic non-stick coating that the company has advertised as "completely toxin-free," "healthy," and "free of PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium."

However, the company has faced scrutiny and lawsuits for these claims, with accusations of misrepresentation and greenwashing. While GreenPan pans are free of PFOA, this is now the norm for all non-stick cookware produced in the United States since 2013.

There are also concerns about the safety of the Thermolon coating, which is made using a Sol-Gel process and mainly consists of silica (or sand). The full list of ingredients is not disclosed, and there are no recent test reports available, so it is challenging to determine the safety of the coating.

Some common complaints about GreenPan cookware include the dissipation of the non-stick coating over time, an odour emitted from the pans, and scratching or chipping of the coating.

Overall, while GreenPan cookware may be a safer alternative to traditional non-stick coatings like Teflon, there are still questions and uncertainties about its safety, particularly due to a lack of transparency and independent testing.

Frequently asked questions