Best Pan For Caramelizing Onions: Non-Stick Or Stainless Steel?

Caramelized onions are a great way to add a burst of flavour to your dishes. They are rich, silky smooth, and sweet. However, making them can be a time-consuming process. It takes at least 45 minutes over low heat for the natural sugars in the onions to caramelize. While a non-stick pan is great for making pancakes and eggs, it may not be the best option for caramelizing onions. A cast-iron skillet or carbon steel pan is recommended as they allow for even cooking and enhance the flavour of the onions.

Non-stick pans can be used for caramelising onions, but they are not the best option

Caramelising onions requires patience as it is a slow process that can take at least 45 minutes, and often over an hour. The onions need to be cooked over a low heat to allow the natural sugars to caramelise properly, and a non-stick pan may not distribute the heat evenly, leading to hot spots that can scorch the sugars.

A cast-iron skillet or a heavy-based pan, such as a carbon steel pan, is the best option for caramelising onions. These pans distribute heat evenly and retain a lot of heat, ensuring that the onions cook evenly. Additionally, the crispy brown build-ups that stick to the bottom of the pan can be scraped up and mixed with the onions, adding even more flavour.

The size of the pan also matters when caramelising onions. It's important to use a large and wide pan to allow moisture to evaporate as the onions cook. For 4 onions, a 12-inch or larger skillet is recommended, while a 10-inch skillet is suitable for 3 onions.

While non-stick pans can be used for caramelising onions, they may not produce the same desirable results as a cast-iron skillet or a heavy-based pan. It's worth investing in a good-quality pan to achieve the best flavour and texture for your caramelised onions.

Cast iron skillets are a good choice for caramelising onions

Caramelising onions is a great way to season your cast iron skillet. The alliums slowly pick up the fond (browned bits) from the surface of the pan, and this process is enhanced by the even heat distribution of a cast iron skillet. The fond adds flavour and colour to your onions, and the slow cooking process allows the natural sugars in the onions to caramelise properly.

Cast iron skillets are heavy, which is an advantage when caramelising onions because you want your pan to retain heat at a low flame. The weight of the skillet helps to ensure that the heat is distributed evenly, preventing hot spots and scorching. This even heat distribution is key to achieving the desired result when caramelising onions.

The size of the pan also matters when choosing a skillet for caramelising onions. You will need a large and wide skillet to allow moisture to evaporate as the onions cook. For four onions, a 12-inch or larger skillet is recommended, while a 10-inch skillet is suitable for three onions.

Carbon steel pans are another option, but they may not produce the same authentic texture as cast iron

Carbon steel pans are another option for caramelizing onions, but they may not produce the same authentic texture as cast iron. While carbon steel pans can indeed be used for caramelizing onions, some people claim that cast iron pans give the onions a more authentic texture.

Cast iron skillets have long been a go-to for caramelizing onions due to their ability to retain and distribute heat evenly, resulting in evenly cooked onions. The rough surface of cast iron pans also contributes to the desired texture of caramelized onions. Additionally, the build-up of crispy brown bits in the pan can be scraped up and mixed with the onions, enhancing their flavor.

Carbon steel pans, on the other hand, are known for their exceptional browning capabilities and even heat distribution. They are also much lighter than cast iron pans, making them easier to handle in the kitchen. However, some people find that carbon steel pans can be less forgiving if the onions are left unattended and not stirred frequently. The onions may not develop the same crispy edges as they would in a cast iron pan.

It's worth noting that the choice between cast iron and carbon steel pans is a matter of personal preference. Both options will produce delicious caramelized onions, but the texture and flavor nuances may vary slightly between the two types of pans. Ultimately, the decision may depend on factors such as the desired texture, ease of use, and personal experience with each type of pan.

Stainless steel pans are also mentioned as a possibility, but there are mixed reviews on their effectiveness

While non-stick pans are great for making pancakes and eggs, they are not the best choice for caramelizing onions. Instead, a cast-iron skillet is recommended. This is because, as the onions cook, a fond will develop at the bottom of the pan, and scraping and stirring it into the onions will make their flavour richer. However, stainless steel pans are also mentioned as a possibility, but there are mixed reviews on their effectiveness.

One source states that stainless steel pans are the only way to hold all the slices and get good, consistent surface contact when caramelizing a lot of onions. The user does mention that they would use a non-stick pan if they had a larger one, as they would have to do it in batches with their current stainless steel pan. Another source mentions that they have had good results with a bigger stainless steel pan, but not with a smaller non-stick one.

On the other hand, another source mentions that they have had good results with non-stick pans, cast iron, and stainless steel as long as they go low and slow. They also mention that they have not done a full-length cook on a non-stick pan, only on stainless steel. One user comments that they have tried a large batch with a bigger stainless steel pan, and it worked wonderfully, but a smaller non-stick pan didn't render the same results.

Another user mentions that they have tried caramelizing onions in a crockpot, an enameled Dutch oven, non-stick, stainless steel, and a cheap wok, and the way it came out best for them was with stainless steel. However, they do mention that they have not tried a full-length cook on a non-stick pan, only on stainless steel.

Finally, one source mentions that cast iron, due to its slightly rough surface, would caramelize onions the best, followed by stainless steel, and then carbon steel, as the latter is slightly more non-stick compared to stainless steel.

The size of the pan is important, as it needs to be large and wide to allow moisture to evaporate

When it comes to caramelizing onions, the size and type of pan you use can make a difference. While a non-stick pan may be your go-to for cooking eggs or pancakes, it's not the best choice for caramelizing onions. Instead, a cast-iron skillet or a heavy-bottomed pan is recommended. The reason lies in the magic that happens as the onions slowly cook: a delicious fond develops at the bottom of the pan, adding depth of flavor to your onions when scraped up and stirred in. This fond is less likely to form in a non-stick pan.

Now, let's talk about the size of the pan. It's important to choose a pan that is large and wide, and here's why: it allows for the moisture to evaporate as the onions cook. If your pan is too small or crowded, the onions will stew in their juices, and this will impact the caramelization process. You want to give those onions room to breathe! A wide surface area is key. For context, if you're cooking 4 onions, opt for a 12-inch or larger skillet, and for 3 onions, a 10-inch skillet is a good size.

The science behind this is that as the onions cook, their juices are released, and the sugars in the onions start to caramelize. If your pan is too small or crowded, this process is hindered, and your onions may end up stewing rather than caramelizing. So, when you're preparing to caramelize onions, remember to choose a pan that is large and wide enough to give those onions the space they need to release their moisture and develop that sweet, complex flavor.

Additionally, when cooking a large batch of onions, you might want to consider using a roasting pan in the oven. This method allows you to cook a large quantity of onions evenly without having to stir them constantly. Set your oven to a low temperature, somewhere between 275-300 degrees Fahrenheit, and let those onions slowly caramelize, stirring them occasionally. This method is perfect for when you want to make a big batch of caramelized onions to store for later use.

Frequently asked questions