Scratching Steel Pans: Harmful?

Scratches on stainless steel pans are generally safe and inevitable, especially with regular use. Stainless steel is considered safe for food contact by the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA), the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), and the US National Science Foundation (NSF). However, deep scratches that expose the aluminium core of clad stainless steel pans can be unsafe due to the reactivity of aluminium with certain foods. Light to moderate scratches are typical and safe for most uses, although they may accelerate the release of nickel and chromium, which can adhere to food. While these metals are not toxic in small quantities, individuals with allergies or sensitivities may be affected. To prevent scratches, it is recommended to use silicone or wooden utensils for cooking and cleaning, along with cleaning powders, instead of abrasive cleaners.

Stainless steel is safe to use even when scratched

Scratches are normal when it comes to stainless steel pans, and they are still safe to use. Stainless steel is a robust material, and it would take a lot of effort to penetrate the exterior enough to expose the aluminium or copper core. Even if your pan is scratched, it is still safe to cook with.

According to the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA), the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), and the US National Science Foundation (NSF), stainless steel is considered safe for food contact. It is made from an iron alloy that consists of chromium and nickel, which protect the steel from corrosion and rust. While small amounts of chromium and nickel can be released into food, even from brand-new pans, these metals are not toxic in small quantities.

If you are concerned about scratching your pans, it is recommended to use silicone or wooden utensils when cooking and cleaning, rather than metal utensils, which can cause scratches. It is also best to clean your pans with cleaning powder and a soft sponge, rather than abrasive cleaners and scouring pads, which can also cause scratches.

While scratched stainless steel pans are safe to use, it is important to note that if you have an allergy or sensitivity to metals, food prepared in a scratched pan could cause irritation. This is because scratched pans may release more nickel and chromium, which can adhere to food and be consumed.

Deep scratches on stainless steel pans can expose the aluminium core, making them unsafe to use

Scratches on stainless steel pans are normal and inevitable. They can occur from everyday use, such as stirring food with a metal fork or spatula, or cleaning the pan with a scrub pad or steel wool. While scratches from day-to-day use are generally safe, deep scratches can be unsafe.

While it would take a lot of effort to penetrate the stainless steel exterior and expose the aluminium or copper core, it is still possible to do so. If you have scratched your stainless steel pan deeply and exposed the core, it is recommended to replace the pan.

To avoid deep scratches on your stainless steel pans, use silicone or wooden utensils for stirring food and cleaning powders instead of abrasive cleaners. Additionally, avoid using metal utensils on nonstick pans, as they can compromise the surface coating and allow potential toxins to leach into your food.

To prevent scratches, use silicone or wooden utensils to stir food and clean with powder instead of abrasive cleaners

Scratches on stainless steel pans are normal and unavoidable. Stainless steel is a soft metal, so it will scratch easily. However, these scratches are superficial and do not affect the performance or safety of the pan. Even high-quality stainless steel pans will develop scratches over time.

To prevent scratches, or at least keep them to a minimum, use silicone or wooden utensils to stir food and cook with. Avoid using metal utensils, as these can scratch the surface of your pan. When cleaning your pan, avoid using abrasive tools like steel wool or harsh cleaners like bleach or oven cleaner, as these can permanently damage the surface. Instead, use cleaning powders like Bar Keepers Friend, or a soft sponge or scouring pad with hot water and dish soap. For tougher stains, you can use baking soda or vinegar.

It is also important to let your pan cool down before cleaning. Do not submerge a hot pan in cold water, as this can cause warping. Instead, deglaze the pan by adding some hot water, which will make cleaning easier and will not damage the pan.

Stainless steel pans with light to moderate scratches are safe for most uses

Scratches on stainless steel pans are generally safe and inevitable. Stainless steel is a soft metal, so scratches are to be expected with everyday use. Light to moderate scratches are safe for most uses, and it would take a lot of effort to expose the aluminium or copper core.

According to nutrition expert Rebecca Wood, stainless steel cookware with light to moderate scratches should be safe for most uses. However, she also notes that deeper scratches may accelerate the release of some chemicals, and food prepared in damaged stainless steel cookware could irritate those with allergies or sensitivity to metals.

Stainless steel is composed of iron, chromium, and nickel. Chromium and nickel protect the steel from corrosion and rust caused by exposure to oxygen and the acidic liquids in your food. A 2013 study found that stainless steel leaches small amounts of chromium and nickel into food, even when brand new. The amount leached increases with the acidity of the food and the length of cooking time. However, neither metal is toxic in small quantities, and only those with allergies to these metals may experience adverse effects.

To avoid scratches, it is recommended to use silicone or wooden utensils to stir food and clean with cleaning powder instead of abrasive cleaners.

Food prepared in heavily scratched pans may irritate those with allergies or sensitivity to metals

Scratches on stainless steel pans are not necessarily unsafe. However, it is important to note that scratched stainless steel cookware may accelerate the release of certain chemicals, which could be harmful to individuals with allergies or sensitivity to metals.

When a stainless steel pan is scratched, it can start to lose nickel and chromium during use. These metals can then adhere to food and be consumed. While neither nickel nor chromium is considered toxic in small quantities, those with allergies or sensitivity to these metals may experience adverse reactions after eating food prepared in heavily scratched stainless steel cookware.

To minimize the risk of exposure to nickel and chromium, it is recommended to use utensils made from bamboo, nylon, or silicone when cooking with stainless steel pans. Additionally, cleaning stainless steel cookware with light pressure and non-abrasive materials can help prevent scratches and reduce the potential for metal release.

It is worth noting that the impact of scratches on stainless steel pans is primarily a concern for individuals with allergies or sensitivity to metals. For those without such allergies or sensitivity, cooking with lightly or moderately scratched stainless steel pans is generally considered safe. However, it is always advisable to exercise caution and maintain cookware properly to ensure the safest possible cooking environment.

In summary, while scratches on stainless steel pans may not be inherently dangerous, they can potentially cause issues for individuals with allergies or sensitivity to metals. To minimize the risk of exposure to nickel and chromium, it is important to use appropriate utensils, clean cookware gently, and avoid heavily scratched pans if you have known allergies or sensitivity to metals.

Frequently asked questions