Pan-Frying Vs. Pan-Searing: What's The Difference?

Pan-frying and pan-searing are two different cooking methods, but they share some similarities. Both techniques use high heat and oil to cook food, and they can both result in a golden crust forming on the food's surface. However, there are some key differences between the two methods. Pan-frying is a complete cooking technique, meaning that when a food has been pan-fried, it is ready to be served. On the other hand, searing is typically an incomplete process and is often a step in a larger cooking process. For example, you might sear a steak in a pan before finishing it in the oven. Searing is done quickly and only affects the surface of the food, giving it a brown crust and adding flavour and texture.

Pan-frying is a complete cooking technique

There are two basic types of pan-frying: a dry-fry, or sear, and a shallow-fry. The sear requires very little oil and, if using a marbled cut, no oil at all. This is an excellent way to enhance the flavour as it allows for intense browning and the Maillard reaction, a French term for when meat's amino acids and sugars merge after being subjected to intense heat. Shallow-frying, on the other hand, requires more oil and is often used when preparing breaded meats, such as fried chicken or breaded pork chops.

When pan-frying, it is important that the heat remains at a constant, medium-high temperature; otherwise, any breading will absorb the oil and become soggy. The best cuts for pan-frying are naturally tender and of uniform thickness with a flat, wide surface area, like steaks, chops, and poultry breasts. You will want to use a pan that is bigger than you think you need to avoid overcrowding, which is key to achieving that desired browning.

Pan-frying is an effective way to add a rich, caramelized flavour to food, as well as retain its moisture and tenderness. It is a quick process that gives fantastic tasting results and a crispy surface.

Searing is an incomplete process

Searing is an incomplete cooking process, a step in a larger process. It is a surface treatment that only affects the exterior of the food item, browning or caramelising its surface. Searing can be done before roasting, braising, or other finishing methods. For example, a pan-seared steak is typically seared in a cast-iron skillet on a stovetop and then transferred to a hot oven to finish cooking.

Searing is a quick process that is done over high heat, and it only takes a few minutes per side. The pan should be hot enough for the moisture in the food to escape in the form of steam, which keeps the oil from soaking into the food. The high heat also helps create a golden brown exterior on the food.

Searing is not limited to pans and can be done on a grill, griddle pan, or even over an open flame. However, a pan is typically used as it is the most convenient method.

While searing and pan-frying share some similarities, such as the use of high heat and oil, they serve different purposes in the cooking process. Pan-frying is a complete cooking technique, and when something has been "pan-fried," it is done and ready to serve. In contrast, searing is just one step in the cooking process and is often followed by another cooking method to complete the dish.

Searing can be done without a pan

Searing and pan-frying are two different cooking techniques. While pan-frying is a complete cooking technique, searing is an incomplete process and a step in a larger process. Searing is done to build flavour by caramelising the surface of the meat. This process can be done without a pan, as it can also be done on a grill, in a griddle pan, or even over an open flame.

Searing is done at a high temperature, and a stainless steel or cast-iron skillet is best for this type of cooking. It is important to ensure that the pan is hot before adding the meat, and to pat the meat dry to improve contact with the pan and reduce steaming. A thin coating of oil with a high smoke point, such as vegetable oil, should be used to get a uniform surface contact between the meat and the pan.

When searing, it is important to not crowd the pan, as this can cause the meat to steam instead of sear. The meat should also be left uninterrupted for a few minutes to allow it to properly sear and naturally release from the pan. Once all sides of the meat have been seared, it can be transferred to an oven to roast or continue with another cooking method.

Searing does not seal in juices

Searing and pan-frying are two different cooking techniques. While pan-frying is a complete cooking technique, searing is an incomplete process, often a step in a larger process. For instance, searing can be followed by roasting, braising, or grilling.

Now, here's why searing does not seal in juices:

Firstly, it is important to understand that searing creates no "seal" or waterproof barrier to prevent juices from escaping from the inside of the meat. The brown "crust" that forms during searing does not act as a barrier to keep the juices in. This is a common misconception that can be traced back to the German chemist Justus von Liebig, who, in 1847, published this theory in his book "Researches on the Chemistry of Food". However, the crust formed during searing is not waterproof, and juices continue to escape during cooking. The sizzling sound we hear when cooking meat is proof of the juices seeping out and vaporizing.

Most cooking experts agree that searing does not seal in juices. In fact, grilling meat in a pan over high heat can lead to moisture loss. An experiment conducted by Alton Brown demonstrated this by weighing two steaks, one seared before roasting and the other roasted without searing. The steak that was only roasted lost 13% of its weight, while the steak that was seared and roasted lost about 19%. This disproves the idea that searing seals in juices.

Additionally, meat is composed of muscle fibers that contain liquid held in by thin membranes. When meat is heated, the muscle fibers contract, squeezing out the liquid from the cells. This liquid is what forms the meat's juices, and it escapes during cooking, either by leaking out or being converted into steam through evaporation. Therefore, cooking meat, regardless of the method, will always result in some juice loss.

Furthermore, the longer meat is cooked, the more juices it will lose. Searing, as a high-temperature cooking technique, cooks meat quickly, reducing the time for juice loss. However, this does not mean that searing "seals" in the juices. The juiciness of meat is also influenced by the degree of doneness and the resting time after cooking. Overcooking meat can damage the muscle cells, making it impossible for them to reabsorb the juices, resulting in drier meat.

In conclusion, searing does not create a seal to lock in the juices. While it is a valuable step in developing flavour and texture through the Maillard reaction, it does not prevent moisture loss during cooking. The juiciness of meat is influenced by various factors, including cooking time, temperature, and resting.

Pan-frying is also known as shallow frying

Pan-frying and pan-searing are two different cooking techniques that use similar principles: high heat, oil, and flipping the food once or twice. They also create the same desirable result: a golden crust.

Pan-frying is a complete cooking technique. When something has been pan-fried, it is ready to serve. It is done by letting the food sit in the pan and occasionally stirring or flipping. It is usually done with larger pieces of food and at a medium to medium-high heat.

On the other hand, pan-searing is an incomplete process and is often a step in a larger process. It can be done before roasting, braising, or another finishing method. Searing does not have to be done in a pan and can be done on a grill, in a griddle pan, or even over an open flame. The key to searing is to brown or caramelize the surface of the food.

Now, pan-frying is also known as shallow frying. Shallow frying refers to the food being partially submerged in hot oil and flipped once, as opposed to deep-frying where the food is fully submerged the whole time. Shallow frying is usually used to prepare cuts of fish meat and fritters. It is done at a medium to medium-high heat, similar to pan-frying.

Frequently asked questions