Pan Pizza: Costlier, But Worth It?

Pan pizza is a divisive topic among pizza lovers. Some people are willing to pay extra for the crust, while others think it's a rip-off. In some cases, pan pizza can be more expensive than other options, with some restaurants charging up to $1 or $2 extra for this style. This has led to a decline in sales for some businesses, as customers opt for cheaper alternatives or choose to patronize other establishments altogether. However, there are also instances where pan pizza is priced the same as thin crust, leaving consumers confused about the pricing strategy. Ultimately, the pricing of pan pizza varies and can be influenced by factors such as labour intensity, ingredient costs, and business strategies.

Pan pizza is more expensive due to the higher cost of ingredients and labour

Pan pizza is a popular dish worldwide, but it can be more expensive than other pizza varieties due to several factors related to ingredients and labour. Firstly, the cost of ingredients for pan pizza tends to be higher. This is because pan pizza usually requires more dough, which is made from flour, and a greater quantity of cheese, both of which can be relatively expensive. Additionally, meat toppings, such as pepperoni, can significantly increase the cost as they require a lot of processing.

Labour costs also contribute to the higher price of pan pizza. Preparing pan pizza is labour-intensive, from mixing and shaping the dough to assembling and baking the pizza. Pizza restaurants need to pay fair wages to their employees, and these labour costs are often passed on to the customers. The rise in minimum wage rates has also played a part in increasing labour costs for businesses.

Overhead costs, such as rent and utilities, have increased for many pizza restaurants, and these expenses are often reflected in the menu prices. The demand for high-quality and organic ingredients has also led to higher prices. Consumers are increasingly discerning about the quality of their pizza, and restaurants invest in better ingredients to meet these expectations. This is especially true for independent pizzerias that focus on artisanal pies.

Delivery services have also driven up the cost of pan pizza. As more people opt for delivery, restaurants must invest in technology and infrastructure to keep up with the demand. These costs are often included in the menu prices or charged as separate delivery fees. Additionally, packaging costs associated with takeaways have increased, further contributing to the overall expense.

Lastly, inflation and rising operating costs have impacted the price of pan pizza. This includes external factors such as import tariffs and export duties, which have increased the cost of production for pizzerias. All these factors combined result in pan pizza being more expensive than other pizza varieties.

Pizza Hut's pan pizza is $1 more expensive than other crusts

Pizza Hut's decision to charge extra for their pan crust has had a significant impact on sales. According to a Reddit user who claims to work at Pizza Hut, the number of pan pizzas sold dropped drastically overnight after the price change. This change also affected customer behavior, with some customers switching to hand-tossed crust or choosing other pizza restaurants that offer more affordable options.

The reason behind the $1 upcharge for pan pizza at Pizza Hut is twofold. Firstly, pan pizzas require more labor and are more labor-intensive to make. Secondly, pan pizzas use more ingredients and have a higher ingredient cost than other crusts. This is because pan pizzas require more of certain ingredients to ensure the dough cooks evenly and thoroughly.

Some customers have expressed their understanding of the price increase, acknowledging that businesses need to adapt to rising costs. However, others feel that Pizza Hut is becoming too expensive, especially when compared to its competitors. The price increase has led some customers to reduce their tipping for delivery drivers or opt for carry-out instead of delivery to save money.

Despite the controversy, Pizza Hut's pan pizza remains a favorite for many. Some customers appreciate the greasy, heavy texture of the pan crust, which is different from the hand-tossed option. Ultimately, the decision to pay extra for the pan crust depends on individual preferences and budgets.

Pan pizza is fried in oil, making it greasier and heavier

Pan pizza is fried in oil, which gives it a crisp, golden-brown crust. This technique involves placing the dough in a pan with oil and cooking it in the oven or on a stovetop. The oil adds flavour and texture to the crust, making it greasier and heavier than other types of pizza crusts.

Frying the dough in oil is a key step in achieving the characteristic crispiness and golden colour of pan pizza crusts. This is done by coating a pan with oil, placing the dough in the oiled pan, and then cooking it. The oil helps to reduce friction, allowing the dough to spread easily and fry evenly. This results in a crust that is crispy, golden, and fried on the bottom.

The type of oil used is important, as it needs to have a high smoke point due to the high cooking temperature required for pan pizza. Oils such as extra virgin olive oil are not suitable because they tend to smoke at temperatures above 375°F. Instead, oils with higher smoke points, such as pure olive oil, grapeseed oil, peanut oil, canola oil, or vegetable oil, are recommended.

The amount of oil used is also a key factor. It is important to be generous with the oil, as it serves multiple purposes. Firstly, it reduces friction and allows the dough to spread easily. Secondly, it adds an extra layer of cooking to the exterior of the crust, essentially frying it. And lastly, it enhances the flavour of the pizza.

In addition to the oil, the dough itself plays a crucial role in the success of a pan pizza. The dough should be "slack" or "no-knead", meaning it is wet and sticky, allowing it to spread easily in the pan. This type of dough is typically made with high-gluten or bread flour, which gives the crust a chewier texture. The dough is also allowed to rise slowly, usually for at least 8 hours, to develop flavour and chewiness.

Overall, the process of frying pan pizza dough in oil results in a greasier and heavier crust compared to other types of pizza crusts. This technique adds flavour, texture, and colour to the pizza, making it a popular choice for those who enjoy a crispy, golden, and fried crust.

Pan pizzas have a thick crust, usually one or more inches deep

Pan pizzas are characterised by their thick and fluffy crust, usually measuring one inch or more in depth. This is in contrast to hand-tossed pizzas, which have a thinner and flatter crust. The dough used for pan pizzas is slightly thicker and stiffer, as there is limited room for expansion in the pan. This results in a fluffier texture. The dough does rise during baking due to yeast activity, and the final product is spongy and full of bubbles.

The preparation method for pan pizzas also differs from that of hand-tossed pizzas. To shape a pan pizza, dough balls are oiled and spread inside a deep pan. This technique helps achieve the desired shape without tossing or kneading. The pan is then coated with a thin layer of oil before baking, which gives the crust a fried and golden-brown appearance.

The thicker crust of a pan pizza allows for more toppings and cheese. The crust can handle the weight of additional ingredients, and the cheese often extends to the edges of the crust. This results in a softer texture overall, creating a blend of crispiness and juiciness.

The price difference between pan and hand-tossed pizzas varies depending on the pizza chain. For example, Pizza Hut charges an additional fee for their pan crust, while Dominos and other pizza places may also charge a higher price for pan pizzas. The increased cost is due to the labour-intensive nature of preparing pan pizzas and the higher quantity of ingredients used.

Pizza Hut's pan pizza was changed for the first time in 40 years in 2019

In May 2019, Pizza Hut altered the recipe of its Original Pan Pizza for the first time in 40 years. The chain, whose pizzas' specific flavours and textures are synonymous with pizza for many, promised a crispier crust, a crusty exterior, and a chewy interior. This was made possible by a "newly engineered" baking pan. The new recipe also included a different sauce and a new type of stringier, part-skim mozzarella cheese. The pan was redesigned to make the crust more golden and buttery.

Pizza Hut's senior director of culinary innovation and strategy, Penny Shaheen, stated that the new recipe was the result of a "lengthy innovation journey" that combined "art, science, and culinary expertise." The chain had been working on the new recipe in test kitchens for three years.

The change was met with mixed reactions from customers. Some fans of the original recipe were disappointed and hoped for the return of the classic version. They also expressed concerns about the inclusion of ingredients like soy and soybean oil, which could trigger allergic reactions in some customers.

The change in the pan pizza recipe also affected the pricing of Pizza Hut's offerings. The new recipe, with its additional ingredients and altered cooking process, resulted in an increase in the price of pan pizzas. This change in pricing sparked discussions and reactions from customers, with some expressing surprise and disappointment over the additional charge.

The impact of the recipe change and the price increase was significant, with some customers choosing to reduce their tip amounts to offset the higher cost. Others opted to switch to alternative pizza options or different restaurants that offered more affordable choices.

The shift in pricing dynamics influenced sales trends, with pan pizzas experiencing a decline in popularity. The additional charge, along with the change in the default crust option on the website, contributed to a decrease in sales for pan pizzas.

Despite the mixed reactions and adjustments in purchasing behaviour, Pizza Hut stood by its decision to modify the Original Pan Pizza recipe. The company emphasised the time and effort invested in the recipe alteration, showcasing its commitment to innovation and enhancing the customer experience.

Frequently asked questions