Non-Stick Searing: Safe Or Not?

Searing is a cooking technique used to brown the exterior of food items such as steak, pork chops, and burgers. While it is possible to sear food in a non-stick pan, it is generally not recommended due to the potential health hazards associated with heating the pan's coating to high temperatures. Non-stick pans are also not designed for high heat and can be damaged, leading to an unevenly cooked meal. Cast iron or carbon steel pans are typically preferred for searing as they can withstand higher temperatures and produce better results. However, if you only occasionally cook food that requires searing, you can use a non-stick pan by following specific techniques and being mindful of the heat level.

Non-stick pans are not designed for high heat

Non-stick pans are perfect for cooking fish fillets, omelettes, and other delicate, stick-prone foods. However, they are not designed for high heat. Higher temperatures will damage the coating over time, and high heat can also cause the release of harmful toxins, depending on the type of coating on your pan.

If you need to sear a steak, it is better to reach for a stainless steel or cast-iron pan. While non-stick pans are great for some cooking tasks, it is best to know when to use and not use them.

Exposing a non-stick pan to high heat, even if only for a few minutes, can ruin the non-stick surface. A single session at temperatures above 500° Fahrenheit or 260° Celsius is sufficient to destroy any PTFE-based non-stick pan, regardless of price or quality. PTFE undergoes pyrolysis at high temperatures, during which some of its fluorine compounds vaporise. After pyrolysis, the coating loses many of its non-stick properties, even though it may appear undamaged.

Therefore, it is important to use the right tool for the job. If you need to sear meat, it is better to invest in a cast-iron or carbon steel pan, which can withstand higher temperatures. These pans are also better at retaining heat, resulting in more even cooking.

High heat can damage the coating

While it is possible to sear meat in a non-stick pan, it is not recommended to do so regularly. Non-stick pans are not designed for high heat, and subjecting them to very high temperatures can damage the coating. The coating on non-stick pans can give off dangerous fumes when heated to high temperatures, and it can also break down if heated to near 500°F (260°C) repeatedly. This can be a health hazard, and it will also shorten the lifespan of the pan.

If you are going to sear meat in a non-stick pan, it is important to choose a high-quality pan that is designed to withstand high temperatures. Even then, you should only use high heat occasionally. For thicker cuts of meat, you can start with a cold pan and then turn the heat up to high. This will allow the heat to build gradually without overheating the pan. You should then lower the heat to medium and continue cooking, flipping the meat every couple of minutes. This will allow you to build up a crust gradually without overcooking the meat.

If you are searing meat regularly, it is recommended to use a cast iron or carbon steel pan instead of a non-stick pan. These pans are better able to withstand high temperatures and will give you a better sear. They are also safer to use at high temperatures and will last longer than non-stick pans.

Non-stick pans are potentially toxic

The risk of exposure to these toxic chemicals is heightened when non-stick pans are overheated to temperatures above 500°F (260°C). At such high temperatures, the non-stick coating can break down and emit toxic fumes, causing polymer fume fever or "Teflon flu," with symptoms including fever, chills, muscle tension, and headaches.

While the potential toxicity of non-stick pans is a concern, it's important to note that the risk is primarily associated with overheating. When used at low to medium heat, non-stick cookware is generally considered safe for cooking. Additionally, the migration of PFAS from the pan's surface into food during cooking is not well-established, and the amount of exposure from cookware may be minimal compared to other sources, such as food packaging and drinking water.

To minimize the potential risks associated with non-stick cookware, it is recommended to follow these guidelines:

• Avoid using non-stick pans at high temperatures above 500°F (260°C).
• Do not heat an empty non-stick pan, as it can get too hot.
• Avoid using metal utensils that can scratch the non-stick coating, potentially making it easier for chemicals to migrate into food.
• Opt for alternative materials like cast iron, carbon steel, or ceramic, which are safer and more durable options.

Non-stick pans are not ideal for longevity

Non-stick pans are convenient and easy to use, but they are not designed for longevity. While some people may expect their non-stick pans to last forever, the reality is that these pans typically have a much shorter lifespan, even with proper care.

The non-stick coating on these pans is delicate and can easily be damaged by high heat, metal utensils, and improper cleaning methods. For example, using metal utensils or sharp instruments can scratch and damage the non-stick finish. Additionally, most non-stick cookware is not dishwasher-safe, and even with gentle hand-washing, the coating can gradually wear away over time.

The quality of the pan also plays a significant role in its longevity. Cheap non-stick pans may only last a year or so before the coating starts to deteriorate, while higher-quality pans can last for several years. However, even the best non-stick pans will eventually need to be replaced as the coating wears down and loses its effectiveness.

To prolong the lifespan of a non-stick pan, it is important to follow the manufacturer's care instructions carefully. This includes using only recommended utensils, avoiding high heat, and properly cleaning and maintaining the pan. Even with diligent care, however, non-stick pans will inevitably degrade over time, and users should be prepared to replace them every few years.

In summary, while non-stick pans offer convenience and ease of use, they are not designed for long-term durability. With regular use, the non-stick coating will gradually deteriorate, and the pan will need to be replaced. For those seeking long-lasting cookware, cast iron or stainless steel options may be a more suitable choice.

A cast-iron pan is a better alternative

While it is possible to sear food in a non-stick pan, there are several reasons why a cast-iron pan is a better alternative.

Firstly, cast-iron pans are incredibly durable and long-lasting. Cast iron is made to last a lifetime and, with proper care, can be used for generations. Even if it rusts, it can be restored to a condition almost like new. On the other hand, non-stick pans are not designed for high heat, and using them for searing can damage the coating, shortening their lifespan.

Secondly, cast iron pans have excellent heat retention properties. They take a while to heat up and cool down, but once they are hot, they stay hot, making them ideal for getting a good sear on your food. Non-stick pans, on the other hand, often struggle to reach high enough temperatures for a proper sear, and even if they do, the temperature can drop when you add your food to the pan.

Thirdly, cast iron pans are naturally non-stick when they are properly seasoned. This non-stick surface can be reapplied through a process called "seasoning", where the pan is coated with oil and heated past the smoke point, allowing the fat to polymerize and create a hard, slick surface. While non-stick pans are designed to be non-stick, they can only handle high heat occasionally, and even then, they may not get hot enough for a proper sear.

Finally, cast iron pans are very versatile. They can be used on any heat source, including stovetops, ovens, campfires, and grills, and can be used for a wide variety of cooking methods such as searing, grilling, sautéing, baking, and frying. They come in various shapes and sizes, including skillets, pots, griddles, cake pans, and pizza sheets. Non-stick pans, on the other hand, are not suitable for extended periods of high heat and should be avoided when boiling water or simmering food.

In summary, while it is possible to sear food in a non-stick pan, a cast-iron pan is a better alternative due to its durability, heat retention, natural non-stick properties when seasoned, and versatility.

Frequently asked questions