Steaming Vs Roasting: Which Method Keeps Veggies Healthier?

There are many ways to cook vegetables, but which methods are the healthiest? Steaming and roasting are two popular options, but they affect the nutritional content of vegetables differently. Boiling vegetables can cause a loss of nutrients as they leach into the water, so steaming and roasting are often recommended as healthier alternatives.

Boiling vegetables can cause a loss of nutrients

Boiling vegetables is a convenient and easy way to prepare them, but it can also lead to a loss of nutrients. This is because boiling can cause certain nutrients to leak out of the vegetables and into the water. While this can be mitigated by drinking the water or using it in soups or stews, it is still something to be aware of when deciding how to cook your vegetables.

Nutritionist Lindsey Pine, R.D. says, "Nutrients tend to leach into the water when vegetables are boiled. As long as you don't boil them, you'll save the most nutrients." This is especially true for water-soluble vitamins like vitamin C and B vitamins. Research has shown that boiling broccoli can result in a loss of up to 50% of its vitamin C content. A 2009 study also found that peas, cauliflower, and zucchini lost more than 50% of their antioxidants when boiled.

Another factor to consider is that boiling can affect the flavour of vegetables. Pine notes that boiling can "suck out flavour" and that this is particularly noticeable in vegetables like spinach and Brussels sprouts.

So, if you're looking to retain the most nutrients in your vegetables, it's best to avoid boiling them. Instead, try steaming or roasting them, which can help to preserve or even enhance the nutritional content of your vegetables.

Microwaving is a healthy way to cook vegetables

Microwaving is a convenient, quick, and easy way to cook vegetables, but is it healthy? The short answer is yes. Microwaving vegetables is a healthy cooking method as it preserves nutrients and can even increase the nutritional value of some vegetables.

Microwaves use waves of non-ionized energy, similar to radio waves, to cook food. These waves cause the molecules in food to vibrate and build up thermal energy, heating the food quickly. This rapid cooking time helps to preserve heat-sensitive nutrients such as vitamin C.

Cooking vegetables in water, such as boiling, can cause a loss of nutrients as they leach into the cooking water. For example, boiled broccoli loses glucosinolate, a compound that may give it cancer-fighting properties. Steaming vegetables, including microwave steaming, is a better option as it helps retain more nutrients.

Tips for microwaving vegetables:

• Use microwave-safe dishes, especially glass.
• Add a small amount of water to create steam and preserve nutrients.
• Avoid microwaving cauliflower as it can lead to a loss of vitamins and phytonutrients.

The bottom line:

Roasting vegetables can alter their nutritional profile

However, roasting can also boost other nutrients and make them more accessible to the body. For example, cooked tomatoes provide higher levels of lycopene, which may have cardiovascular benefits. Similarly, roasted carrots have higher levels of carotenoids, which are rich in antioxidants.

It is worth noting that the impact of roasting on the nutritional profile of vegetables depends on the specific vegetable being cooked. For instance, roasting broccoli may reduce its nutritional benefits slightly. On the other hand, roasting is an excellent way to cook vegetables like Brussels sprouts, potatoes, parsnips, cauliflower, onions, and broccoli, as it enhances their flavour and texture.

To minimize nutrient loss when roasting vegetables, it is recommended to use less oil, avoid overheating, and keep the temperature below the smoke point of the oil. Additionally, consider parboiling the vegetables before roasting to reduce the cooking time.

Steaming is the best way to cook vegetables

Steaming is one of the best ways to cook vegetables as it maximises their nutritional value. This is because, compared to other cooking methods, steaming requires a minimal amount of cooking time, a lower temperature, and less water.

Steaming is a healthier way to cook vegetables than boiling, roasting, or baking them. Boiling vegetables can cause a loss of up to 50% of their nutritional value, as the nutrients leach into the water. Roasting and baking vegetables can also compromise some nutrients, although it may boost others.

Steaming uses indirect, moist heat and is a quick process, so the vegetables are exposed to the heat source for a relatively short time. This gentle heat also increases polyphenol levels because the vegetables are not submerged in water.

Steaming works well for vegetables such as broccoli, carrots, sprouts, and green beans. It is less suitable for larger, denser vegetables like potatoes.

Microwaving vegetables is another healthy option, as it also uses little to no water and can heat the vegetables quickly, preserving nutrients such as vitamin C.

Griddling is a healthy alternative to grilling

Griddling is a great way to cook vegetables. It uses a pan with raised edges, usually on a stovetop or in an oven, and gives vegetables a caramelised flavour without the smokiness of grilling.

A 2009 study in the Journal of Food Science found that griddling vegetables preserved the highest levels of antioxidants when compared to boiling, pressure-cooking, baking, microwaving, and frying.

Vegetables that work particularly well for griddling include asparagus, corn, onions, aubergine, peppers, mushrooms, courgette, fennel, and tomatoes.

To griddle vegetables, heat the griddle first. While it's heating, cut the vegetables into thin slices to ensure they cook evenly. Brush olive oil or another cooking oil directly onto the vegetables—don't pour it onto the griddle, as this will affect the flavour and texture. Place the vegetables on the griddle and allow them to caramelise, turning golden. For larger slices, oil the uncooked side before flipping.

Griddled vegetables are a delicious and healthy addition to meals, served hot or cold. They can be enjoyed with pasta and pesto, on top of risotto, or with cheeses, houmous, and bread.

Frequently asked questions