Roast Turkey: Rack Or No Rack?

Roasting a turkey on a rack in a pan is a common method that has its pros and cons. The rack keeps the meat off the bottom of the pan, promoting airflow for even cooking, while the pan collects meat drippings and provides a space to roast vegetables. However, the high sides of a roasting pan can block airflow, leading to uneven cooking. As a result, some people opt for alternative methods such as using a sheet pan or a makeshift rack made of vegetables or aluminium foil. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to use a rack in a pan comes down to personal preference and the desired outcome.

Using a rack helps to keep the skin crispy

Using a rack is a great way to ensure your turkey has crispy skin. The rack lifts the turkey off the bottom of the pan, allowing hot air to circulate around the bird as it roasts. This even cooking means that all surfaces of the skin are exposed to the heat, helping to keep it crispy. Without a rack, the skin on the underside of the turkey may become soggy as it sits in the fat and drippings in the bottom of the pan.

There are a few different types of racks that can be used for roasting a turkey. A flat oven-proof rack is ideal, as it allows for good airflow while also providing more surface area for aromatics and liquid. Roasting racks that come with a roasting pan are also a good option, although they don't provide as much surface area. If you don't have a rack, you can create a DIY rack using balls of aluminum foil, upside-down ramekins, or even chopped vegetables like carrots, potatoes, and onions.

It's important to note that while a rack helps with crispy skin, it's not the only factor. The temperature and cooking time also play a role in achieving crispy skin. Roasting at a higher temperature can help, but be careful not to overcook the meat. Checking the temperature periodically can help ensure your turkey is cooked evenly.

Additionally, the type of pan you use can impact the crispiness of the skin. While a traditional roasting pan with high sides is great for carrying the turkey and holding a large volume of liquid, it can block airflow and impact even cooking. A sheet pan with shorter sides can improve airflow, leading to more even cooking and crispier skin.

In conclusion, using a rack is an important step in achieving crispy skin on your roasted turkey. It ensures even cooking by allowing hot air to circulate around the bird. With a rack, you can avoid soggy skin and enjoy a delicious, crispy-skinned turkey.

A rack is not necessary but helps to keep the turkey raised

While it is not necessary to use a rack when roasting a turkey, doing so does have its benefits. The rack keeps the meat off the bottom of the pan, promoting airflow for even cooking. This is because the point of using a rack is to let the heat circulate around the turkey. The rack also allows more surface area for aromatics and liquid.

If you don't have a rack, you can use a flat oven-proof rack or a v-rack with a stable base. You can also use a makeshift rack by using balls of aluminium foil, upside-down ramekins, or vegetables like carrots, potatoes, and onions. If you're using vegetables, toss them with a few tablespoons of oil before adding them to the pan to keep them moist.

If you choose not to use a rack, be aware that the skin of the turkey may turn out flabby and moist. In this case, you can make turkey cracklings by peeling off any parts of the skin that haven't browned well, coarsely chopping them, and putting them in a hot skillet. The skin will release liquid and fat, and then sizzle until brown and crisp.

Using a rack is a matter of personal preference and the desired outcome. If you want to ensure even cooking and maximise surface area for aromatics and liquid, using a rack is a good idea. However, if you don't have a rack or prefer a moister bird, you can choose to roast the turkey directly in the pan.

A shallow roasting pan is better than a deep one

While a deep roasting pan can accommodate more liquid in the bottom, preventing the bird from drying out, a shallow pan still allows for the addition of some liquid, which can be replaced as needed to prevent scorching. Additionally, a shallow pan is easier to manoeuvre and handle, especially when filled with a heavy bird and hot pan drippings.

Shallow roasting pans, also known as sheet pans or baking sheets, are typically made of aluminium or steel and measure around 18-by-13 inches. They often come with a flat oven-proof rack that lifts the turkey off the bottom of the pan, promoting even cooking and allowing more space for aromatics and vegetables.

When choosing a shallow roasting pan, look for one with sturdy handles that provide a secure grip, even with bulky oven mitts or kitchen towels. Also, consider the thickness and material of the pan, as thinner pans may be more prone to warping. While non-stick coatings can be convenient for easy cleaning, they may not be as durable as uncoated pans.

In summary, a shallow roasting pan is preferable to a deep one when cooking a turkey, as it allows for better heat circulation, easier handling, and more even cooking. With the proper techniques and adjustments, a shallow pan can produce a perfectly cooked, juicy, and crisp-skinned turkey.

Basting does not keep the inside meat moist

While basting is a popular technique used to keep meat moist, some chefs believe that it does not actually keep the inside of the meat moist. The purpose of basting is to add colour, flavour, and crispness to the exterior of the roast. However, it is important to note that basting does not affect the flavour or texture of the meat itself, and will not make the interior more moist, more tender, or more flavourful. The process of roasting in the oven should be enough to achieve a golden-brown exterior without basting.

Basting is a cooking technique that involves coating meat with its own juices, a sauce, or a marinade while it cooks. It is commonly used for turkey, pork, chicken, duck, and beef. While basting can be effective in keeping the surface of the meat moist, it does not impact the interior moisture of the meat. The moisture is lost from the meat surfaces due to the opening of the oven door and the resulting loss of temperature and moisture content in the air.

To prevent moisture loss, it is recommended to minimise the opening of the oven door and avoid temperature fluctuations. Additionally, using a roasting rack can help improve air circulation and promote even cooking. A roasting rack lifts the meat above the bottom of the pan, allowing heat to circulate around the meat. This can be achieved using a flat oven-proof rack or even balls of aluminium foil.

Another factor to consider is the type of pan used for roasting. A roasting pan with high sides can block airflow and affect the even cooking of the meat. On the other hand, a sheet pan with shorter sides allows for better heat circulation, resulting in more uniform cooking. However, shorter sides may not accommodate as much liquid, and handling a shallow pan with hot drippings can be challenging.

In conclusion, while basting can add flavour and moisture to the surface of the meat, it does not impact the interior moisture of the roast. To ensure a moist and flavourful turkey, it is more important to focus on proper cooking techniques, such as using a roasting rack and maintaining a consistent oven temperature, rather than relying solely on basting.

A roasting pan is not necessary

If you don't have a roasting pan, you can use a sheet pan, Dutch oven, or skillet. A rimmed sheet pan with raised edges is a good alternative, especially for larger birds and briskets. This will help contain the juices and drippings, keeping the turkey moist and minimizing mess.

However, it is important to note that without a rack, the bottom of the turkey may become soggy. To avoid this, you can elevate the turkey in some way. This can be done by using a wire cooling rack, balls of aluminum foil, upside-down ramekins, or even a bed of coarsely chopped vegetables like potatoes, carrots, and onions. Elevating the turkey will help air circulate for even cooking and produce crispier skin.

Additionally, it is important to ensure that your chosen vessel is large enough to accommodate the turkey. For a full-sized turkey, a standard 9-by-13-inch cake pan or casserole dish may be too small. A foil roasting pan can be used, but it is flimsy and should be placed on a sturdy baking sheet for stability.

In summary, while a roasting pan is convenient, it is not necessary to cook a delicious, moist, and crispy-skinned turkey. With some creativity and a few simple substitutions, you can achieve excellent results without one.

Frequently asked questions