Steam Vs Boiling Water: Which Cooks Faster?

Boiling and steaming are two different cooking methods that have been used for thousands of years. Boiling involves submerging food in water, whereas steaming cooks food with the steam produced by boiling water, without direct contact with the water. While both methods have their advantages, this paragraph will focus on the question of which technique cooks food faster.

Steaming is faster because steam is hotter than boiling water

Steaming is faster than boiling because steam is hotter than boiling water. When water is boiled, the food is sitting in hot water, and the heat is transferred through conduction. However, steam is packed with extra energy. This is because, to turn water into steam, water absorbs a lot of heat (known as the latent heat of vaporization).

Steam at 100 °C carries a lot more energy than just hot water. When steam hits the surface of cooler food, it condenses back into water, releasing this extra energy into the food. This means that steaming can transfer more than five times the energy that boiling water can.

Steaming is also more energy-efficient than boiling because it requires less water. It also has excellent thermodynamic heat transfer properties.

Additionally, steaming is considered a gentler cooking method than boiling, which can be important for delicate foods. It helps retain more nutrients and results in a moist texture for the food.

Steaming is more energy-efficient as it requires less water

Steaming is a cooking method that uses steam, often generated by a food steamer or a wok. It is considered a healthy and efficient technique that can be used for various foods, including vegetables, meats, and dumplings. One of the key advantages of steaming is its energy efficiency compared to boiling.

Steaming is more energy-efficient than boiling because it requires less water. When steaming, only a small amount of water is needed to generate steam, which then cooks the food. In contrast, boiling requires a larger amount of water to fully immerse the food. This difference in water usage leads to several energy-saving benefits.

Firstly, it takes less energy to heat a smaller amount of water to generate steam than to boil a larger volume of water. This means that steaming can reduce the time and energy required to heat the water to the cooking temperature. Additionally, with steaming, the water is continuously boiled to produce steam, which carries heat to the nearby food. This continuous process ensures that the food is cooked efficiently without the need for a large volume of boiling water.

Another advantage of steaming is that it utilizes the excellent thermodynamic heat transfer properties of steam. Steam is created when water absorbs a significant amount of heat, known as the latent heat of vaporization. This extra energy is then released when the steam condenses back into water on the surface of the cooler food. As a result, each gram of steam can transfer more energy to the food than the same amount of boiling water, leading to faster and more efficient cooking.

Furthermore, steaming is often done in enclosed vessels, such as steamers with lids, which helps retain the steam and minimize heat loss during cooking. This design also allows for cooking multiple dishes simultaneously, as steam can circulate and cook food on different tiers or levels.

In summary, steaming is more energy-efficient than boiling because it requires less water, resulting in reduced heating time, effective heat transfer through steam condensation, and minimized heat loss due to enclosed cooking vessels. These factors contribute to a faster and more energy-efficient cooking process when steaming compared to boiling.

Boiling dilutes the taste of food

Boiling water is not the same as steaming. Boiling requires submersion in water, and this can cause osmosis, where the food soaks up some water and the water soaks up some of the food. This can result in the food becoming waterlogged and losing flavour.

Steaming, on the other hand, is a gentler method that provides a wet, non-drying heat without the food soaking up much water. It also prevents the leaching of colour, nutrients, and flavour from the food. This is why some recipes specify steaming as the cooking method.

When you boil food, the water temperature cannot exceed 100°C, but steam can get far hotter than that. This means that steaming cooks food much faster than boiling.

However, the choice between boiling and steaming depends on the type of food being cooked. For example, pasta and rice need to be boiled so that they soak up the water. On the other hand, dumplings should be steamed because they are delicate and would dissolve if boiled.

Additionally, the container used for boiling water can influence its taste. If the container is not sanitised, the boiled water will taste unpleasant.

Boiling can cause food to become waterlogged

When boiling, food is sitting in hot water. The water at 100 °C touches the surface of the food and heats it up. This is simple heat transfer through conduction. Boiling water gives you a certain amount of energy to raise the temperature of the food by 1 °C.

Steaming is faster and more energy-efficient than boiling because it requires less water and takes advantage of the excellent thermodynamic heat transfer properties of steam. Steam is still at 100 °C, but it's packed with extra energy. To turn water into steam, water absorbs a lot of heat (called the latent heat of vaporisation). Each gram of steam carries a lot more energy than just hot water.

When that steam hits the surface of cooler food, it condenses back into water, dumping all that extra energy right into the food. This means that a small amount of steam can transfer more than five times the energy of a much larger amount of boiling water, just by condensing.

This is why food can become waterlogged when boiled. Boiling exposes the food to a lot of water, and the water is less efficient at transferring heat than steam.

Boiling can result in a loss of nutrients

Boiling, simmering, and poaching are similar methods of water-based cooking. These techniques differ by water temperature, with poaching being the coolest and boiling the hottest.

While cooking food improves digestion and increases the absorption of many nutrients, boiling can reduce levels of some vitamins and minerals. For example, vitamin C is water-soluble and heat-sensitive, so it can leach out of vegetables when they are boiled. In fact, boiling reduces vitamin C content more than any other cooking method. Broccoli, spinach, and lettuce may lose up to 50% or more of their vitamin C when boiled. B vitamins are also heat-sensitive, and up to 60% of thiamine, niacin, and other B vitamins may be lost when meat is boiled.

However, when the liquid containing meat juices is consumed, 100% of the minerals and 70-90% of B vitamins are retained. Boiling fish has also been shown to preserve omega-3 fatty acid content more than frying or microwaving.

Water-based cooking methods cause the greatest losses of water-soluble vitamins but have very little effect on omega-3 fats.

Steaming is one of the best cooking methods for preserving nutrients, including water-soluble vitamins, which are sensitive to heat and water. Researchers have found that steaming broccoli, spinach, and lettuce reduces their vitamin C content by only 9-15%.

When it comes to cooking food, there is no one-size-fits-all approach. Each cooking method has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the best method will depend on the specific food being cooked and the desired outcome.

Frequently asked questions