Understanding Dry Sump Oil Pans: Performance And Functionality

Dry sump and wet sump refer to two different types of oil systems used in cars. The purpose of an oil system is to lubricate the engine and its various parts. Oil then drains from the system and collects in a sump at the base of the engine. In a wet sump system, the oil is stored in an oil pan, whereas in a dry sump system, the oil is stored in an external reservoir. Wet sumps are typically used for smaller engines and commercial cars, while dry sumps are used for high-performance cars, such as sports vehicles and racing cars, as they offer greater power and control.

Dry sump oil pans are used in racing cars

Wet sump oil pans are used in 99% of street cars. They have a conventional oil pan with a dipstick, where the oil is stored and supplied to the oil pump. The oil is sucked up through a pickup tube and into the stock oil pump, where it is filtered and supplied to the engine under pressure. This system works well for highway use, but it presents problems under racing conditions. The oil is subjected to extreme cornering forces and tends to "crawl" up the sides of the pan, away from the pick-up, leading to pressure loss and a reduction in horsepower.

Dry sump systems, on the other hand, use a separate tank or reservoir to contain the stored oil. This reservoir is typically tall and narrow, allowing for improved oil temperature control and increased oil capacity. The dry sump oil pump has a minimum of two stages, with one stage for pressure and the remaining stage(s) for scavenging the oil out of the dry sump pan and returning it to the top of the tank or reservoir. This design ensures consistent oil pressure and prevents engine oil starvation, resulting in improved engine reliability. Additionally, the shallow oil pan of a dry sump system allows the engine to be mounted lower in the chassis, improving vehicle handling and stability.

While dry sump systems offer these advantages, they also come with increased cost, complexity, and weight compared to wet sump systems. They require more plumbing and fittings, which increases the potential for leaks. The large external reservoir and pumps can also be challenging to position around the engine. Despite these drawbacks, dry sump systems are favoured in racing cars due to their superior performance and reliability under high-speed and high-acceleration conditions.

Overall, dry sump oil pans are used in racing cars to enhance engine reliability, increase oil capacity, improve vehicle handling, and maximize engine power. These benefits are crucial for high-performance racing applications, justifying the adoption of dry sump technology despite its complexities and higher costs.

They are more complicated and expensive

Dry sump oil pans are more complicated and expensive than wet sump systems. They require more pumps, plumbing, and fittings, which increases the potential for leaks and the chances of system failure. The additional components also make the system more complex to package and install, and the external pumps can fail without warning.

The cost of a dry sump system is significantly higher than that of a wet sump system. The pumps alone can add $2,000 to $4,000 to the overall cost. The complexity and expense of a dry sump system are offset by its advantages, such as improved engine reliability, increased oil capacity, and better vehicle handling and stability. However, these benefits may not always be necessary, especially for street cars that do not encounter high g-forces or racing conditions.

The extra pumps and lines in dry-sump systems also require additional oil and maintenance. The large external reservoir and pumps can be challenging to position within the engine bay due to their size. This complexity adds weight and bulk to the system, making it less suitable for some applications.

Overall, while dry sump oil pans offer improved performance and reliability, they come at a higher cost and with increased complexity when compared to wet sump systems.

They improve vehicle handling

A dry sump oil pan improves vehicle handling by lowering the vehicle's centre of gravity. In a wet sump system, the oil pan has to be large and deep enough to hold four to six quarts of oil. This means that the engine sits higher in the vehicle. Conversely, a dry sump system stores oil in an external reservoir, freeing up space under the hood. This allows the engine to be mounted lower in the vehicle, lowering the centre of gravity and improving handling.

A lower centre of gravity is particularly advantageous for racing cars, which may encounter high g-forces when cornering. A lower centre of gravity also improves aerodynamics, which is beneficial for high-speed vehicles.

In addition to improved handling, a lower centre of gravity can also improve vehicle stability. This is because a lower centre of gravity reduces the risk of the vehicle rolling over during cornering or other manoeuvres.

The weight distribution of a vehicle can also be modified by locating the external oil reservoir away from the engine. This can further improve vehicle handling, particularly when combined with a lower centre of gravity.

While a dry sump system can improve vehicle handling, it also has some disadvantages. Dry sump systems are more complex, heavier, and more expensive than wet sump systems. They also require more space in the engine compartment due to the external reservoir and additional pumps. However, for high-performance vehicles, the advantages of a dry sump system, including improved handling, may outweigh these disadvantages.

They are better for high-performance cars

Dry sump oil pans are better for high-performance cars for several reasons. Firstly, they provide better engine reliability due to consistent oil pressure, which helps to prevent engine oil starvation. This is particularly important in high-performance cars that experience high G-forces, as the oil is less likely to climb the sides of the pan and cause a loss of oil pressure, which can lead to engine damage.

Secondly, dry sump systems offer improved horsepower due to reduced air friction and viscosity. The oil in the crankcase can be minimised as it is drawn away by scavenge pumps, reducing the drag caused by oil swirling around the crankshaft. This results in improved engine performance and fuel efficiency.

Thirdly, dry sump systems have increased oil capacity due to the external storage tank, which means there is more oil in the system overall. This is advantageous for high-performance cars as it reduces the risk of engine oil starvation during hard cornering or sustained cornering. Additionally, the external tank allows for better control of oil temperature and the removal of gases trapped in the oil.

Lastly, dry sump systems offer improved vehicle handling and stability. The shallow oil pan allows for a lower engine placement, which lowers the centre of gravity of the car. This enhances the handling and makes the car more competitive on the track. The weight distribution can also be optimised by strategically placing the dry sump tank, which is particularly beneficial for racing cars.

While dry sump systems are more complex and expensive than wet sump systems, they offer significant advantages for high-performance cars in terms of engine reliability, horsepower, oil capacity, and vehicle handling. These benefits make dry sump oil pans a common choice for sports cars, racing vehicles, and cars with track intent.

They are not needed for street cars

Dry sump oil pans are not needed for street cars because they are more complex, more expensive, and heavier than wet sump systems. They also take up more room in the engine compartment. Dry sump systems are more prone to failure and leaks due to their increased complexity and additional parts.

Wet sump systems are simpler, easier to assemble, more compact, and lighter than dry sump systems. They are also more cost-effective, as dry sump systems can cost twice as much or more. Wet sump systems are adequate for highway use and smaller engines with lower power consumption, whereas dry sumps are designed for high-performance vehicles that need greater power and control.

Dry sump systems are advantageous for racing cars, high-performance sports cars, and aircraft that experience high G-forces and accelerations. They improve engine reliability by maintaining consistent oil pressure and preventing oil starvation during high G-loads. They also enhance vehicle handling and stability by allowing the engine to be mounted lower in the chassis, lowering the center of gravity.

In summary, dry sump oil pans offer benefits for high-performance vehicles in racing conditions, but they are not necessary for typical street cars. Wet sump systems are simpler, more cost-effective, and suitable for everyday driving conditions.

Frequently asked questions