The Ultimate Cast Iron Pan: A Comprehensive Guide To Choosing The Best

Cast iron pans are durable, efficient, and endlessly useful. They are great for searing, roasting, and frying. When used and cared for properly, cast iron can be an effective alternative to non-stick cookware. While non-stick skillets have a short life expectancy, well-maintained cast-iron cookware can last generations.

The best cast-iron skillet overall is the Field Company No. 8 Cast-Iron Skillet. It is lightweight, has a polished surface, and is easy to manoeuvre. For those on a budget, the Lodge 10.25-Inch Cast-Iron Skillet is a great option. It is durable, has a rough surface texture, and is very affordable.

Best cast iron pan for searing

When it comes to the best cast iron pan for searing, there are a few options that stand out. Here are some detailed descriptions of the top contenders to help you decide which one might be the best fit for your needs:

Lodge Cast Iron Skillet:

The Lodge Cast Iron Skillet is a popular and affordable option, often recommended by chefs and food enthusiasts. It sears superbly, with prices typically ranging from $20 to $30. The pan has a durable build and a non-stick surface, making it ideal for various cooking tasks such as searing steaks, baking cornbread, and frying eggs. It weighs around 5 pounds, which is slightly heavier than some lightweight options but still manageable for most people. Keep in mind that this pan may emit a potent smell and smoke during the first few uses.

Lancaster No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet:

The Lancaster No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet is a lightweight option, weighing just over 4 pounds. It heats up quickly and sears steak beautifully. The smooth surface is non-stick right out of the box, and it produces perfect pan-fried eggs and evenly golden cornbread. The lighter weight makes it easy to manoeuvre, especially when taking it in and out of the oven. However, due to its thin design, it may wobble slightly when heated on a glass-top stove.

Field Company No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet:

The Field Company No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet is another lightweight option, weighing just over 4 pounds. It has a dark grey, silky smooth surface that releases food with ease. The flared sides make up for the lack of pour spouts, allowing for easy pouring of butter or oil. While it doesn't have the traditional pour spouts, it still performs well in the oil pouring test. This skillet is easy to manoeuvre and a pleasure to cook with, but it does come with a higher price tag.

Victoria Cast Iron Skillet:

The Victoria Cast Iron Skillet is a budget-friendly option, usually just a few bucks less than the Lodge skillet. It has a rougher surface and a pitch-black colouring. The arched handle makes it easy to lift and move, and it performed well in various tests, producing an even sear on steak and turning out perfect cornbread. However, like the Lodge skillet, it may emit a strong smell and smoke during the initial uses.

Le Creuset Signature Enameled Cast Iron Skillet:

If you're looking for the benefits of cast iron without the traditional maintenance, the Le Creuset Signature Enameled Cast Iron Skillet is a great option. The enamel coating makes it more non-stick than uncoated cast iron, and it still retains heat well. It heated up very quickly in tests and seared steaks like a dream. This skillet is ideal for sticky dishes like scrambled eggs, as well as acidic foods that are not recommended for uncoated cast iron. However, it is a bit on the heavier side, and the flared sides slightly reduce the cooking area.

In summary, these are some of the best cast iron pans for searing, offering a range of features and price points to suit different needs and preferences. Consider your priorities in terms of weight, manoeuvrability, non-stick properties, and budget to help you make an informed decision.

Best cast iron pan for frying

Frying is one of the best applications for cast iron pans, and there are a few things to consider when choosing the best cast iron pan for frying.

First, cast iron pans are known for their heat retention, which means they can maintain a high temperature even when cold ingredients are added. This makes them ideal for deep frying. Cast iron pans also develop a coating over time that allows them to be used similarly to non-stick pans.

When choosing a cast iron pan for frying, it's important to consider the weight and manoeuvrability of the pan. A heavier pan will retain more heat, which is beneficial for searing thick cuts of meat, but a lighter pan will be easier to handle, especially when frying with one hand. Look for a pan with a comfortable, angled handle that allows for a natural grip and a large helper handle on the opposite side for added support.

The shape of the pan is also important. A pan with slightly sloped sides will make it easier to stir and manoeuvre food, while deeper pans are better for frying larger or heavier items that may splatter. If you plan on deep frying, a Dutch oven-style cast iron pan with higher sides is recommended.

Some recommended cast iron pans for frying include:

• Lodge Chef Collection 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet: This pan is lighter than traditional cast iron skillets, with angled and ergonomic handles, and slightly sloped sides that make it great for searing and roasting.
• Lodge Pre-Seasoned 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet: A deeper and heavier option that is excellent for frying chicken or preparing shallow braises. It has a comfortable handle and a large helper handle for easy manoeuvring.
• Field Company No. 8 Cast-Iron Skillet: A premium, lightweight, and heirloom-quality skillet with a polished surface. It has excellent heat retention and develops a non-stick coating with use.

Best cast iron pan for stir-frying

Cast iron pans are known for their heat retention and non-stick properties. They are durable, efficient, and endlessly useful. While they take a while to heat up, they are great for stir-frying as they can hold a constant temperature. Here are some of the best cast iron pans for stir-frying:

Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet

This skillet is known for its non-stick coating and easy maneuverability. It has excellent heat retention, which is essential for stir-frying. The long handle doesn't heat up as quickly as some other pans, and the lighter weight makes it easy to move on the stovetop and in and out of the oven. The high-sloping walls also help to minimize mess by keeping oil from splashing out of the pan. The Stargazer is a reliable and worthy investment for any kitchen.

Lodge Cast Iron Skillet

The Lodge Cast Iron Skillet is a durable workhorse and a great budget option. It comes pre-seasoned and is very easy to clean. While it is slow to heat up, it retains its temperature well, which is perfect for stir-frying. The silicone handle cover makes it easy to handle, and it performed well in the non-stick tests. The only downside is that it runs a little too hot, so you have to be careful not to burn your food.

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet

This skillet is known for its high-quality design and ease of use. The larger helper handle makes it easy to maneuver, and the sloped sides are great for stir-frying. It heats evenly and allows for a perfect deep brown sear. The enameled cast iron is also low maintenance and never needs seasoning. However, it is shallower than other pans, which can cause a bit more oil splatter.

Field Company No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet

The Field Company No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet is a premium, lightweight option that is easy to maneuver. It has a polished, smooth surface and is made from recycled American iron. While it doesn't have a pour spout, the thin, slightly curved lip makes it easy to pour liquids without making a mess. It developed an even, glossy black patina after a few rounds of seasoning and performed well in the searing and egg tests.

Best cast iron pan for roasting

When it comes to roasting, cast iron pans are a great choice due to their heat retention and ability to develop a non-stick coating. Here are some recommendations for the best cast iron pan for roasting:

Lodge Cast Iron Pan

Lodge offers a range of cast-iron pans, including a 10.25-inch skillet, a 12-inch pre-seasoned skillet, and a 10.5-inch square grill pan. These pans are durable, versatile, and affordable, making them a popular choice for many home cooks. They can be found at various retailers, including Amazon, Walmart, and Home Depot, with prices ranging from $15 to $30.

Lancaster No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet

The Lancaster No. 8 cast iron skillet is another excellent option for roasting. It is lightweight compared to some other cast iron pans, making it easier to handle. This pan is available on the Lancaster website and is also recommended by Serious Eats.

Bayou Classic Cast Iron Roasting Pan

The Bayou Classic cast iron roasting pan is perfect for slow cooking roast turkey, chicken, ham, pot roast, stews, soups, and chili. It features a domed cast iron lid, and you can find it on Amazon.

Pit Boss 6qt. Cast Iron Roaster with Lid

This cast iron roaster with a lid is a great option for roasting and can be found on Amazon. It has a capacity of 6 quarts and is currently one of the top choices on the platform.

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Rectangular Roaster

Le Creuset is a well-known brand for enameled cast iron cookware, and their rectangular roaster is a great option for roasting meats and vegetables. It has a capacity of 7 quarts and can be purchased on Amazon.

Rachael Ray NITRO Cast Iron Roasting Lasagna Pan/Baking Dish

If you're looking for a cast iron pan that can handle both roasting and baking, the Rachael Ray NITRO pan is a good choice. It comes in a unique agave blue colour and can be found on Amazon.

When choosing a cast iron pan for roasting, consider the size, weight, and whether it comes pre-seasoned. Cast iron pans are versatile and durable, but they may require special care and maintenance to keep them in good condition.

Best cast iron pan for baking

Cast iron pans are known for their heat retention and non-stick properties, making them perfect for searing steaks, frying eggs, and baking cornbread. If you're looking for the best cast iron pan for baking, here are some options to consider:

Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet

The Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet is a super-smooth, made-in-the-USA pan that is both attractive and built to last. It has excellent heat retention, which leads to even browning in whatever you're baking. It also has impressive searing capabilities, giving a nice crust to steaks and pork chops. The Stargazer is relatively lightweight compared to other cast iron pans, and its handle doesn't get too hot, making it easy to manoeuvre. In addition, it has excellent non-stick properties, with not a trace of egg whites sticking to the pan during tests.

Lodge Blacklock Cast Iron Skillet

The Lodge Blacklock Cast Iron Skillet is a lightweight option that heats up quickly and is great for searing. It has a looped handle that stays cool and gives a great hanging option. While its pour spouts are not the best, its non-stick abilities are top-notch. Fried eggs came out of the pan effortlessly, and cornbread came out with a clean release. This pan is easy to maintain and will likely be pretty easy to season over time.

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet

The Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet is a high-quality, beautiful design that never needs seasoning and can be washed in the dishwasher. It has a larger helper handle that makes it easy to manoeuvre, and it heated evenly during tests. It allowed for a perfect deep brown steak crust while searing, and cornbread came out cleanly. This pan is a great quality, durable design that is worth the high price.

Lodge Cast Iron Skillet

The Lodge Cast Iron Skillet is a user-friendly, affordable option. It comes pre-seasoned and is very easy to clean. While it is slow to heat up, it retains temperature well, making it perfect for getting a good sear on steaks. It performed pretty well in non-stick tests – cornbread came out with a clean release, although there was a bit more sticking than desired during the egg test. It also comes with a silicone handle cover, which makes it easy to manoeuvre.

Field Company No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet

The Field Company No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet is a lightweight, premium option that is easy to manoeuvre. It developed an even, glossy black patina after a couple of rounds of seasoning and was able to sear a New York strip steak perfectly. It also fried an egg with no sticking at all. While it doesn't have a pour spout, its thin and slightly curved lip make it easy to pour liquids over the side without making a mess. This pan is a great choice for experienced home cooks who are willing to invest in a premium pan.

Frequently asked questions