Perfect Pan Size For Caramel Making

When making caramels, the size and type of pan you use are important considerations. The ideal pan will have a heavy bottom to ensure even heat distribution and prevent hot spots, which can burn your caramel. For home use, a 2-quart pan is typically sufficient, while larger sizes such as 4 quarts and up are better for bigger batches. Additionally, the walls of the pan should be high enough to prevent splattering, especially if you plan to add cream or milk.

In terms of materials, copper, aluminium, and stainless steel are all suitable options. Copper conducts heat efficiently and evenly, making it ideal for caramelisation, but it can be reactive with some ingredients and more expensive. Aluminium is a good all-rounder, offering a wide range of price points, while stainless steel is affordable and non-reactive but may not conduct heat as evenly.

Non-stick pans should generally be avoided when making caramel, as the high temperatures required can damage the coating, and it may peel off into your caramel. Instead, a regular flat pan or a narrower, pot-like saucepan with tall sides can help prevent caramel from bubbling over and making a mess on your countertop.

Pan material: copper, aluminium, stainless steel, or cast iron?

When making caramels, the most important factor to consider is even heating. Hot spots should be avoided, especially when making dry caramel, as you won't be able to stir the mixture. A responsive pan is also necessary for making caramel. While the most evenly heating pans are typically the least responsive, a good sandwiched steel pan with an aluminium core should offer a decent trade-off between evenness and responsiveness on most stove types.

Copper pans are considered the premium option for cooking sugar. They heat up quickly, use less energy, and make it easier to control the temperature, which is crucial when making caramel. However, they are expensive and not a necessity. One user commented that they made caramels for years without a copper pan "with great success".

Aluminium pans are inexpensive and will heat well, but there is a risk of the aluminium leaking into your caramels and affecting their taste and colour.

Stainless steel pans are a good option for making caramel. They are typically responsive and can be used on a variety of stove types. Stainless steel pans with an aluminium or copper core will heat more evenly.

Cast iron pans are not recommended for making caramel on a resistive stove, as they are unresponsive and will display considerable hot spots. However, one user commented that they use a small enamelled Dutch oven for making caramel on an induction plate.

Pan type: flat or pot-like?

When making caramels, you can use a flat pan or a pot-like saucepan. The choice between the two depends on the quantity of caramels you want to make and the ease of cleaning you prefer.

Flat pans are ideal if you are making small batches of caramel. They have a large surface area, which allows for even heating and makes it easy to monitor the colour of the caramel as it cooks. However, flat pans may not have tall enough sides to prevent the caramel from bubbling over and creating a mess on your countertop.

On the other hand, pot-like saucepans are better suited for larger batches of caramel. They have taller sides, which help to prevent splattering and contain the caramel as it boils. Additionally, saucepans typically have a lid, which can be useful for controlling the evaporation of the caramel mixture. However, one disadvantage of using a saucepan is that it may be more difficult to clean than a flat pan due to its narrower shape.

Ultimately, the decision between using a flat pan or a pot-like saucepan depends on your personal preferences and the specific requirements of your caramel recipe. Both types of pans can be effective for making caramels, so choose the one that best suits your needs and cooking style.

Pan size: 2-quart or 4-quart?

When it comes to choosing between a 2-quart and a 4-quart pan for making caramels, the decision depends on several factors, including the quantity of caramels desired, the type of stove or heat source being used, and personal preferences for pan depth and diameter. Here's a detailed breakdown to help you decide:

Quantity of Caramels:

If you're making a small batch of caramels, a 2-quart pan should be sufficient. A 4-quart pan is better suited for larger quantities or bigger-scale production. Consider how many caramels you want to make in one go, and choose the pan size accordingly.

Heat Source:

The choice between a 2-quart and a 4-quart pan may also depend on your heat source. If you're using an induction stove, a smaller and more responsive 2-quart pan might be preferable. On the other hand, if you have a resistive stove, a larger 4-quart pan with better heat distribution might be a better option.

Pan Depth and Diameter:

The depth and diameter of the pan are important considerations. For caramels, the ideal depth is between 1 and 5 cm. A 2-quart pan typically has a smaller diameter, resulting in a shallower depth, while a 4-quart pan might offer more depth. However, keep in mind that a deeper pan may also require longer utensils to stir the caramel effectively.

Ease of Handling:

A 2-quart pan is generally easier to handle due to its smaller size and weight. If you prefer a more lightweight and manoeuvrable option, a 2-quart pan might be the right choice.

Personal Preference:

Ultimately, the decision between a 2-quart and a 4-quart pan comes down to personal preference. If you have the space and don't mind a heavier pan, a 4-quart option might work well. However, if you're looking for something more compact and lightweight, a 2-quart pan is a good choice.

Pan features: non-stick, heavy-bottomed, or long-handled?

When making caramels, the most important features to look for in a pan are even heating and responsiveness. A good option is a heavy-bottomed pan, which can help with even heating and prevent hot spots. Additionally, a long-handled pan can provide a comfortable grip and keep your hands away from the heat. Here is a more detailed explanation of the different features:

Non-stick Pans:

• Non-stick pans are ideal for cooking delicate foods like eggs and fish without sticking.
• They are usually lightweight and easy to manoeuvre.
• However, non-stick coatings can break down at high temperatures, so it's important to avoid overheating the pan.
• Some people also have concerns about the environmental and health impacts of the chemicals used in non-stick coatings.

Heavy-bottomed Pans:

• Heavy-bottomed pans, such as those made of cast iron or stainless steel, can distribute heat more evenly.
• They are generally heavier and may be more difficult to handle than non-stick pans.
• Heavy-bottomed pans are a good choice for induction cooktops as they heat up quickly and evenly.

Long-handled Pans:

• A long handle can provide a comfortable grip and keep your hands away from the heat.
• Look for a handle that is angled correctly for easy flipping and manoeuvring.
• Some handles have a removable silicone sheath for added heat protection.

In summary, when choosing a pan for making caramels, look for one with even heating and responsiveness. A heavy-bottomed pan can help with even heat distribution, while a long-handled pan provides a comfortable grip. Additionally, consider the material and coating of the pan to ensure it is suitable for the type of stovetop you have and your preferred cooking methods.

Pan brand: Scanpan, Cuisinart, or Mauviel?

When making caramels, the most important thing to consider is even heating. You will also need a responsive pan. A good sandwiched steel with an aluminium core should offer a decent trade-off between evenness and responsiveness on most stove types. You will also need the correct size pan. If your caramel is less than 1 cm deep, it is very hard not to burn it. If it is deeper than 5 cm, there is too much of a heat gradient in the depth. Choose the pan diameter so that your caramel depth will be between 1 and 5 cm. If you are going to add any liquid to the caramel, you will need a deep-walled vessel to catch the foam. Use a deep saucepan or a small pot instead of a frying pan. You want a 10 cm wall above the caramel level.

Now, let's look at the three brands you've mentioned: Scanpan, Cuisinart, and Mauviel. Scanpan is a family-owned business based in Ryomgaard, Denmark, where they have been creating high-quality cookware for over thirty decades. They are one of the world's leading producers of PFOA-free non-stick products. Scanpan is also environmentally conscious and uses 100% recycled aluminium in their products. Their Classic 3-Quart pan is 5″ wide, 13″ long, and 8″ deep and is also available in 1 and 2-quart sizes. The Classic range is not induction-compatible, but their CTX range is. The CTX Nonstick Skillet features a five-layer clad-aluminum construction and a ceramic titanium non-stick surface. The Classic and CTX ranges are dishwasher-safe, but it is recommended to keep the CTX skillet out of the dishwasher.

Cuisinart offers a number of affordable cookware sets and individual pans. Their cookware ranges include the CastLite Non-Stick Cast Iron Cookware, the Chef’s Classic Non-Stick Stainless, MultiClad Pro Non-Stick Skillets, and the MultiClad Pro. Their products are non-stick, oven-ready, dishwasher and broiler-safe, induction-ready, and available in different colours. However, they are manufactured in China, whereas Scanpan is produced in Europe.

Mauviel is a French brand that manufactures some of the best pans ever made. Their Stainless Steel 1830 range is amazing and is likely to be the last pan of its size that you ever buy. They do have some products that are manufactured in China under licence, so be aware of that when purchasing.

Overall, if you are looking for a premium non-stick option, Scanpan is a great choice. If you are looking for something more affordable, Cuisinart might be a better option. If you want something that is likely to be a lifetime purchase, consider Mauviel.

Frequently asked questions