The Deglazing Dilemma: Why Cast Iron Pans Don't Make The Cut

While cast iron pans are great for cooking, they are unsuitable for deglazing due to the risk of affecting the seasoning of the pan. Deglazing involves adding liquid to a hot pan, which can cause the seasoning to start flaking off. The type of liquid used is also important; highly acidic liquids such as vinegar or wine can hurt the seasoning and impart a metallic taste to the food. However, some people have successfully deglazed their cast iron pans with wine, broth, or water without any issues. It is recommended to avoid using vinegar or other strongly acidic liquids for deglazing cast iron pans.

Deglazing cast iron with vinegar or wine can hurt the seasoning

Deglazing a cast-iron pan with vinegar or wine can hurt the seasoning of the pan. The true seasoning of a cast-iron pan is polymerized/denatured oil which has adhered to the surface of the pan. While deglazing, the oil and cooked-on food remnants will be removed, and the underlying seasoning will generally be safe. However, if the pan is overheated and then hit with flash-boiled liquid at the same time, the seasoning may start to flake off.

Additionally, cast iron corrodes at a pH lower than 4.3. Pure white vinegar (5%) has a pH of 2.4, and wine is around 3.2 to 3.8. Therefore, undiluted vinegar or wine can ruin the pot and release a large amount of iron into the food. A splash of vinegar or wine for sauce or deglazing is okay, but pouring a significant amount straight into the pan will ruin the cookware and potentially your health.

To avoid hurting the seasoning of a cast-iron pan, it is recommended to dilute the vinegar or wine with water before deglazing.

Acidic sauces can cause concern when deglazing cast iron

Deglazing a cast-iron pan with an acid-based liquid can cause concern for a few reasons. Firstly, the length of time the acid is in contact with the cast iron can affect the taste of the food. If the acid is in the pan for too long, it can cause an off-putting metallic taste to the food. This is due to the acid reacting with the exposed metal of the pan.

Secondly, the acid can also affect the seasoning of the pan. The seasoning of a cast-iron pan is created by polymerized/denatured oil that has adhered to the surface. If the pan is overheated and then deglazed with an acid, it can cause the seasoning to start flaking off.

It is worth noting that some sources suggest that a well-seasoned pan should be able to withstand deglazing with an acidic liquid. However, it is generally recommended to avoid deglazing cast iron with vinegar or other strongly acidic liquids and to instead use water, broth, or wine.

Overheating and flash-boiling liquid can cause seasoning to flake off

While cast iron pans can be deglazed, there are some important things to keep in mind to avoid damaging the pan's seasoning. Overheating the pan and then adding flash-boiled liquid is one of the main reasons the seasoning may start to flake off.

The seasoning of a cast-iron pan is created by polymerizing/denaturing oil, which then adheres to the surface of the pan. This process creates a non-stick surface, allowing you to cook with less fat or oil. However, if the pan is overheated and then rapidly cooled by adding flash-boiled liquid, it can cause the seasoning to flake off. This is because the extreme temperature change can shock the polymerized oil, causing it to contract and expand rapidly, which can lead to flaking.

To avoid this issue, it is important to control the temperature of the pan and the liquid you are using for deglazing. First, ensure that the pan is not overheated. Then, when adding liquid, use room-temperature or warm liquid and avoid flash-boiling it. This will help prevent shocking the seasoning and reduce the risk of flaking. Additionally, using a neutral liquid such as broth or wine is recommended, as strongly acidic liquids like vinegar can also damage the seasoning.

Remember, after deglazing, it is important to lightly oil the pan to maintain the seasoning. By following these steps, you can safely deglaze your cast-iron pan without worrying about damaging the seasoning.

Deglazing with vinegar or wine can impart a metallic taste to the food

While deglazing with vinegar or wine can add flavour to your dish, it can also impart a metallic taste to the food. This is because cast iron pans are reactive to acidic ingredients, such as wine and vinegar. The acidity of these liquids can strip away the seasoning on the pan, exposing the iron and causing a metallic taste to be imparted to the food.

To avoid this, it is recommended to use less acidic liquids for deglazing, such as broth, water, or wine only in small amounts. If you do choose to deglaze with wine or vinegar, it is important to take care not to overheat the pan and then add the liquid, as this can cause the seasoning to start flaking off. Additionally, make sure to oil the pan lightly after deglazing to protect the seasoning.

It is worth noting that some people have reported success in deglazing their cast iron pans with wine or vinegar without any issues. However, it is generally recommended to avoid highly acidic liquids to be on the safe side and preserve the seasoning of the pan.

If you notice a metallic taste in your food after deglazing with vinegar or wine, it is likely due to the reaction between the acid and the cast iron. In this case, it is best to strip and reseason your pan or, if the issue persists, purchase a new one.

Tomato sauces are not recommended for cast iron due to their high acidity

Deglazing involves pouring a small amount of liquid into a hot pan to scrape up any cooked-on food and create a sauce. While deglazing a cast-iron pan is generally safe, some liquids should be avoided. Liquids with a high acidity, such as vinegar, can damage the seasoning of the pan. This is because the acid interacts with the iron, loosening and leaching trace amounts of molecules from the metal into the food.

Tomato sauces, therefore, are not recommended for cast iron due to their high acidity. While cooking acidic tomato sauce in a cast-iron pan for a short period will not have any dire consequences, leaving the sauce in the pan for an extended period can cause unwanted metallic flavours to emerge. In one test, tasters detected a metallic flavour in a tomato sauce only after it had simmered for 30 minutes.

To avoid this, it is recommended to use an enameled cast-iron pan, which has an enameled coating that makes it safe to cook acidic ingredients for any length of time. If using a regular cast-iron pan, ensure that it is well-seasoned before use, as seasoning creates a barrier that protects the iron from interacting with the acid. Additionally, remove acidic dishes from the pan promptly after cooking and transfer any leftovers to an airtight container.

Frequently asked questions