Soup Slurp Or Soup Skip: Why Chinese Hot Pot Leaves The Broth Behind

Hot pot is a popular Chinese dish where a variety of raw ingredients, such as meat and vegetables, are cooked in a simmering broth. While hot pot is considered a flavourful and nutritious meal, there are several reasons why Chinese people may choose not to drink the soup at the end of the meal.

Firstly, health concerns play a significant role in the decision not to consume the soup. Hot pot soup tends to have high levels of sodium, fat, and purines, which can lead to health issues such as high blood pressure, kidney problems, and even gout. The soup may also contain harmful bacteria, especially after prolonged boiling and the addition of various raw ingredients.

Secondly, cultural and traditional beliefs influence Chinese dining etiquette. In Chinese culture, it is considered important to use separate utensils for handling raw food and cooked food. Drinking the soup directly from the communal pot may be frowned upon as it could potentially spread germs and illnesses.

Additionally, the soup may be discarded due to practical reasons. Hot pot restaurants often have strict food handling policies, requiring any leftover soup to be disposed of rather than saved or taken home.

Lastly, personal preference and taste also come into play. Some people may find the soup too spicy, salty, or oily to drink. Others may simply be too full from the meal to want to consume the soup.

While hot pot soup may be discarded or left unfinished, it is worth noting that some Chinese people do enjoy drinking the broth, especially at home or when taking leftovers home. Overall, the decision to drink or not drink the hot pot soup depends on a combination of health, cultural, practical, and personal factors.

Excessive sodium content

The sodium content in hot pot soup is a major concern for health-conscious individuals. Sodium, which is commonly consumed as salt, is known to elevate blood pressure and increase the risk of cardiovascular disease, congestive heart failure, and kidney disease. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend limiting sodium intake to less than 2,300 milligrams per day, with lower limits for certain at-risk groups.

Hot pot soup, regardless of whether it is canned, jarred, fresh, or frozen, tends to contain an excessive amount of sodium relative to its calorie content. As a result, consuming the soup can quickly lead to exceeding the recommended daily sodium intake. For example, a single cup of chicken noodle soup can contain up to 1780 mg of sodium, which is more than half of the daily limit for a significant portion of the US population.

The high sodium content in hot pot soup can be attributed to the type of broth used as a base. Traditional Chinese hot pot soup often starts with a broth that is very high in sodium, super spicy, or full of oil, or a combination of these factors. These broths, such as the famous Chongqing hot pot, are not typically consumed as drinking soup due to their extremely high sodium levels.

In addition, the process of cooking various ingredients in the hot pot can further increase the sodium content of the soup. Meats, vegetables, and other ingredients may release additional sodium into the broth during cooking, especially if they have been processed or seasoned beforehand. This accumulation of sodium in the soup can make it even more unhealthy to consume, particularly for those with hypertension, diabetes, or kidney disease.

To reduce sodium intake, individuals can opt to make their own hot pot soup at home, using low-sodium broths and fresh ingredients. This allows for better control over the sodium content and overall nutritional value of the meal. However, when dining out at hot pot restaurants, it is important to be mindful of the excessive sodium levels in the soup and consider not consuming it or consuming it in moderation to maintain a healthy diet.

High-fat content

The high-fat content of hot pot soup is one of the main reasons why Chinese people often choose not to drink it. This is especially true for the popular Sichuan-style broth, which contains a significant amount of fat, usually in the form of beef tallow. This high concentration of fat contributes to the rich and aromatic qualities of the soup but can also be a health concern for some individuals.

The fat content in hot pot soup can vary depending on the type of broth used. For instance, the Sichuan spicy broth, also known as "Hong You Guo Di" or "red oil hot pot broth," is characterised by its high-fat content, which gives it a distinctive mouth-numbing and spicy flavour known as "Mala". This style of broth typically includes beef tallow or cooking oil, along with dried chilli peppers, Sichuan pepper, and various spices and aromatics. The combination of these ingredients results in a soup with a rich, aromatic, and spicy flavour profile.

In contrast, a mild hot pot broth, often referred to as "Qing Tang Guo Di" or "clear broth," tends to have a lower fat content. This type of broth typically consists of stock, aromatics, herbs, and sometimes vegetables, resulting in a lighter and more delicate flavour. Chicken, pork, beef, mushroom, or tomato stock can be used as the base for this milder version of hot pot soup.

While some people may choose to consume the soup despite its high-fat content, others may opt to avoid it due to health concerns or personal preferences. It's worth noting that the fat content can vary depending on the specific ingredients and proportions used in the broth, as well as individual dietary needs and restrictions.

When it comes to hot pot soup, it's essential to be mindful of the high-fat content, especially for those watching their fat intake or with specific health considerations. However, for those who enjoy the rich and spicy flavours, the Sichuan-style broth can be a delicious and indulgent treat. Ultimately, the decision to drink the soup or not comes down to personal preference and dietary choices.

Health risks

Drinking hot pot soup can have several health risks, and it is recommended that people only consume hot pot once or twice a month. The soup is often very high in sodium, with some types of broth containing a whopping 3,840mg to 12,778mg of sodium per serving. As a comparison, it is recommended that we consume no more than 2,000mg of sodium per day. In addition, spicy broths tend to be high in fat due to the use of large amounts of oil. Some broths that add coconut milk or fatty meat will also increase the saturated fat content.

The ingredients cooked in the broth can also influence the nutritional value of the soup. Fried or processed foods, as well as dipping sauces, can make the meal even unhealthier. It is advised to choose clear or light-flavoured soups as your base, such as mushroom or cabbage soup, and to include more fresh vegetables and lean meats such as chicken or fish. It is also important to ensure that all food is fully cooked to prevent food poisoning.

Another health risk to consider is the transmission of germs and bacteria when sharing a communal pot. This practice has been linked to the spread of diseases and infections, such as stomach cancer and hepatitis.

Finally, drinking water that is too hot can cause burns or discomfort to the mouth and throat, so it is important to exercise moderation and allow the soup to cool to an appropriate temperature before consuming it.

Cultural norms

Hot pot is a popular dish in China, and while there are no fixed rules about drinking the soup, there are some cultural norms and health considerations that influence people's choices. Here are some cultural norms regarding the consumption of hot pot soup in China:

• Social and Cultural Factors: Hot pot is a social activity enjoyed with family, friends, and colleagues. As such, the soup plays a central role in the dining experience, with diners savouring the flavours that accumulate throughout the meal. However, drinking the soup is not always customary and may be seen as unhealthy or unnecessary, especially in certain regions or among specific demographic groups.
• Health and Safety Concerns: Some people refrain from drinking the soup due to health concerns. Hot pot soup can be high in sodium, fat, and purines, which are associated with health issues like gout, high blood pressure, and kidney problems. Additionally, the prolonged boiling of meat and vegetables may lead to the formation of nitrosamines, a potential carcinogen. As a result, some individuals choose to avoid drinking the soup or consume it in moderation.
• Regional Variations: Hot pot varies across China, with "Southern style" and "Northern style" being the two main categories. Southern styles tend to have spicy broths and focus on seafood, vegetables, and mushrooms, while Northern styles are simpler and emphasise meat, particularly mutton. These regional variations may influence the likelihood of drinking the soup, with some broths being more palatable or healthier than others.
• Personal Preference and Taste: Ultimately, the decision to drink the soup comes down to individual preference. Some people enjoy the rich flavours that develop during the meal, while others may find the soup too spicy, salty, or fatty. Personal taste plays a significant role in whether or not someone chooses to consume the hot pot soup.
• Dining Etiquette: While not a hard-and-fast rule, some diners may avoid drinking the soup to prevent overindulgence or maintain table manners. It is considered rude to dump all the ingredients into the pot at once, and the meal is meant to be savoured slowly. Drinking the soup may be viewed as unnecessary, especially if one is already full from the solid ingredients.

Safety concerns

Drinking hot pot soup has been associated with several health risks. Firstly, the soup tends to have an excessively high amount of sodium, with some types of broth containing up to 12,778mg of sodium, far exceeding the recommended daily intake. High sodium intake can lead to increased risk of high blood pressure and kidney problems. Additionally, spicy broths used in hot pots have high-fat content due to the use of large amounts of oil. Certain types of broth that include coconut milk or fatty meat also contribute to increased saturated fat consumption.

The raw ingredients cooked in the hot pot soup, such as meat and vegetables, can further impact the nutritional value of the dish. Fried or processed foods, as well as dipping sauces, can make the meal even unhealthier. Consuming undercooked or raw meat also poses a risk of food poisoning.

Another safety concern related to hot pot soup is the potential for cross-contamination when multiple people are dipping food into the same pot. This practice can increase the risk of transmitting bacteria and germs, leading to illnesses.

To ensure safety, it is recommended to use separate utensils for handling raw ingredients and cooked food. It is also important to ensure that all food is thoroughly cooked before consumption.

In addition to these health and safety concerns, the cultural aspect of drinking hot pot soup should be considered. In some regions, such as Hong Kong, drinking the soup is generally frowned upon. It is believed that after a prolonged period of cooking various meats and vegetables, the soup becomes saturated with purines, which may contribute to health issues like gout and kidney stones. Therefore, it is advisable to refrain from drinking the soup to avoid potential health risks.

Frequently asked questions