Lodge Carbon Steel Pans: Rough But Nonstick

Lodge carbon steel pans are pre-seasoned and ready to use straight away. However, many people are perplexed by their rough surfaces, which goes against the idea that carbon steel pans should have a smooth surface to optimise their non-stick properties. Some people dislike the rough surface so much that they return their pans. However, the rough surface does smooth out with seasoning and use.

The rough surface is intentional

The rough surface of Lodge's carbon steel pans is indeed intentional. While the exact reason for this design choice is not known, there are several theories and potential benefits that users have pointed out.

One theory suggests that the rough surface may be designed to help the pan hold its seasoning better. The coarse texture could provide a better surface for the oil to adhere to during the pre-seasoning process, resulting in a more durable and effective non-stick coating. This is supported by the observation that the rough surface tends to smooth out over time as the pan is used and seasoned repeatedly.

Another possible advantage of the rough surface is that it can be desirable for certain cooking techniques, such as flash frying and sautéing. The texture may also be beneficial for searing meats and preparing fish, as it can help create a perfect sear and a delightful caramelization on vegetables.

Some users have also noted that the rough surface did not seem to affect the non-stick properties of the pan. Over time, with proper seasoning and use, the pan can become just as non-stick as other carbon steel or cast iron pans. This suggests that the initial roughness may be a temporary feature that smooths out as the pan develops a patina and a stronger seasoning.

While the rough surface may be intentional, it's worth noting that some users have expressed dissatisfaction with this design choice. Some people prefer a smoother surface, especially when compared to other carbon steel pans in the market that offer a mirror-like polish. This has led some users to attempt to smooth out the surface of their Lodge pans using sandpaper or other abrasive methods before reseasoning the pan.

In conclusion, while the exact reason for Lodge's decision to create carbon steel pans with a rough surface is not known, it appears to be an intentional design choice that may offer benefits such as improved seasoning, desirable cooking characteristics, and the ability to achieve a non-stick surface over time. However, the rough surface may not appeal to all users, and some may prefer to modify the surface to create a smoother finish.

It helps the pan hold its seasoning better

Lodge's carbon steel pans are pre-seasoned and ready to use straight away. The pre-seasoning is done in the foundry using natural soybean oil, which creates an easy-release finish. The natural seasoning improves over time, and the more the pan is used, the darker, glossier, and more seasoned it becomes.

The rough surface of Lodge's carbon steel pans is designed to help the pan hold its seasoning better. The coarse texture allows the oil to adhere better, creating a non-stick surface that improves with use. This is intentional, as the rough surface is required for the oil to stick to the pan during the pre-seasoning process.

While the rough surface of Lodge's carbon steel pans may be surprising to some, it serves a functional purpose. The coarse texture is designed to improve the pan's ability to hold its seasoning, resulting in a non-stick surface that improves with each use.

The pre-seasoning process involves spraying the pans with oil and then heating them in commercial conveyor ovens at very high temperatures. This allows the oil to deeply penetrate the pores of the pan, creating a natural, easy-release finish. The rough surface of the pan helps to ensure that the oil adheres properly during this process.

While some users may be initially put off by the rough surface of Lodge's carbon steel pans, it is important to understand that it is designed to improve the pan's functionality and durability. The rough texture enhances the pan's ability to hold its seasoning, resulting in a non-stick surface that improves with each use.

The rough surface smooths out with use

Lodge carbon steel pans are pre-seasoned and have a rough surface. The rough surface is designed to help the oil adhere better, improving the pan's non-stick properties. The rough surface will smooth out with use and additional seasoning.

The rough surface of Lodge carbon steel pans has sparked some controversy, with some users questioning whether they received a defective product. However, the rough surface is intentional and serves a specific purpose. The texture is designed to help the oil adhere better during the pre-seasoning process, enhancing the pan's non-stick properties.

While the rough surface may be off-putting at first, it will smooth out over time with use and proper care. The more the pan is used and seasoned, the darker, glossier, and smoother it will become. This is a natural process that occurs with carbon steel cookware as the seasoning builds up over time.

To accelerate the smoothing process, additional seasoning can be applied. This involves heating the pan, applying a thin layer of oil, and then allowing it to cool. Repeating this process several times will help build up the seasoning and lead to a smoother surface.

It's important to note that while the rough surface may be undesirable for some, it doesn't affect the pan's performance. Lodge carbon steel pans are known for their effective heat distribution, lightweight design, and versatility. With proper care and seasoning, they can develop a beautiful patina and become treasured companions in any kitchen.

Lodge carbon steel pans are pre-seasoned with natural soy bean oil

Lodge skillets are made from 100% carbon steel, which can take the heat. Carbon steel pans are lighter than cast iron and easier to handle. They heat up and cool down quickly, and can be used on any kitchen stovetop, in the oven, on induction hobs, on the grill, and even over a campfire.

Lodge skillets are made in the USA and are foundry-seasoned. The pre-seasoning process involves hanging the skillets on a transport system, where a robot sprays them with oil before they are moved through an oven. This allows the oil to penetrate deeply into the pores of the cookware, creating an easy-release finish.

The natural seasoning gets better over time and creates an easy-release cooking surface. The more you cook with a Lodge skillet, the better it performs, building up its seasoning and creating a non-stick surface that rivals traditional non-stick pans.

The rough surface is likely to help the oil adhere better

Lodge carbon steel pans have a rough surface, which is likely to help the oil adhere better. This is because the pans are pre-seasoned with natural soybean oil, which is sprayed on by a robot. The rough surface of the skillets is required for the oil to adhere better. The more the pan is used, the better the pre-seasoning becomes, and the pan will develop a non-stick surface.

The rough surface of Lodge carbon steel pans is intentional, and it is likely that the manufacturer made them this way so that the pan holds its seasoning better. The rough surface also helps to create an easy-release finish, which is a natural, rich flavour that is imparted to dishes cooked in the pan. The pre-seasoning gets better with every use, and after using the pan every day for two weeks, it will look as dark, glossy, and properly seasoned as one ten times its age.

The rough surface of Lodge carbon steel pans is a unique feature, as most other carbon steel pans have a smooth surface. This is because Lodge carbon steel pans are formed by spinning and stamping, while other skillets are made from sheet material that is smooth. The spinning and stamping process allows Lodge pans to be lighter and thinner than other skillets.

The rough surface of Lodge carbon steel pans can be a surprise to some users, who expect the surface to be smooth. Some people find the rough surface unnecessary and prefer a smoother surface for cooking. However, the rough surface of Lodge pans is not a defect, and it does not affect the performance of the pan. In fact, the rough surface can be beneficial, as it helps the oil to adhere better and creates a non-stick surface over time.

Frequently asked questions