The Mystery Of The Brown Cast Iron Pan: Unraveling The Reasons

If your cast iron pan has turned brown, there could be several reasons. Firstly, it's important to note that cast iron pans can naturally develop a brown or copper tint after seasoning, especially if you've used too much oil or if the oil hasn't fully polymerized. This is a common issue with new cast iron skillets and is nothing to worry about. Simply heating the pan and wiping away excess oil can help resolve this. Another reason could be that your pan has developed rust due to exposure to moisture. This can happen if the pan is left to soak, put in the dishwasher, or not dried thoroughly. To fix this, scrub the rust off with a stiff brush or scouring pad, dry the pan, and apply a thin layer of seasoning oil.

The cast iron pan may be discoloured due to patchy seasoning

To fix this issue, you can try using a little extra oil or fat when cooking, and regularly make recipes that will add more seasoning to your pan. You can also try scouring the pan with a chain mail scrubber, steel wool, or the edge of a metal spatula, paying attention to any areas with loose or flaky seasoning. After that, clean and dry your pan as usual. The more you use the pan, the more seasoning will build up, and the colour will even out.

Another potential cause of discolouration is oil residue. This can occur when you use too much oil when seasoning the pan, or if some oil hasn't fully polymerized and turned into seasoning yet. To fix this, heat your pan over medium heat for a few minutes to reduce the stickiness, then continue cooking as normal. The new seasoning will gradually incorporate the marks, and the surface will even out with use.

If your pan is rusty, this can also cause discolouration. To fix this, scrub the rust off under cold water, then begin building up new seasoning. Make sure to dry the pan thoroughly after scrubbing to prevent new rust from forming. Once dry, coat the pan with a thin layer of seasoning oil. Covering the pan with seasoning oil after each use and using it frequently will protect it from rusting in the future.

The brown colour could be due to the use of certain oils, like flaxseed

The brown colour of your cast iron pan could be due to the use of certain oils, like flaxseed oil. Flaxseed oil is often recommended as the best oil for seasoning cast iron because it is a "drying oil", which means it can transform into a hard, tough film through a chemical process called "polymerization". This creates a smooth, protective layer on the pan that is more resistant to scratching and wear and tear than other oils.

However, there are some potential drawbacks to using flaxseed oil. Firstly, it is expensive, with a 16-ounce bottle typically costing around $17-20. Secondly, it requires multiple coats (usually around six) and a time-intensive process of baking and cooling to properly season the pan. Thirdly, there have been reports of flaking, especially if the wrong type of flaxseed oil is used or if the oil is applied too thickly.

To avoid these issues, it is important to use pure, food-grade flaxseed oil that is organic, unrefined, and requires refrigeration. It should also be applied in a very thin layer, wiped off with a paper towel until the pan looks dry, and baked at a high temperature (around 500°F) for an hour. The pan should then be left to cool in the oven for an additional two hours before repeating the process for a total of six times.

While flaxseed oil can create a beautiful, sleek finish on cast iron, it is not the only option for seasoning. Other oils with a moderately high smoke point, such as canola oil or lard, can also be used and may be more cost-effective and less finicky.

The pan may be rusty

If your cast iron pan is brown, it may be rusty. Rust forms when cast iron is exposed to moisture for extended periods of time. This can happen if the pan is left to soak in the sink, put in the dishwasher, or allowed to air-dry. It can also occur if the pan is stored in a moisture-prone environment, such as a cabinet near a dishwasher, an open cabinet in a humid location, or outdoors.

To remove rust from your cast iron pan, start by scrubbing the rusty sections with steel wool or a lodge rust eraser. Then, wash the pan with warm, soapy water. This step may remove portions of the seasoning, but that's okay because you will be re-seasoning the pan.

Next, completely dry your cast iron pan with a paper towel or lint-free cloth. You can place it on the stovetop on low heat for a few minutes to ensure it is completely dry.

Once the pan is dry, add a very thin layer of cooking oil to the entire surface. Be sure to use just a thin layer of oil, as you don't want it to drip or run when you tilt the pan. Thin layers are important for baking seasoning into the pan.

Preheat your oven to 450-500 degrees F. Place aluminum foil on the bottom rack of the oven to catch any excess oil. Place your cookware upside down on the center rack to prevent oil from pooling on the cooking surface. Bake for 1 hour.

Finally, turn off the heat and allow the cast iron pan to cool in the oven. This allows the seasoning to further cure and adhere to the iron.

By following these steps, you can effectively remove rust from your cast iron pan and restore it to its former glory.

The brown colour could be due to overheating of fats and oils

Cast iron skillets are resilient and can withstand high temperatures. However, the brown colour on your cast iron pan could be due to the overheating of fats and oils. This happens when the oil has a low smoke point and carbonizes at high temperatures. The residue from the pores of your pan rubs off onto your food, appearing as black specks. While unappealing, these carbon deposits are not harmful to your health.

To avoid this, use an oil with a smoke point higher than your cooking temperature. For example, if you are cooking at 500°F, use an oil with a smoke point higher than 500°F. You can also avoid overheating the oil to prevent carbonization.

If you continue to use the pan, the colour will even out and darken overall as more seasoning is added. You can also try using a little extra oil or fat to help with the breaking-in process.

It is important to note that the colour of your pan is not as important as its performance. A brown-coloured pan is still polymerized and safe to use. With time and use, your pan will develop a black patina.

The brown colour could be due to burnt food particles

The brown colour on your cast-iron pan could be due to burnt food particles. This is a common issue with cast-iron pans, and it can be challenging to clean them thoroughly without removing the seasoning. However, it is essential to be thorough in your cleaning process to prevent food particles from burning and sticking to the pan's surface.

To effectively clean your cast-iron pan and remove the brown colour caused by burnt food particles, follow these steps:

• Use a pan scraper or metal spatula to remove as much of the burnt food as possible.
• If necessary, simmer a small amount of water in the pan for 3-5 minutes to loosen any remaining food particles.
• Use a pan scraper to remove the loosened food particles.
• Dry the pan thoroughly and apply a layer of oil to prevent rust and maintain the seasoning.
• If the problem persists, follow the re-seasoning process outlined below.

To re-season your cast-iron pan and restore its colour:

• Scour the surface of the pan with warm, soapy water and a metal scouring pad. You can also use steel wool or the edge of a metal spatula to remove any stubborn particles.
• Rinse the pan with water and dry it thoroughly.
• Apply a thin, even layer of cooking oil to the pan, ensuring it is well-coated.
• Place the pan upside down on the top rack of your oven and place aluminium foil on the bottom rack to catch any excess oil.
• Bake the pan at 450-500 degrees Fahrenheit for one hour.
• Allow the pan to cool and repeat the process as needed until the desired colour and seasoning are achieved.

By following these steps, you can effectively remove the brown colour caused by burnt food particles and restore your cast-iron pan to its original condition.

Frequently asked questions