The Pan-Asian Conundrum: One Flag, Many Nations

The Pan-Asian flag is a symbol of unity among Asian peoples. It is not an official flag, but it has been used unofficially. The flag features two colours: red, which represents the blood of Asians spilled in the fight for liberty and freedom, and yellow, which represents the whole Asian race. Red and yellow are traditional Asian colours. The Pan-Asian flag was inspired by the Pan-African flag.

The Pan-Asian flag is not officially recognised

Pan-Asianism, also known as Asianism or Greater Asianism, is an ideology that aims to create political and economic unity among Asian peoples. The movement was born out of opposition to Western imperialism and colonialism, and the belief that Asian values are superior to European values. Various theories and movements of Pan-Asianism have been proposed, particularly from East, South and Southeast Asia.

The Pan-Asian flag is not the only flag that celebrates Pan-Asian ideology. In the online game World of Warships, the Pan-Asia faction includes ships from various nations within the Asia-Pacific region, including the People's Republic of China, the Republic of Indonesia, the Kingdom of Thailand, and the Federation of Malaysia. Each ship in the game can fly the ensign of their respective navy or the Pan-Asian flag.

Despite the existence of the Pan-Asian flag and other symbols of Pan-Asianism, there is no single flag that is officially recognised as representing all Asians.

It was inspired by the Pan-African flag

The Pan-Asian flag was inspired by the Pan-African flag, which was created in 1920 by members of the Universal Negro Improvement Association (UNIA) in response to racism against African Americans. The Pan-African flag, also known as the Afro-American flag, Black Liberation flag, UNIA flag, and various other names, is a tri-colour flag consisting of three equal horizontal bands of red, black, and green. The colours of the flag each hold a specific meaning: red symbolises the blood shed by Black people in their quest for liberation; black represents the noble and distinguished race to which they belong; and green represents the luxuriant vegetation of their Motherland.

The Pan-Asian flag, on the other hand, features two red stripes and one yellow stripe. Red symbolises the blood of Asians spilled in their pursuit of liberty and freedom, while yellow represents the entire Asian race. The colours red and yellow are considered traditional Asian colours. The Pan-Asian flag was designed to promote unity among Asian peoples, drawing inspiration from the Pan-African flag's role in fostering solidarity and unity among Black people worldwide.

The concept of Pan-Asianism, or Asianism, advocates for political and economic unity among Asian peoples, particularly in opposition to Western imperialism and colonialism. The movement asserts that Asian values are superior to European values. While Pan-Asianism has taken on different forms in various Asian countries, such as Japan, China, and Turkey, it has often been associated with nationalist ideologies and justifications for imperialism. Nonetheless, the Pan-Asian flag stands as a symbol of the aspiration for Asian unity, modelled after the powerful message and impact of the Pan-African flag.

Red symbolises the blood of Asians fighting for freedom

The Pan-Asian flag is a symbol of the movement for political and economic unity among Asian peoples. The flag is not officially recognised, but it draws inspiration from the Pan-African flag. The red in the flag symbolises the blood of Asians fighting for their liberty and freedom, with red being a traditional Asian colour. The red also represents the struggle for survival, independence, and freedom, as seen in the Armenian flag.

The red in the Pan-Asian flag is a powerful reminder of the blood spilled by Asians in their fight for liberty and freedom. This interpretation of the colour aligns with the historical context of the Pan-Asian movement, which emerged in opposition to Western imperialism and colonialism. The movement asserted the superiority of Asian values over European ones. The red in the flag thus serves as a visual representation of the sacrifices made by Asians in their struggle for freedom and independence from colonial rule.

The colour red is also significant in the flags of individual Asian countries. For example, the red in the Chinese flag represents the revolution and the blood of workers, with the five stars symbolising the unity of the Chinese people under the leadership of the Communist Party. Similarly, the red in the Vietnamese flag stands for the revolution and the blood of the working class. In the Cambodian flag, the dominant red colour symbolises the blood shed during the country's struggle for independence.

The red in the Pan-Asian flag, therefore, draws on the powerful symbolism of the colour in Asian culture and history, representing the blood of Asians fighting for their freedom and independence. It serves as a reminder of the shared struggle across the continent and the unity among Asian peoples.

Yellow symbolises the whole Asian race

The Pan-Asian flag is a symbol of unity among Asian peoples, with red representing the blood spilled by Asians in their struggle for freedom, and yellow symbolising the whole Asian race. The use of yellow in this context is powerful and complex, with a long history that is important to understand.

Yellow has been used as a derogatory term for people of East Asian descent for centuries, with roots in Western imperialism and colonialism. The term "Yellow Peril" was coined in the 19th century by the Russian sociologist Jacques Novikow, and was used by Kaiser Wilhelm II to encourage other European empires to invade and colonise Asian countries, specifically China. This ideology portrayed the Japanese and Asian victory in the Russo-Japanese War as a threat to white Western Europe, and fuelled anti-Asian racism in Europe and North America. The colour yellow was used to depict Asians as an "other", fuelling racist fears and stereotypes that continue to this day.

However, in recent times, there has been a movement to reclaim the term "yellow" and use it as a positive symbol of empowerment. In the 1960s, during the civil rights era, Asian American activists embraced the term "yellow" as a rallying cry for unity and self-determination. Groups such as the Yellow Seeds, the Yellow Identity Symposium, and the Yellow Jackets Collective have used "yellow" in their names as a way to reclaim the term and challenge the racist connotations that have been attached to it.

The colour yellow itself has multiple connotations, including serenity, happiness, toxicity, and impurity. By using yellow in the Pan-Asian flag, the designer is embracing the complexity and diversity of Asian cultures, and challenging the simplistic stereotypes that have been used to oppress and marginalise Asians throughout history.

Ultimately, the use of yellow in the Pan-Asian flag is a bold statement that seeks to redefine the way Asians are perceived and treated by the rest of the world. It is a call for unity and empowerment, and a rejection of the racist ideologies that have sought to divide and conquer Asian peoples.

It is considered East Asian-centric

It is undeniable that the Pan-Asian flag, intended to represent the unity and diversity of all Asian people, has sparked debate and controversy due to its design and the implications it carries. One of the most prominent criticisms is the perception that the flag is East Asian-centric and fails to adequately represent the vast and varied Asian continent.

The flag, as it stands, features a yellow background with a red disc in the center. This design bears a striking resemblance to the flags of East Asian countries, particularly Japan, which has an identical color scheme, and China, which uses the same colors but with different proportions and the addition of stars. This similarity has led to accusations of East Asian bias, as it seems to draw direct inspiration from these countries while potentially neglecting the diversity of other Asian regions.

The use of the red and yellow colors, while holding symbolic value in some East Asian cultures, does not necessarily resonate with all Asian cultures and traditions. Many have pointed out that the flag's design seems to favor East Asian aesthetics and symbolism, ignoring the rich and varied cultural heritages of South Asia, Southeast Asia, and Central Asia, which encompass a multitude of different ethnicities, languages, and religious beliefs. This perceived bias toward East Asian cultural influences contributes to the notion that the Pan-Asian flag is East Asian-centric and fails to fully embrace the pan-national spirit it aims to convey.

Another factor contributing to this criticism is the historical context and power dynamics within the Asian continent. East Asian countries, particularly China and Japan, have exerted significant cultural, economic, and political influence globally. This influence has, at times, overshadowed the unique identities of other Asian countries, leading to a perception of East Asian dominance within the Asian community. As a result, when the Pan-Asian flag appears to favor East Asian design elements and symbolism, it inadvertently reinforces this perceived power imbalance and fails to showcase the equal representation and unity among all Asian nations that the flag intends to convey.

Frequently asked questions