Caraway Pans: Non-Toxic Or Marketing Myth?

Caraway cookware has gained a lot of attention for its non-toxic, non-stick, and eco-friendly features. The brand promotes its products as a healthier and more environmentally-friendly alternative to traditional non-stick cookware, which often contains toxic chemicals like Teflon. Caraway's ceramic coating is marketed as a natural, non-toxic, and frictionless surface that doesn't require the use of synthetic chemicals. However, some users have expressed concerns about the durability of the non-stick coating, the tedious care instructions, and the high price. So, are Caraway pans truly non-toxic and worth the investment? Let's explore further.

Caraway Cookware's non-toxic claims

Caraway cookware is marketed as a healthier, more environmentally-friendly alternative to traditional non-stick cookware. The brand's tagline, "Quality Cookware, Without Chemicals," reflects its commitment to creating non-toxic products that are free from synthetic chemicals like polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), commonly known as Teflon.

Caraway cookware is made with an aluminum core and coated with a ceramic non-stick coating. This coating is created using a sol-gel process, which involves applying a liquid ceramic solution to the metal surface before it hardens, resulting in a smooth, nonporous, and non-stick finish. The brand claims that their products are free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, cadmium, and other toxic materials that can be harmful to health.

To support their non-toxic claims, Caraway has conducted third-party testing through accredited agencies such as SGS S.A. and NSL Analytical. These tests have shown no detectable levels of PTFE, PFOA, lead, cadmium, or other toxic metals in the non-stick coating. Caraway has also provided test reports on their website, including California Prop 65 leaching tests for heavy metals and FDA leaching tests for lead and cadmium.

However, there have been some concerns and criticisms regarding Caraway's non-toxic claims. One independent researcher, Tamara Rubin, conducted X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) testing on Caraway cookware and found positive results for lead, cadmium, titanium, and other metals. It is important to note that XRF testing may not be as reliable for this type of product, especially when performed on used cookware. The test results could be affected by contamination from oil, food, utensils, or other sources.

Additionally, Caraway's marketing claims have been scrutinized, with some believing that the company is engaging in greenwashing. For example, their claim of "without chemicals" lacks nuance as even water and iron are chemicals. While Caraway's statements might be interpreted as misleading, they don't necessarily amount to full-on greenwashing.

In conclusion, Caraway cookware stands by its non-toxic claims and has provided evidence through third-party testing. However, there are still some concerns and debates surrounding the accuracy of these claims, with independent tests yielding different results. While Caraway's products might be an improvement over traditional non-stick cookware, they might not be as eco-friendly as they claim due to their shorter lifespan compared to cast iron or stainless steel.

Ceramic coating's safety

Ceramic coatings are considered a safer non-stick alternative to Teflon. However, they are not without their own health concerns. Ceramic coating can be damaged easily, which can bring the metal in direct contact with food. In the case of some metal alloys, this can be potentially harmful to health.

Ceramic-coated cookware is usually marked as "ceramic" or "non-stick ceramic cookware". This has led to the misconception that it is made from ceramics. However, ceramic-coated vessels are made from an aluminium or stainless steel metal base covered with a specific coating. The coating is made from multiple layers of silica (silicon dioxide) through gel-sol spin coating technology.

The safety of ceramic coatings depends on several factors. Silica, which is used for non-stick coating, is often used for manufacturing other food-grade items such as silicone utensils and glass bakeware. There is currently no scientific evidence that shows the negative health effects of silica. Studies that investigate the use of silicone for making medical equipment have not found any negative effects when it is in contact with the human body.

Even if silica coating is not the major concern, there are other factors that can affect the safety of ceramic-coated cookware. One claim related to non-stick cookware safety is that scratching a non-stick pan can expose the user to metal leaking from the metal base. This claim is true based on scientific knowledge and experiments. However, the real question is how significant this metal leaking is in the context of negative health effects.

The metal base of non-stick cookware is usually made from aluminium alloys, which have been linked to cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. Regulations have been put in place to prevent aluminium exposure, with the recommended limit set at 1mg/kg of body weight/week. While the amount of aluminium obtained from cooking vessels and food storage items is small, it can still contribute significantly to the total uptake of aluminium. Studies have shown that acidic food like tomato sauce, apple puree, and rhubarb can contribute to aluminium intake, which is worth considering when setting intake limits.

Another concern with ceramic-coated cookware is the use of lead-containing metal alloys. Aluminium alloys used in non-stick cookware bases can contain different elements, including heavy metals such as lead or bismuth. Low-quality non-stick cooking vessels may be contaminated with these elements. Food-grade aluminium is strictly regulated, with limits set on the amount of hazardous substances allowed. However, non-food-grade materials used for non-stick pan bodies may not follow these regulations and could contain harmful levels of heavy metals.

In conclusion, ceramic coatings are generally considered safer than Teflon. However, they are not perfect and can still pose potential health risks, especially if the coating is damaged. Proper care and maintenance of ceramic-coated cookware are important to minimise these risks.

Teflon's health concerns

Teflon, or polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), is a synthetic chemical used to coat non-stick cookware. While Teflon itself is generally considered safe, there are several health concerns associated with its use, particularly when heated to high temperatures.

Firstly, Teflon was previously made with perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), a chemical linked to various health issues, including chronic kidney disease, liver disease, thyroid disorders, testicular cancer, infertility, and low birth weight. Although PFOA has been phased out of Teflon production since 2013, traces of it were found in some Teflon-coated cookware, and it was detected in the blood of 98% of people in the US in a 1999 study. As a result, the US EPA implemented a program to eliminate PFOA by 2015, and all Teflon products have been PFOA-free since 2013.

Secondly, when Teflon is heated above 500°F (260°C) or 570°F (300°C), it starts to break down and release toxic fumes. Inhaling these fumes can lead to polymer fume fever, also known as the Teflon flu, which causes temporary flu-like symptoms such as chills, fever, headache, and body aches. Prolonged exposure to these fumes may also increase the risk of cancer and other health issues.

Additionally, there are concerns about other chemicals used in Teflon production, namely per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). These chemicals are persistent in the environment and have been detected in the blood of US residents. Research is ongoing to understand the potential health risks associated with PFAS exposure.

To minimise the risks associated with Teflon cookware, it is recommended to follow basic safety precautions, such as avoiding preheating an empty pan, cooking on medium or low heat, ventilating the kitchen during cooking, using wooden, silicone, or plastic utensils, and hand washing the cookware gently.

Caraway's durability

Caraway cookware is made with a heavy-gauge aluminium core free of lead, cadmium, and other toxic metals. The interior and exterior are coated in a proprietary, mineral-based ceramic and feature a stainless steel plate on the bottom, making them compatible with induction cooking. The cookware gets its non-stick quality from the multi-layer, mineral-based ceramic.

The durability of Caraway cookware is a mixed bag. On the one hand, the ceramic coating is susceptible to chipping and the exterior paint is prone to coming off easily. The non-stick properties also fade over time, especially if the cookware is washed in a dishwasher. However, Caraway cookware is oven-safe up to 550°F (some sources even say 650°F) and compatible with all cooktops, including induction, gas, and electric stovetops. The aluminium and stainless steel bottoms ensure even heat distribution, and the cookware heats up quickly.

One reviewer who has been using Caraway cookware for over four years says that the ceramic non-stick coating is still going strong, although they are careful not to go above medium heat, avoid metal utensils, and always wash the cookware by hand. Another reviewer who has been using the cookware for six months says that it still looks brand new.

Overall, Caraway cookware seems to be more durable than other ceramic-coated cookware options on the market. However, traditional Teflon-coated non-stick cookware is a better choice if you want the longest-lasting non-stick performance.

Caraway's manufacturing and packaging

Caraway's manufacturing process is designed to be environmentally friendly. Their products are made with an aluminium core and stainless steel bases and handles. The interior features a non-stick coating free of lead, cadmium, PTFE, PFOA, and other harmful chemicals. Caraway's manufacturing process releases up to 60% less CO2 into the environment compared to traditional non-stick coatings. The brand also supports BSCI and SMETA-certified manufacturing partners, ensuring that employees work in safe conditions, are paid fairly, receive benefits, and work regulated hours.

Caraway's packaging is sustainable and eco-friendly. All orders are shipped in packaging made from recycled cardboard and are free from single-use plastics. The brand also includes biodegradable cork trivets as a gift with purchase. Caraway's commitment to sustainability extends beyond their packaging, as they also offer a zip code locator to help customers responsibly recycle their products when they are no longer needed.

Frequently asked questions