Carbon Steel Pans: Drop-Proof?

Carbon steel pans are durable and long-lasting. They can be dropped, banged, overheated, or otherwise handled roughly without breaking or cracking. However, they are susceptible to water damage and should be dried thoroughly after use and cleaning. They are also reactive to acidic foods, which can strip the seasoning and impart a metallic taste to meals.

Carbon steel pans are durable and hard to damage

Carbon steel pans are also lightweight, making them easier to handle than cast iron pans. A 12-inch cast iron pan typically weighs around 7-8 pounds, while a carbon steel skillet of the same size weighs only about 5 pounds. This lightweight quality also makes carbon steel pans more manoeuvrable and safer to handle, especially when transferring them from stovetop to oven.

In terms of maintenance, carbon steel pans require proper cleaning and care to prevent rust and maintain their seasoning. They should always be cleaned by hand, as dishwashing or using soap and water can damage the pan's seasoning. To clean a carbon steel pan, simply wipe away excess oil with a kitchen towel. For more stubborn food residue, a mixture of oil, coarse salt, and warm water can be used. It is also important to ensure that carbon steel pans are thoroughly dried after cleaning, as water can cause rusting.

While carbon steel pans are durable, they are not indestructible. They can react with highly acidic foods such as tomatoes, citrus, vinegar, and wine, which can strip the pan's seasoning. Therefore, it is recommended to avoid cooking such acidic foods in carbon steel pans or to consistently re-season the pan after each use. Additionally, the handles of carbon steel pans can become very hot, so oven mitts or silicone handle covers are recommended to prevent burns.

They are lightweight and easy to handle

Carbon steel pans are lightweight and easy to handle. They are significantly lighter than cast iron pans, with a 12" cast iron skillet weighing around 8 lbs, while a 12" carbon steel pan weighs just over 5 lbs. This makes carbon steel pans much easier to manoeuvre, especially when taking them in and out of the oven. Their lightweight design means that most 10" carbon steel pans don't have or need a helper handle, although some 12" pans do.

Carbon steel pans are also versatile and can be used on the stove, in the oven, under the broiler, and on the grill. They are highly durable and can withstand being dropped, banged, overheated, or otherwise handled roughly. They are made from a composite of 1% carbon and 99% iron, which is strong yet malleable.

Carbon steel pans are also quick to heat up and cool down, making them more responsive to temperature changes than cast iron. They have a slim design that promotes faster heat transfer from the stove to the surface. This can save time when cooking multiple dishes in a busy kitchen.

Carbon steel is safe and non-toxic

Carbon steel pans are a popular choice for professional chefs and home cooks alike. They are lightweight, durable, and versatile. But are they safe to use?

Carbon steel is made from iron and carbon, both non-toxic and food-safe materials. It does not have a non-stick coating but is instead seasoned with oil or lard, which is also non-toxic. This natural non-stick surface is free from chemicals like PFOA, which is often found in traditional non-stick pans and has been linked to cancer and thyroid dysfunction.

Carbon steel is safe to use at very high temperatures for long periods of time without any issues such as damaged coating. This makes it ideal for grilling or oven roasting, unlike non-stick pans, which should only be used at high heat sporadically and for short periods. Carbon steel can withstand temperatures of up to 1200°F, so you can use it for as long as you need to.

While carbon steel is safe, there are a few things to keep in mind. Firstly, carbon steel should be hand-washed to preserve the seasoning and prevent rust. Secondly, acidic ingredients like wine, citrus, tomatoes, or vinegar should be avoided as they can strip the seasoning and impart a metallic taste to your food. Lastly, carbon steel pans can get very hot, so it's a good idea to order a silicone sleeve to handle the pan.

Overall, carbon steel is a safe and non-toxic option for cookware, offering a natural non-stick surface without the use of chemicals.

It's important to season carbon steel pans before use

Carbon steel pans are durable and can withstand being dropped, banged, overheated, or otherwise handled roughly. However, they are susceptible to rust and damage from water and acidic foods.

Seasoning carbon steel pans is important for several reasons. Firstly, it creates a protective layer that prevents the pan from rusting. This is especially important because carbon steel pans are prone to rusting if not properly seasoned or if exposed to moisture and humidity. Secondly, seasoning transforms the surface of the pan into a non-stick coating, enhancing the performance and durability of the pan. This non-stick coating allows for easier cooking of foods like eggs, pancakes, and stir-fried vegetables. Additionally, the seasoning process helps to fill in the small pores on the surface of the pan, creating a slick patina that improves with continued use.

To season a carbon steel pan, follow these general steps:

• Remove any protective coating or beeswax that may be present on a new pan.
• Wash the pan with hot water and mild detergent, then thoroughly dry it.
• Heat the pan over a burner or in an oven to open up the pores and remove any remaining moisture.
• Apply a thin layer of oil with a high smoke point, such as canola oil, vegetable oil, or grapeseed oil, to the inside and outside of the pan.
• Heat the oiled pan over a burner at the highest setting or in an oven at around 450°F (230°C) until the oil forms a polymerized coating.
• Repeat the oil application and heating process several times to build up a solid layer of seasoning.
• Allow the pan to cool completely before using it for cooking.

Remember that proper maintenance of a carbon steel pan is crucial. Avoid using soap or long soaks in water, as these can damage the seasoning. Instead, use hot water and a scouring pad to clean the pan, then ensure it is completely dry before storing it away.

Avoid acidic foods when cooking with carbon steel

Carbon steel pans are durable and can withstand a lot of rough handling. However, they are not indestructible, and one of their vulnerabilities is to acidic foods.

Acidic foods such as tomatoes, wine, vinegar, and lemon juice will react with the carbon steel, stripping away the seasoning and causing an unpleasant metallic taste in your food. This is because carbon steel is a reactive metal with a cooking surface made of bare metal, and when it comes into contact with acid, it leaches iron into the food. This not only ruins your dish but also damages the pan by removing the protective layer of seasoning that prevents corrosion and rust.

Therefore, it is best to avoid cooking acidic foods in carbon steel pans, especially if the recipe involves a long simmer. Instead, opt for a non-reactive surface such as an enamelled cast iron, ceramic, non-stick, or stainless steel pan when cooking acidic dishes.

If you do use your carbon steel pan for acidic foods and notice the effects of degradation, you can always re-season your pan. First, wash the pan with soapy water and scrub it with a soft sponge. Then, pat it dry and heat it on a stovetop for 5 minutes to ensure it is completely dry. Once it has cooled, use a paper towel to wipe the pan with cooking oil, making sure to cover all surfaces. Finally, heat the pan over medium heat for 30 minutes and let it cool. Your pan will now be ready to use again for non-acidic dishes.

Frequently asked questions