Pizza Stone Vs. Pan: Which Is Better?

Pizza stones and pizza pans each have their pros and cons, but which is better for cooking pizza?

Pizza stones are thick ceramic or stone slabs that absorb and radiate heat for an intense bake. They are designed to replicate the heat of a wood-fired oven in your electric oven. Pizza stones deliver more even heat retention and distribution, and are better for thin-crust pizzas. They also absorb moisture from the dough, resulting in a light, airy interior and a crispy crust.

Pizza pans, on the other hand, are crafted from lightweight metal – usually aluminium or steel. They offer quick and even heat distribution and don't require preheating, making them ideal for thin-crust pizzas. Pizza pans are also more affordable, durable, and easier to use and clean.

So, which is better? If you're looking for a crispy crust and a soft, delicate top, a pizza stone is the way to go. But if convenience and ease of use are more important to you, a pizza pan might be the better choice. Ultimately, it depends on your personal preferences and priorities.

Pizza stones are made from porous materials like clay, ceramic or cordierite

Ceramic is another good option for pizza stones, as it conducts heat evenly and is cost-effective. However, ceramic requires preheating to avoid cracking. Ceramic pizza stones are made from clay and fired in a kiln. They are long-lasting and, when properly cared for, can be used for many years.

Cordierite is a more expensive and extremely durable option for pizza stones. It is a mineral that can handle extreme temperatures and is resistant to thermal shock. This means it can be taken from low to very high temperatures without the risk of breaking. Cordierite is the same material used to make kiln shelves, so it is built to last.

Pizza stones made from porous materials like clay, ceramic or cordierite are able to absorb moisture from the dough, resulting in a crispier crust. They also distribute heat evenly, preventing hot spots and ensuring consistent cooking.

Pizza stones are heavier and take longer to heat up

Pizza stones are heavier than standard pizza pans and take longer to heat up. This is because they are usually made from durable materials such as cordierite, clay or ceramic, which are denser than the metal of a typical pizza pan.

Pizza stones need to be heated up inside the oven during the preheating process. They absorb heat during this period and retain it well. This makes pizza stones ideal for cooking thicker crusts and providing a more intense bake. The dense materials of a pizza stone mean that it can supply continuous heat, mimicking the intense, radiant heat of a pizza oven. This is crucial for achieving a crispy crust.

The weight and thickness of a pizza stone mean that it takes longer to preheat than a pizza pan. Thicker stones, in particular, provide more consistent heat but take longer to heat up. Pizza stones are therefore not as convenient as pizza pans, which can be used without preheating and are easier to handle and manoeuvre.

However, despite taking longer to heat up, pizza stones are considered to produce better-quality pizzas. The prolonged preheating time lets the stone store enough heat to cook challenging pizzas, such as those with thick crusts. Pizza stones also ensure even heat distribution, preventing uneven browning or burnt patches. The stone's porous nature draws out moisture from the dough during baking, creating a lighter, airier crust.

Pizza stones are harder to clean

To clean a pizza stone, it is important to first let it cool down completely, as a sudden change in temperature can cause the stone to crack. Once cool, use a brush or scraper to remove any food particles and residue. Then, if necessary, use a damp cloth to wipe away any remaining residue. It is important to avoid using soap or other cleaning chemicals, as these can be absorbed into the stone and affect the taste of future pizzas. Instead, a paste made of baking soda and water can be used to remove stubborn stains or burnt-on food. After cleaning, the stone should be air-dried or wiped with a clean towel.

In addition to being harder to clean, pizza stones also require more care and maintenance than pizza pans. They need to be preheated for a longer period of time before use, and they are more fragile and prone to cracking if dropped or exposed to extreme temperature changes.

Pizza stones are more prone to cracking

Pizza stones can crack due to thermal shock, which occurs when a cold pizza stone is placed in a hot oven. This causes a fracture in the stone as it cannot handle large temperature changes. Thermal shock can also occur when a pizza stone is removed from a hot oven and placed on a cool surface, such as a stove.

Another reason pizza stones crack is due to moisture. Washing or oiling a pizza stone can weaken it and lead to cracking. The porous ceramic material absorbs water, and if the stone is heated before it is completely dry, the water expands and can cause the stone to crack.

Pizza stones can also crack if they are handled too much. The internal integrity of the stone can be weakened over time, leading to fractures. Additionally, placing cool or cold food on a pre-heated pizza stone can cause thermal shock and cracking.

To prevent cracking, it is recommended to always put a pizza stone into a cold oven and do a long pre-heat. Minimizing handling and avoiding washing or oiling the stone can also help prevent cracking.

Pizza pans are more affordable

Pizza pans are durable and can be used for years with proper care. They are also easy to clean, with most pans possessing a non-stick coating. Pizza pans are ideal for thin-crust pizzas and provide even heat distribution, ensuring consistent browning on the bottom crust.

Pizza pans are versatile and can be used for calzones, focaccia, and cookies, making them true kitchen multitaskers. They are also highly portable and can be easily shifted outdoors.

Overall, pizza pans offer a convenient, affordable, and effective option for baking pizzas, especially for those who are new to pizza-making or those who prefer thin-crust pizzas.

Frequently asked questions