Butter Pie Pan: Crust First Or Last?

Whether or not you should butter a pie pan before putting in the crust depends on the type of pan and the recipe you are following. If you are using a store-bought pie crust, it is recommended to lightly grease the pan with cooking spray, butter, or pan release. However, if you are using a homemade recipe with a high-fat content, it may not be necessary to grease the pan. Glass, ceramic, and cast-iron pans typically do not need to be greased, while aluminum or stainless steel pans may require a light coating of butter or pan release for insurance. Ultimately, it is a personal preference, and greasing the pan will not hurt, especially if you plan to remove the pie from the pan before serving.

Glass pie pans don't need greasing, but you can if you want to

Glass pie pans are made of tempered glass, which can withstand the heat of oven baking. They are inexpensive and allow the cook to see the item as it bakes. Glass pie pans are available in 8-, 9-, and 10-inch diameters and various depths. The standard depth for a pie pan is 1 1/2 inches, though deeper pans are available for baking deep-dish pies.

Glass pie pans conduct heat better than metal pans, so it is recommended to lower the oven temperature by 25 degrees Fahrenheit when baking in glass pans to prevent excess browning. Additionally, foods will brown faster and darker in glass pans than in metal pans, so you may need to shorten the baking time.

Regarding greasing the pan, pie crusts typically contain enough shortening or butter that you shouldn't need to grease a glass pie pan before adding the crust. Greasing the pan with cooking sprays, butter, or shortening may change the texture of the crust as it bakes. However, if you plan to remove the pie from the pan for serving, a light coating of grease can help prevent sticking.

It is important to note that sudden temperature changes can cause glass pans to break. Therefore, avoid removing a hot pan from the oven and placing it in cold water or on a cold surface. Do not put a glass pan directly from the refrigerator or freezer into a hot oven, and avoid pouring hot liquids into a cold pan or vice versa.

Metal pans are good conductors of heat, so they don't need greasing

Metal pans are excellent conductors of heat, which means they heat up quickly and evenly. This efficient heat transfer is due to the free flow of electrons in metals. However, different metals have varying levels of thermal conductivity. For example, heat flows more efficiently in copper and aluminium than in cast iron, carbon steel, or pure stainless steel.

When deciding whether or not to grease a pie pan, several factors come into play, such as the type of dough and pan. Greasing the pan with butter, shortening, or non-stick spray can prevent the pie crust from sticking, but it may not always be necessary. This is because pie and tart doughs typically contain a high amount of butter, which acts as a natural lubricant during the baking process. The butter melts and turns into steam, browning the crust and making it crispy.

If you plan to remove the pie from the baking dish before serving, a light coating of grease or cooking spray can be helpful. On the other hand, if you intend to serve the pie in the same dish, greasing may not be necessary. However, a quick spritz of cooking spray can make it easier to remove the first slice, especially if the filling is sticky.

It's important to note that using too much grease or the wrong type can alter the texture of the pie crust. Therefore, if you choose to grease the pan, use a thin layer of melted butter or shortening, or a very light coating of non-stick spray. Additionally, consider the material of your pie dish, as different materials may have specific requirements. For example, ceramic pie dishes may benefit from a light coating of butter, while stainless steel or cast-iron pans can take advantage of their natural non-stick properties.

In summary, while metal pans are good conductors of heat, the decision to grease a pie pan depends on various factors. The type of dough, serving method, and material of the pie dish all play a role in determining the need for greasing. Ultimately, the goal is to achieve a delicious, crispy pie crust without altering its texture or flavour.

Foil pie pans are good when you don't want to wash up, but you can grease them if you want to

Foil pie pans are a convenient option for bakers who want to avoid the hassle of washing up. These disposable pans are designed for single-use and can be simply thrown away after use, eliminating the need for tedious cleaning. They are also a popular choice for those who want to share their baked goods with others, as there is no need to worry about getting your pans back. Additionally, these pans are ideal for catering services, bake sales, or farmer's markets, offering a practical and hygienic solution for food distribution.

While foil pie pans are typically used as-is, without any additional preparation, there may be instances where greasing the pan is beneficial. If you are concerned about the pie sticking to the pan or prefer a crispier crust, you can apply a light coating of butter or non-stick spray. This extra step can help ensure that your pie releases easily from the pan and may enhance the texture of your crust. However, it is important to use a very light touch when greasing the pan, as too much grease can alter the texture of your pie dough.

Another factor to consider is the type of pie you are making. Pies with sticky or messy fillings are more likely to benefit from greasing the pan, as it can make it easier to remove the first slice without the filling acting as glue. Additionally, if you plan to remove the pie from the pan for serving, greasing can facilitate this process and ensure a clean release. On the other hand, if you intend to serve the pie directly in the foil pan, greasing may not be necessary, although it won't hurt.

In conclusion, foil pie pans offer the convenience of mess-free cooking and are perfect for those who want to avoid the chore of washing up. While greasing the pan is generally not required, it can be beneficial in certain situations, such as when dealing with sticky fillings or desiring a crispier crust. Remember to use a light touch when greasing and always consider the specific needs of your pie recipe.

Tart pans with removable bottoms are a good option for a well-browned crust

Tart pans with removable bottoms are a great option for achieving a well-browned crust. They are typically made of stainless steel or carbon steel and feature a non-stick coating, such as the Williams Sonoma Goldtouch® Tart Pan. This type of pan is ideal for tarts and quiches, as the removable bottom allows for easy release and transfer of the baked goods.

When deciding whether to use butter or another form of grease in your pie or tart pan, it is important to consider the type of dough and pan you are using. If you plan to remove the tart or pie from the pan before serving, a light coating of butter, cooking spray, or another grease is recommended to prevent sticking. However, if you intend to serve the pie in the same dish it bakes in, greasing the pan may not be necessary, especially if your dough already contains a significant amount of butter.

Tarts, which are typically baked in pans with scalloped edges and removable bottoms, often have crisp shells made from shortcrust pastry. The dough is firmly pressed into the pan, forming a sharp corner at the base and moulding around the sides. In this case, greasing the pan before pressing in the dough is crucial to prevent the tart from cracking and breaking when removed.

Overall, tart pans with removable bottoms are a good choice for achieving a well-browned crust, but it is important to consider the specific type of dough and pan you are using to determine if additional greasing is necessary.

Ceramic pans are not recommended, as they can make the crust soggy

When it comes to baking the perfect pie, there are many factors to consider, from the ingredients used to the type of pan. While using a ceramic pan for your pie may be convenient, it is not the best option if you want to avoid a soggy crust. Here's why ceramic pans are not recommended and what you can do instead to ensure a crispy, golden crust.

The main issue with ceramic pans is their heat conduction properties. Ceramic pans, usually made of stoneware or porcelain, tend to be slower to transfer heat compared to metal pans. This means that your pie crust may not cook as quickly or evenly, resulting in an unevenly baked crust. In a test conducted by King Arthur Baking, a pie baked in a ceramic pan had the least even browning of the three pies tested (metal, glass, and ceramic). The center of the pie was pale and slightly underbaked, while the outer edge was a deeper brown.

So, what can you use instead? If you're looking for the perfect pie crust, a metal pan is your best bet. Metal conducts heat more efficiently, meaning it gets hot quickly and transfers heat evenly across the pan's surface. This results in a more evenly baked crust that is golden brown and thoroughly cooked. An aluminum pan is an excellent option for achieving the perfect pie crust.

Additionally, there are a few tricks you can use to prevent a soggy pie crust:

• Blind bake the crust: This involves baking the crust before adding the filling, ensuring it is dry and crispy.
• Choose the right rack in the oven: Baking the pie on a lower rack will concentrate the heat on the bottom of the pie and help crisp up the crust.
• Brush the bottom with corn syrup or egg white: Coating the inside surface of the bottom crust creates a barrier that prevents sogginess.
• Put the pie on a hot cookie sheet: Placing the pie on a preheated baking sheet helps the crust get a jump start on cooking, making it impermeable to the liquid in the filling.
• Make a thicker crust: For double-crust pies, roll the bottom crust slightly thicker than the top to prevent the filling's moisture from seeping through.
• Use a metal pie pan: Metal conducts heat better than glass or ceramic, resulting in a crispier crust.

By following these tips and using a metal pan instead of a ceramic one, you can say goodbye to soggy pie crusts and hello to a perfectly baked, delicious pie!

Frequently asked questions