Heating Non-Stick Pans: Oil First Or Last?

Whether you heat a non-stick pan before adding oil depends on who you ask. Some people swear by the mantra hot pan, cold oil to prevent food from sticking. Others prefer to heat the pan and oil together. The hot pan, cold oil method is based on the idea that heating a non-stick pan first closes up the pores in the surface, creating a smoother surface for the oil to slide on. However, some argue that the pores in the pan actually get larger when heated, causing the food to stick more. Ultimately, it is important to ensure that the pan is hot enough when adding food to prevent sticking, regardless of when the oil is added.

Non-stick pans can emit unhealthy fumes if heated without oil

Non-stick pans are convenient and easy to cook with, but they do require special care. One important thing to remember is that non-stick pans can emit unhealthy fumes if heated without oil or butter.

When a non-stick pan is heated without oil, its coating can start to break down and release toxic chemicals into the air. These fumes, known as "polymer fume fever" or "Teflon flu," can cause flu-like symptoms such as chills, fever, headache, and body aches. While cases are rare, it's important to take precautions to avoid exposure to these fumes.

To prevent the release of toxic fumes, it's recommended to always add oil or butter to a non-stick pan before heating it. This helps to amplify the coating's effect and prevents the pan from overheating. It's also important to avoid high heat when cooking with non-stick pans, as higher temperatures can damage the coating and release harmful toxins. Instead, opt for low to medium heat and use ventilation when cooking.

In addition to adding oil before heating, there are a few other tips to keep your non-stick pans in good condition:

• Use wooden, silicone, or plastic utensils instead of metal utensils, which can scratch the coating.
• Hand wash your non-stick pans with a sponge and warm soapy water instead of putting them in the dishwasher.
• Avoid using cooking spray, as it can cause a build-up of residue that is difficult to remove.
• Replace your non-stick pan if the coating starts to visibly deteriorate with scratches, peeling, flaking, or chipping.

By following these simple guidelines, you can safely enjoy the convenience of cooking with non-stick pans while minimising any potential risks to your health.

Oil heats up faster than a pan

When it comes to cooking, there are two schools of thought on whether to heat the pan first or add oil to a cold pan. While both methods have their proponents, the latter is generally considered preferable, especially for non-stick pans. Here's why oil heats up faster than a pan and why this matters for your cooking.

Oil Heats Up Faster

Oil has a lower specific heat capacity than metal, which means it takes less energy to raise its temperature. In simple terms, this means that oil will heat up faster than a metal pan. This is why adding oil to a hot pan can result in the oil heating up almost instantly and being ready for cooking.

Advantages of Adding Oil to a Cold Pan

Adding oil to a cold pan has several advantages:

• Reduced Risk of Burning: Oil has a smoke point, the temperature at which it starts to smoke and decompose. By adding oil to a hot pan, you risk exceeding the smoke point and burning the oil. This can not only ruin the taste of your food but also release toxic chemicals.
• Better Heat Distribution: Oil added to a hot pan may heat up quickly, but it can also form a circle on the outer edge of the pan due to the pan's uneven heating. Adding oil to a cold pan allows for more even heat distribution as the oil has time to spread out and coat the entire cooking surface.
• Protection for Non-Stick Pans: Non-stick pans are particularly sensitive to heat. Adding oil to a hot non-stick pan can damage the coating, defeating the purpose of using such a pan in the first place. Adding oil first provides a protective layer and helps extend the life of the non-stick coating.
• Better Temperature Control: When you add oil to a hot pan, it can be challenging to gauge the temperature accurately. With a cold pan, you can use techniques like the water test (flicking a drop of water onto the pan to check if it sizzles) to determine when the pan is at the desired temperature.
• Ease of Use: Adding oil to a cold pan is simply more convenient and safer. You don't have to worry about accidentally touching the hot pan or splattering oil when adding it to a hot surface.

While there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the pan-or-oil-first debate, adding oil to a cold pan offers several benefits, especially for non-stick cookware. Ultimately, the decision may come down to personal preference and the specific dish being prepared. However, understanding the science behind heat transfer and the properties of the cookware and oil you're using can help you make more informed choices in the kitchen.

Food is more likely to stick to a cold pan

If you add cold oil to a cold pan, the oil moves slowly. It seeps into tiny pores and gaps in the surface of the pan. If you shake the pan back and forth, the oil won't move much. As the pan heats up, the metal expands, trapping the oil. This makes your food more likely to stick to the pan, and makes your pans harder to clean.

When you add cold oil to a hot pan, the pores and gaps in the surface of the pan have already closed when the metal expanded. The oil warms up on contact and you can see it immediately become looser and more liquid in appearance. It will look like it's sliding on the surface of the pan, and will spread out without you having to shake the pan very much at all.

If you're cooking with stainless steel pans, you'll have better results (and less stuck food) if you heat the stainless steel before adding oil.

If you're using a non-stick pan, it's generally recommended to add the oil to the pan before heating. This is because non-stick pans heat up quickly, and high dry heat can cause pans to deteriorate.

Preheating a non-stick pan can be dangerous

Empty non-stick pans can overheat, and the coating can be destroyed without sources of fat like butter or oil. Preheating without food or oil destroys a pan's coating as it doesn't allow the heat to distribute and instead concentrates the temperature, which breaks down the pan's polytetrafluoroethylene compound coating. Not only will the coating have less of its desired non-stick effect, but it can also be toxic.

If heated above 500°F (and without something in the pan to distribute heat), non-stick pans will release toxic fumes into the kitchen air. Since the average gas burner can heat up to 3,500°F, and induction burners can reach over 600°F, keeping the heat down is important when cooking with non-stick pans.

It is also thought to be hazardous when heating empty non-stick pans. The pans get too hot too fast, which can damage the non-stick surface, potentially release toxins, and even cause your pan to warp.

Heating a pan with oil can be used as a temperature gauge

• The water test: A common method to check if your pan is hot enough is to flick a small amount of water onto the dry pan. If the water sizzles and evaporates quickly, your pan is at a good medium heat for cooking. If the water rolls around the pan, you're at a higher temperature, closer to medium-high or high heat. This method is also known as the Leidenfrost effect, where a drop of water forms a ball and glides on the hot surface of the pan. However, this method may not be accurate for non-stick pans, as you typically don't want to heat them dry.
• Oil movement: When you swirl the pan, the oil should move quickly and almost look like water. It should have a loose, fluid appearance, coating the pan easily with a slight shimmy. If the oil moves slowly and forms long, individual droplets, it's not hot enough yet.
• Oil shimmering: As the oil heats up, it will start to shimmer and give off a glistening effect. This is a good indication that your pan is ready for cooking.
• Oil "fingers": When you swirl the oil, it should look like it's stretching and forming "fingers." This is another sign that your oil is hot and ready.
• Oil smoking: If your oil starts to smoke, it's too hot. Remove it from the heat and turn down the temperature. Smoking oil can degrade and release toxic chemicals, so it's best to avoid this.
• Wooden spoon test: For deep or shallow frying, dip a wooden spoon into the hot oil. If small bubbles rapidly form around the spoon, your oil is hot enough for frying.
• Sizzling food: When you add food to the pan, it should sizzle. If it doesn't, your pan may not be hot enough, and you should wait a bit longer before adding the food.
• Use a thermometer: While not always practical, you can use a thermometer to directly measure the temperature of your pan. An infrared thermometer is a handy tool for this purpose.

Remember, the ideal temperature for your pan depends on what you're cooking. For example, searing meat or vegetables requires a higher temperature than sweating vegetables. Always ensure your pan is hot enough before adding food to avoid sticking. Additionally, different oils have different smoke points, so choose an oil suitable for the temperature you're cooking at.

Frequently asked questions