The Pan Conundrum: Oil Or Heat First?

Whether you heat the pan or the oil first is a contentious issue in the culinary world, with valid arguments on both sides. Some people believe that heating the pan first gives the oil less time to burn, while others argue that adding oil to a hot pan prevents food from sticking.

Those who heat the pan first typically do so until they can feel the heat radiating from the surface, then add oil and food. This method is said to reduce the risk of the oil burning and prevent food from sticking. It also ensures that the oil is heated instantly and that the food doesn't end up in a cold pan with cold oil, creating a sticky mess.

On the other hand, some people add oil to a cold pan and heat both together. This approach is said to be safer for non-stick pans, as heating an empty non-stick pan can cause the coating to break down. It also allows you to use the oil as a temperature gauge—when it becomes runny or starts to shimmer, you know the pan is ready.

Ultimately, the decision may depend on the type of pan and oil being used, the cooking temperature, and personal preference.

Heating the pan first prevents oil from burning

Heating the pan first prevents the oil from burning. If you heat the oil and the pan together, the oil will burn before the pan reaches the desired temperature.

The pan should be heated first until you can feel the heat radiating from the surface. Then, add the oil. Heating the pan first also ensures that the oil heats up instantly.

If you heat the oil first, the oil will start to break down and burn. The longer the oil is heated without anything else in the pan, the quicker it will burn.

Heating the pan first is especially important if you are going for a hard sear, such as with a steak. You can get the pan hotter than the oil, and adding a touch of oil immediately before putting the steak in will ensure the steak doesn't stick to the pan.

Heating the pan first also helps to prevent kitchen accidents. If you heat the pan and oil together, you may forget about it and come back to a pan full of flaming oil. If you heat the pan first and then add the oil, you will be able to turn the heat off and let the pan cool down.

Oil can be used as a temperature gauge

You can test the temperature of your oil by observing its behaviour. When you lift the pan and swirl the oil around, if it moves quickly and shimmers, it's hot enough. You should also see "fingers" in the oil – this means it looks like the oil is stretching and moving in places when it swirls. If you see smoke coming from the oil, it's too hot.

If you're not sure whether your oil is hot enough, you can test it with a splash of water. If the water sizzles and immediately evaporates, your pan is hot. If it takes some time to evaporate, your pan is at a lower temperature.

You can also use a thermometer to test the temperature of your oil. A meat thermometer can be used for this purpose, but it must be able to tolerate high temperatures – some older meat thermometers have a lower temperature tolerance of 200-200°F. An oil thermometer, infrared thermometer, or candy thermometer is specifically designed for measuring extremely high temperatures.

Heating the pan first prevents food from sticking

The Science of Sticking

Even on a perfectly smooth surface with no cracks or imperfections, meat will still stick to the pan as proteins form molecular bonds with the metal. The goal is to get the meat to cook before it comes into contact with the metal by heating oil hot enough that it can cook the meat in the time it takes for it to pass from the air, through the film of oil, and into the pan.

The Role of Temperature

The difference between a crispy, delicious meal and a soggy, sad mess starts before food hits the pan. If the oil isn't hot enough, the food will soak it up instead of sizzling in it, and it won't taste as good. When the pan isn't hot enough, ingredients soak up the oil instead of crisping in it, and they're more likely to be soggy.

The Role of Moisture

The simple act of preheating your skillet properly will stop your food from sticking the majority of the time. When a pan is properly preheated, the moisture in the food wicks away from the surface of the pan, and the fat that you add to the pan makes a slip and slide for your food on top of that hot pan. A lukewarm pan will draw the moisture to the pan, and the moisture makes the food stick.

The Role of Oil

Cooking with fat not only provides a ton of flavour but also acts as a lubricant and helps your food release from the pan instead of simply burning onto it. If your food sticks, there is a chance that you simply didn't use enough oil. That said, you don't need to get carried away with oiling your food and cooking vessels—a thin layer of fat, combined with heat and time, should do the trick beautifully.

Heating the pan first prevents oil degradation

Heating the pan first is a good way to prevent oil degradation. When oil is heated, it breaks down, leading to flavour degradation and the release of toxic chemicals. The longer the oil is heated, the more it degrades and the lower its smoke point becomes.

Oil primarily degrades when heated above its smoke point, the temperature at which it begins to smoke and decompose. If you heat the pan first, you can ensure that the oil spends less time heating up and, therefore, less time degrading.

Additionally, heating the pan first can help prevent the oil from burning. If you heat the oil and the pan together, you may not realise that the oil is starting to burn as the pan will not yet be hot enough for cooking. However, if you heat the pan first and then add the oil, you can be sure that the oil will heat up instantly and be ready for cooking. This reduces the risk of the oil burning while you are waiting for the pan to heat up.

It is important to note that the type of pan you are using may affect whether you should heat the pan first. For example, non-stick pans heat up quickly, and high dry heat can cause them to deteriorate. Therefore, it is not recommended to preheat an empty non-stick pan.

Heating the pan first prevents water from bursting into steam

Heating the pan first is a good idea for several reasons. Firstly, it prevents the oil from burning. Oil can break down and burn quickly when heated without anything else in the pan to absorb the heat. Adding oil to a hot pan means it heats up instantly and is less likely to burn.

Secondly, heating the pan first helps to prevent the oil from spitting. If there is moisture in the pan, heating it first will force that moisture to evaporate. If there is a layer of oil on top of the moisture when it heats up, it can cause the oil to splatter.

Thirdly, heating the pan first is useful if you are aiming for a hard sear on your food. For example, when cooking a steak, you might want to get your pan up to 600°F. If you add oil to a cold pan, by the time the pan reaches 400°F, the oil will be at the same temperature and will start smoking. However, if you heat the pan first and then add a small amount of oil, you can get the pan to a higher temperature before adding your food, resulting in a better sear.

Finally, heating the pan first reduces the risk of absent-mindedness in the kitchen. If you heat oil in a pan and then get distracted, you may come back to a pan of flaming oil. If you heat the pan first and then add oil, you are less likely to forget about it, and if you do, it will be easier to deal with a hot, empty pan than a pan of burning oil.

Frequently asked questions