Pan Pizza Vs Thin Crust: Which Is Better?

Pizza is a dish that's beloved by people all over the world, and there are many ways to make it. But when it comes to choosing between pan pizza and hand-tossed pizza, the decision is not so simple. Pan pizza is baked in a deep dish, resulting in a thicker and doughier crust. This crust is often brushed with oil or butter, giving it a crispy exterior. The dough is made with high-gluten flour, which allows it to hold up under thick toppings. On the other hand, hand-tossed pizza is made by stretching and tossing the dough in the air by hand, creating a thin and crispy crust. This technique is iconic and gives the pizza an authentic feel. So, which one is better? Well, that depends on your personal preference! If you're craving a pizza with lots of toppings, then pan pizza is the way to go. But if you're in the mood for something simpler with minimal toppings, then hand-tossed pizza might be more your style.

Pan pizza is made in a pan and has a thicker, bready dough

Pan pizza is made in a deep dish pan or sheet pan, and its dough is spread out and baked in a circular pan or skillet. The dough is rolled out with a rolling pin and then spread inside a pan greased with olive oil. The dough is thicker and harder than hand-tossed pizza dough, and it is more bread-like and fluffy. It is often compared to focaccia bread, with a spongy and dense texture.

The thicker dough of the pan pizza means it can hold more toppings. It is usually loaded up with sauce, several different cheeses, and various toppings. The dough is covered in oil, so the crust is crispy, as if it has been fried. The bottom and sides of the crust become fried and crispy in the oil used to coat the pan.

Pan pizza is baked at a higher temperature than hand-tossed pizza. It is baked at around 550° F (287° C) for about 15 minutes or until the crust is golden and crispy. The dough rises a lot because its air bubbles stay intact, resulting in a thick and chewy crust.

The best way to eat pan pizza is with a fork and knife due to its thick crust and toppings. However, there is no right or wrong way to eat pizza, and it is meant to be enjoyed however you like.

Pan pizza is often confused with deep-dish pizza

Deep-dish pizza is characterised by its thick, tender crust, which serves as the perfect companion to hearty toppings. The crust is typically thicker and breadier than that of pan pizza, and it is made with a combination of yeast and baking powder. Baking powder is added to minimise the formation of large air pockets and to soften the dough. Deep-dish pizza is usually baked at a low temperature (400°F) for 25-30 minutes, resulting in a soft and tender crust.

On the other hand, pan pizza has a softer and more buttery crust compared to regular hand-tossed pizza. It is baked in a deep, round pan with sloping sides, similar to a cake pan. The dough is pressed into the pan and baked until golden and crispy. Pan pizza is baked at a higher temperature (475-500°F) for a shorter amount of time (12-15 minutes), resulting in a lighter and less chewy crust.

While both types of pizza are considered thick-crust varieties, deep-dish pizza has a thicker and flakier crust, while pan pizza has a softer and more airy interior. Deep-dish pizza is known for its generous amount of toppings, while pan pizza is more versatile and can accommodate both meat and vegetable toppings.

In conclusion, while pan pizza and deep-dish pizza share some similarities, they are distinct types of pizza with unique characteristics and flavours.

Pan pizza has a thicker crust that is fried to a golden colour in the pan

Pan pizza is a popular alternative to the traditional round pizza, and it is characterised by its thick and chewy crust. The dough is rolled out with a rolling pin and then placed in a cake pan or skillet greased with olive oil. The olive oil gives the crust a crispy, fried texture, as if it has been fried to a golden colour in the pan.

The dough for pan pizza is denser and contains more air bubbles than traditional round pizza, resulting in a thicker crust. The thickness of the crust can vary depending on the size of the pan and the amount of dough used. The pans can be round, square, or rectangular, and the depth will depend on the desired thickness of the pizza. A deeper pan will create a thicker crust, while a shallow pan will result in a thinner crust.

The olive oil used to grease the pan plays a crucial role in achieving the desired golden colour and crispy texture of the crust. When baked, the edges of the crust will become a golden brown, creating a delicious contrast between the crispy exterior and the soft, chewy interior.

The baking temperature for pan pizza is typically higher than that of traditional round pizza, with most recipes calling for a temperature of around 550° F (287° C). The higher temperature ensures that the thicker dough is cooked through, resulting in a crust that is golden and crispy.

In addition to its thick crust, pan pizza is also characterised by its generous toppings. The thicker crust can support more toppings, including sauce, cheese, vegetables, and meats. The toppings are added before the sauce, which is poured on top. This assembly method ensures that the toppings are securely anchored to the pizza, creating a cohesive and flavourful bite.

The best way to eat pan pizza is with a fork and knife due to its thick crust and abundant toppings. Cutting it into squares is a popular serving method, especially for those who prepare it at home.

Pan pizza is topped with sauce, cheese, and toppings, in that order

Pan pizza is a rectangular pizza cooked in a pan and cut and eaten in squares. It is believed that the homeland of true Italian pizza is Naples, where the first pizzerias opened in the late 18th and early 19th centuries.

To make a pan pizza, roll the dough out with a rolling pin and spread it inside a cake pan or skillet greased with olive oil. Then, add your cheese, followed by your toppings, and finish with the sauce.

When it comes to baking, pan pizzas are usually baked at a higher temperature than hand-tossed pizzas. They are baked at around 550° F (287° C) for 15 minutes or more.

Thin-crust pizza tends to be greasy and not stiff enough to hold the weight of the toppings. Thin crusts are also considered more of a meal than a dessert

Thin-crust pizza is a divisive option, with some people preferring it over the thick crust and others not. One of the main reasons for this preference might be that thin-crust pizza tends to be greasy and not stiff enough to hold the weight of the toppings.

The thin crust, when loaded with toppings, can be difficult to eat without a knife and fork as it tends to bend and droop under the weight of the toppings. This can be a deal-breaker for some, as it takes away the convenience of eating pizza with your hands. However, there are techniques to counter this issue, such as folding the slice or using two hands to hold it.

The thin crust's inability to support the weight of toppings also limits the amount that can be added. This can be a disadvantage for those who enjoy a generous serving of toppings on their pizza. Thin-crust pizzas are usually made with a finely pureed tomato sauce, shredded mozzarella, and thinly sliced meats. While this combination can be delicious, the limited space on the crust means that the quantity of toppings is reduced.

Another reason why some people may prefer thick-crust pizza is that thin-crust pizza is considered more of a meal than a dessert. The thin crust has a smaller form factor, making it ideal for parties as it is easy to eat while socialising, playing games, or dancing. However, for a sit-down dinner, a thick-crust pizza might be preferred as it is more substantial and filling.

Despite these challenges, thin-crust pizza has its advantages. It has fewer calories and carbohydrates than thick-crust pizza, making it a healthier option for those watching their weight. It also has less salt, sodium, and saturated fat. Additionally, the thin crust allows the flavours of the toppings to shine through, as it becomes less of the main character and more of a supporting player.

In conclusion, while thin-crust pizza may not be stiff enough to hold heavy toppings and is considered more of a meal, it has its benefits. These include a lower calorie count, a better balance of flavours, and the convenience of a smaller size. Ultimately, the preference for thin or thick crust comes down to individual taste and the specific occasion.

Frequently asked questions