Hot Or Cold Pan: When To Add Oil?

Whether you add oil to a hot or cold pan depends on several factors, including the type of pan, the type of oil, and the type of food being cooked. For non-stick pans, it is generally recommended to add a small amount of oil to the pan first before heating, as heating a non-stick pan without oil can damage the coating and release unhealthy fumes. For regular pans, there are differing opinions—some say that heating the pan first ensures the oil heats up instantly and is less likely to stick, while others argue that adding oil to a hot pan can cause it to smoke and degrade, filling the kitchen with fumes. Ultimately, it is a matter of preference, as long as the pan is hot enough when food is added.

Non-stick pans should always be heated with oil inside

Non-stick pans are designed for moderate heat and are not made for high heat. Therefore, it is not recommended to preheat them for more than 30 seconds or at high settings. The pans get too hot too fast, which can damage the non-stick surface, potentially release toxins, and even cause the pan to warp.

When using a non-stick pan, it is recommended to add a light coat of oil or fat to the pan as soon as it is exposed to heat. This is because cooking fat amplifies the coating's effect, and some non-stick pans can release toxins when heated without any cooking fat in the pan. Adding oil or fat to the pan at the beginning also helps to indicate when the pan is ready for cooking, as the oil will start to shimmer or lightly smoke.

It is important to note that non-stick pans should not be used with cooking spray, as this can build up and become difficult to remove, damaging the non-stick surface. Instead, it is recommended to use oils such as olive oil, avocado oil, or butter.

Stainless steel pans should be heated dry

When cooking with stainless steel pans, it is best to heat the pan first and then add oil. This is because stainless steel pans have minuscule fissures, pores, and gaps in their surface. When you add cold oil to a cold stainless steel pan, the oil seeps into these tiny pores. As the pan heats up, the metal expands, trapping the oil and making your food more likely to stick to the pan. It also makes the pan harder to clean.

On the other hand, when you add cold oil to a hot stainless steel pan, the pores and gaps in the surface have already closed as the metal expands. The oil warms up on contact and becomes looser and more liquid. It will slide on the surface of the pan and spread out easily.

Heating the pan first also means that the oil is less likely to get trapped in the fissures as the pan cools, making the pan easier to clean. The consistency of the oil changes at higher heat, and adding oil to a preheated pan brings it up to the appropriate temperature faster than if you add the oil to a cold pan.

To know when your stainless steel pan is hot enough, you can do the "water test". Flick a drop of water onto the surface of the dry pan. If it sizzles, your pan is at a medium heat. If the water droplet rolls around on the surface of the pan, you are at a medium-high or high heat. Then, add your oil.

It is important to note that this advice does not apply to non-stick pans. For non-stick pans, you should add a little oil to the pan first before heating.

Olive oil is a good choice for pan-frying and sautéing

Olive oil is a great choice for pan-frying and sautéing. It has a high smoke point, ranging from 350° to 410° F, which is higher than that of butter (302°F). This makes olive oil suitable for most stovetop cooking, as the temperature required for sautéing is about 320° F.

There are different types of olive oil, each with varying smoke points. Regular olive oil, for example, has a higher smoke point than extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) because it is made from a blend of refined olive oil and virgin olive oil, which has been treated with heat and chemicals to remove defects in flavour. This process also raises the smoke point to about 390°-470° F, making regular olive oil a good choice for pan-frying.

Light olive oil is another good option for pan-frying. It is a combination of refined olive oil and virgin olive oil, with only 5-10% virgin oil, resulting in a high smoke point and neutral flavour. However, it has fewer health benefits than EVOO as many antioxidants are missing.

EVOO can be used for pan-frying, but it is best to keep the temperature at medium to prevent the flavour from degrading. It is also best to cook quickly when using EVOO for pan-frying.

When pan-frying, it is important to get the oil to the right temperature. The oil should be hot enough to sizzle, but not so hot that the food becomes brown before the interior is cooked. The sweet spot is about 375° F.

In summary, olive oil is a versatile and flavourful option for pan-frying and sautéing, with a high smoke point that makes it suitable for most stovetop cooking. The type of olive oil and temperature used will depend on the specific dish being prepared.

The Leidenfrost effect can be used to test the temperature of a pan

To test the temperature of a pan using the Leidenfrost effect, one can sprinkle drops of water onto the pan as it heats up. Initially, when the pan is below 100 °C (212 °F), the water will stay liquid or slowly evaporate. As the temperature rises above 100 °C, water droplets will hiss and evaporate quickly when they touch the pan. When the temperature reaches the Leidenfrost point, which is approximately 193 °C (379 °F) for water, the water droplets will form small balls that skid and scoot over the surface of the pan, taking a long time to evaporate.

This effect occurs because the bottom of the water droplet vaporises immediately when it comes into contact with the hot pan, creating a layer of gas that suspends the rest of the droplet above the pan, preventing direct contact and slowing down heat transfer.

Using the Leidenfrost effect to test the temperature of a pan can be a simple way for cooks to gauge the heat without a thermometer. However, it is important to note that the temperature at which the Leidenfrost effect appears can vary depending on the liquid used and other factors. Additionally, if the pan is heated above the smoke point of the oil or fat used for cooking, it can lead to degradation and the release of toxic chemicals, so care must be taken not to overheat the pan.

Oil added to a hot pan will heat up instantly

There are differing opinions on whether oil should be added to a hot or cold pan. Some sources claim that oil should be added to a hot pan, while others argue that it is better to add oil to a cold pan and heat them together. Here is an exploration of the idea that oil added to a hot pan will heat up instantly.

Oil Added to a Hot Pan

Adding oil to a hot pan is a common practice, especially when using stainless steel or aluminium cookware. This method ensures that the oil heats up instantly, achieving the desired temperature for cooking. It is crucial to be cautious and avoid overheating the pan before adding the oil, as this can lead to splattering and potential grease fires.

Advantages of Adding Oil to a Hot Pan

One significant advantage of adding oil to a hot pan is the visual cues it provides. As the oil heats up, it ripples, shimmers, and eventually barely smokes, indicating that it is ready for cooking. This helps prevent overheating the pan, which can be a risk when heating a dry pan.

Additionally, adding oil to a hot pan can be beneficial for searing and browning certain foods. It ensures that the oil reaches the desired temperature quickly, allowing for better searing and browning of the ingredients.

Factors to Consider

It is important to note that the type of oil and cookware used can influence the decision to add oil to a hot or cold pan. When using oils with a high smoke point, such as peanut or grapeseed oil, adding them to a hot pan is generally safe. However, oils with a low smoke point, like olive oil, may burn instantly if the pan is very hot.

The type of cookware also matters. For non-stick pans, it is generally recommended to add oil to a cold pan to avoid damaging the coating. On the other hand, when using carbon steel or cast-iron pans, some people prefer to heat the dry pan first and then add the oil to achieve a non-stick surface through the seasoning process.

In conclusion, adding oil to a hot pan can be advantageous as it allows the oil to heat up instantly, providing visual cues about the temperature and enabling better searing and browning of certain foods. However, it is essential to consider the type of oil and cookware used, as well as the risks associated with overheating the pan. Ultimately, the decision to add oil to a hot or cold pan may depend on personal preference and the specific cooking requirements.

Frequently asked questions