The Truth About Iron Pan Seasoning: Is It Leaching Chemicals?

Cast iron pans are popular, especially for searing, and are generally safe to use. However, they can leach iron, which is a strong pro-oxidant. The amount of iron leached depends on the condition of the pan, the type of food being cooked, and the cooking time. Newer and less-seasoned pans tend to leach more iron than older and heavily-seasoned ones. Acidic foods with high moisture content, such as tomato sauce and applesauce, absorb more iron, while foods with shorter cooking times and less frequent stirring absorb less.

While iron is an essential dietary mineral, and the additional iron from cast iron pans can be beneficial for those with iron deficiency, it can be harmful for those with iron overload or at risk for iron overload. Those with hemochromatosis, a genetic condition that causes the body to absorb an abnormal amount of iron, should avoid using cast iron cookware as it can contribute to iron toxicity.

To reduce iron leaching, it is recommended to use well-seasoned cast iron pans and avoid cooking acidic foods for prolonged periods. Enameled cast iron cookware, which has a protective enamel coating, is another option that does not leach iron into food.

Iron pans can leach iron into food, especially when new

For most people, however, the amount of iron leached from cast iron pans is small and not harmful. In fact, it can be beneficial for those who are anemic. Studies have shown that cooking with cast iron can help raise iron levels in anemic individuals.

The amount of iron leached depends on several factors, including the age of the pan, the type of food being cooked, and the cooking time. Newer pans leach more iron than older, well-seasoned pans. Acidic foods with high moisture content, such as applesauce and tomato sauce, absorb the most iron. Cooking food for longer periods of time also increases the amount of iron leached.

To reduce the amount of iron leached from cast iron pans, it is recommended to season the pan regularly and avoid cooking acidic foods for extended periods. Enameled cast iron cookware is another option, as it has a protective enamel coating that prevents iron from leaching into food.

Acidic foods cooked in iron pans absorb more iron

Acidic foods cooked in iron pans do absorb more iron. In fact, cooking in an iron skillet can add significant amounts of iron to your food and body. A study by Y.J. Cheng and H.C. Brittin, published in the Journal of Food Science in 1991, found that both applesauce and spaghetti sauce picked up a measurable amount of iron after being cooked in cast-iron pots. When cooked in glass dishes, the iron content of the foods was negligible. However, when cooked in cast-iron pots, the spaghetti sauce picked up about 2 mg of iron per 100g of sauce, and the applesauce picked up 6 mg per 100g.

The ability of cast-iron cookware to impart a small amount of iron to foods cooked in it can be beneficial for those looking to boost their iron intake. The amount of iron transferred is enough to be a significant source of dietary iron but not enough to pose any risk of iron overload in healthy people. The recommended daily intake of iron is 8 mg for men and 18 mg for women. A typical serving of spaghetti sauce or applesauce (about 250g) cooked in a cast-iron pot would provide around 6-8 mg of additional iron.

It is important to note that not all foods benefit equally from being cooked in iron skillets. Dry, non-acidic foods like pancakes, rice, and green beans don't pick up much iron. Additionally, certain factors can increase the amount of iron absorbed by food, such as longer cooking times, frequent stirring, and using a newer iron skillet.

While iron from cast-iron cookware can be a beneficial source of dietary iron for some individuals, it is important to be cautious if you are at risk for iron overload or have young children. Too much iron can lead to a condition called iron toxicity, especially in children under three, with symptoms including nausea, diarrhea, and hemorrhaging. Therefore, it is recommended to avoid cooking foods for young children in iron pots and to be aware of your iron intake if you are at risk for iron overload.

Cooking in an iron pan for longer increases iron absorption

Cooking in an iron pan for longer does indeed increase iron absorption. In fact, there are several factors that contribute to how much iron is leached from the pan into your food.

The age of the pan is one factor. A newer iron pan will cause more iron absorption than an older, well-seasoned pan. This is because older pans have smooth, hardened surfaces, whereas newer pans are more likely to stick to food, allowing more iron to be transferred.

The type of food also makes a difference. Acidic foods with higher moisture content, such as applesauce and spaghetti sauce, absorb the most iron. Dry, non-acidic foods like pancakes, rice, and green beans don't pick up as much iron.

Cooking time is another factor. The longer food is cooked in an iron pan, the more iron it will absorb. This is because longer cooking times allow for more contact between the food and the iron pan. Similarly, stirring food more frequently can increase iron absorption for the same reason.

The amount of iron that leaches into food from an iron pan can be significant. For example, the iron content of 100 grams of spaghetti sauce can increase from 0.6 mg to 5.7 mg after being cooked in a cast-iron pot. This is well within the recommended daily intake of iron, which is 8 mg for men and 18 mg for women.

While cooking in an iron pan can increase iron absorption, it is important to note that too much iron can be harmful. Iron overload has been linked to various health conditions, and certain groups of people, such as children under three, are particularly susceptible to iron toxicity. Therefore, it is advisable to avoid cooking foods for young children in iron pots. Additionally, those genetically at risk for iron overload should be cautious when using iron pans.

People with hemochromatosis should avoid cooking with iron pans

A 1986 study found that nearly every food tested had increased levels of iron after being cooked in cast iron. The study also found that foods cooked for longer periods of time absorbed more iron, as did foods that were stirred more frequently. Acidic foods with a higher moisture content, such as applesauce and tomato sauce, absorbed the most iron.

For people with hemochromatosis, the risk of iron overload is much more serious. Cast iron pans are generally safe to use, but they can leach iron, which is a strong pro-oxidant. The body cannot get rid of excess iron, and it has a tendency to produce free radicals, which are linked to a wide variety of serious health conditions.

If you have hemochromatosis, it is best to avoid cooking with cast iron pans and instead opt for pure ceramic, enameled cast-iron, or glass-ceramic cookware, which will not leach any iron into your food.

Iron pans are safe for most people

Cast iron pans are generally safe to use. They have been used for over a thousand years, and their longevity speaks to their safety. However, they can leach iron, which is a strong pro-oxidant. This means that for some people, especially those with certain genetic conditions, cast iron pans may not be the best option.

Who should be cautious of using cast iron pans?

People with the genetic condition hemochromatosis, or iron overload syndrome, should avoid using cast iron pans. This is because cast iron pans can leach iron into food during the cooking process, and too much iron can be harmful. For people with hemochromatosis, even small amounts of additional iron can be dangerous.

People with hemochromatosis can absorb too much dietary iron, which can lead to a build-up of iron in the body. This excess iron is stored in organs like the heart, liver, and pancreas, and can cause damage to these organs. Symptoms of iron overload can include joint pain, fatigue, weight loss, and stomach pain. Treatment for hemochromatosis often involves regular bloodletting to reduce iron levels.

It is estimated that up to 0.5% of people of European ancestry have hemochromatosis, and the condition is more common in those with Irish and Scottish ancestry. However, many people with hemochromatosis do not know they have the condition, especially women, who may not be diagnosed until after menopause.

The amount of iron leached from cast iron pans depends on several factors, including the age and seasoning of the pan, the type of food being cooked, and the cooking time. Newer and less-seasoned pans will leach more iron than older, well-seasoned pans. Acidic foods with high moisture content, such as tomato sauce and applesauce, will absorb more iron, especially if they are cooked for longer periods of time.

Studies have found that cooking with cast iron can increase the iron content of food by several milligrams, and in some cases, this can exceed the recommended daily intake of iron. For example, one study found that cooking 100 grams of applesauce in a cast iron skillet increased the iron content from 0.35 mg to 7.3 mg. However, it is important to note that the iron leached from cast iron pans is in the non-heme form, which is not absorbed as well as heme iron from meat.

Another potential concern with using cast iron pans is the seasoning process, which involves coating the pan with oil and heating it to create a non-stick surface. There is some uncertainty about the health effects of consuming tiny amounts of oxidized oil from the seasoning over a long period of time. However, this risk is probably not very large, and the benefits of a non-stick surface may outweigh any potential risks.

In conclusion, while cast iron pans are generally safe for most people, those with hemochromatosis or other iron overload conditions should avoid using them to prevent further increasing their iron levels. For everyone else, cast iron pans can be a safe and healthy option, especially for those who are anaemic or need to increase their iron intake.

Frequently asked questions