Stoneware Vs Steel: Baking's Best Friend?

Stoneware and steel pans are two of the most popular types of bakeware, each with their own unique properties that can affect the outcome of your baked goods. Metal pans are durable, easy to clean, and conduct heat well, making them ideal for baking cookies, cakes, and breads. However, metal pans can cause your baked goods to over-brown or even burn on the bottom if not lined with parchment paper or a silicone mat. On the other hand, stoneware is known for its durability and strength and can be used in the oven at any temperature. It is a hard, chemically inert material that makes cooking food safe. Additionally, stoneware has a rustic aesthetic, making it perfect for special occasions and family reunions. So, which one bakes better? The answer depends on what you are baking and your personal preferences. Both stoneware and steel pans have their pros and cons, and choosing the right one for you involves considering factors such as heat conduction, weight, budget, and the type of food you plan to bake.

Stoneware is nonporous, while ceramic is porous

Stoneware and ceramic are two different types of materials used for bakeware. While they may look similar, there is a key difference between them: stoneware is nonporous, while ceramic is porous.

The production of pottery involves turning soft, soluble clay into hard insoluble ceramics by moulding it into the required shape, drying it out, and then firing it in a kiln, which is essentially an extremely hot oven. During the firing process, the clay undergoes chemical and physical changes to become ceramic.

Ceramic is a broad term that refers to clay once it has undergone an irreversible change into something hard and insoluble. However, different types of ceramics have different qualities. One of these qualities is porosity, which refers to the percentage of void or pore space in the ceramic ware.

Earthenware, a type of ceramic, is relatively porous compared to stoneware. If dunked in water, it will absorb water like a sponge. Because of its porous nature, earthenware needs to be coated in pottery glaze to be watertight. On the other hand, stoneware is non-porous and does not need to be glazed. When stoneware clay is fired correctly, it will not absorb or leak water once it has been made into ceramic.

The difference in porosity between stoneware and ceramic has several implications for their use as bakeware. Firstly, it affects their durability. Earthenware is weaker than stoneware due to its porous nature, making it more susceptible to chipping and breaking. Stoneware, being less porous, is a tougher and more durable material.

Secondly, the porosity affects the suitability of the materials for different types of baking. Ceramic dishes are suitable for dishes that need to be baked slowly and evenly, such as casseroles, pies, lasagnas, tarts, and quiches. Stoneware, being nonporous, is better for baked goods that benefit from a crispy exterior, as its surface helps absorb moisture.

In summary, while stoneware and ceramic may appear similar, they have distinct qualities due to their difference in porosity. Stoneware is nonporous, making it more durable and suitable for baked goods that need a crispy exterior. Ceramic is porous, which makes it more prone to chipping and breaking, but also ideal for dishes that require slow and even baking.

Stoneware is safe at any oven temperature

Stoneware is a durable ceramic material that is often used to make dishes designed to go in the oven, such as pie dishes, baking trays, and casserole dishes. It is generally safe to use in the oven, but there are a few things to keep in mind.

First, check that your stoneware is labelled as oven-safe by the manufacturer. Most stoneware is oven-safe, but not all, and it's important to be sure before using it in the oven. The label will usually say 'oven-proof' or 'oven-safe', or there may be a symbol indicating that it is safe for oven use. If your stoneware doesn't have a label, you can try contacting the manufacturer to find out if it is oven-safe.

Second, be mindful of the maximum temperature that your stoneware can withstand. Different brands of stoneware have different maximum temperatures, with some being safe up to 350° F (176.7° C) and others safe up to 450° F (232° C). Going beyond this maximum temperature can cause your stoneware to crack.

Third, avoid sudden temperature changes when using stoneware in the oven. Stoneware is sensitive to rapid changes in temperature, which can cause thermal shock and lead to cracking or breaking. It's best to avoid taking stoneware directly from the fridge or freezer and placing it into a preheated oven. Instead, allow it to come to room temperature first. Similarly, don't place hot stoneware directly onto a cold surface, as this can also cause thermal shock.

Fourth, don't heat an empty stoneware dish in the oven. Always have food in the dish when using it in a hot oven, and make sure that the dish is only slightly larger than the food being heated. This helps to ensure even heating and reduces the risk of breaking.

Finally, don't use stoneware under direct heat, such as on a stove, hob, grill, or broiler. The intense, uneven heat from these sources can put a lot of strain on the stoneware and cause it to crack or shatter. Some stoneware manufacturers do make items that are suitable for use under a broiler, but it's important to follow their specific guidelines for safe use.

By following these guidelines, you can safely use stoneware in the oven at any temperature within the specified limits. Stoneware is a great option for baking and roasting due to its durability, even heat distribution, and ability to retain heat, resulting in even cooking and maintaining temperature even when removed from the oven.

Stoneware is more durable than steel

Stoneware is a type of ceramic dinnerware made from stoneware clay and fired at temperatures between 2150 and 2330 degrees Fahrenheit. It is thicker and more opaque than porcelain or china due to its thicker construction and material makeup.

Additionally, stoneware is more durable because of the clay's natural flexibility and the additional moisture used in the manufacturing process. The flexibility of the clay allows it to absorb shock more effectively, making it less likely to chip or break. Stoneware is also less prone to chipping than steel, as the added rigidity of steel comes at the expense of tensile strength, making it less resilient to everyday stresses like being dropped.

Furthermore, stoneware is a popular choice for both tableware and cooking tools due to its low price. Stoneware is less expensive than steel since it requires less severe firing temperatures, and its clay and additives are readily available and inexpensive.

Finally, stoneware holds heat very well, making it ideal for baking. It produces well-browned bottoms, crispy edges, and completely cooked centres. Stoneware's ability to retain heat also means that it can keep food warm for longer, which is advantageous for serving meals.

Stoneware is cheaper than steel

Stoneware is also a great option for those who are new to baking. It gradually conducts heat, and food doesn't stick to its cooking surface. It is also easy to clean and is versatile enough to be used in the stove or oven/broiler. It is also dishwasher-safe and can be used for a variety of foods since it has a non-stick cooking surface and doesn't react with acidic or alkaline foods.

Stoneware is made of clay or stone particles. You can get cookware that is entirely stoneware or has other kinds of metals such as aluminum and a heavy stoneware coating. It is also non-toxic, lightweight, durable, and easy to clean.

However, stoneware might not be the best option for cooking methods that require extremely high heat due to its slower heat conduction. It is also more brittle compared to steel and has poor heating properties.

Stoneware is lighter than steel

The weight of any object depends on its volume and the density of the material from which it is made. Density is defined as the mass per unit volume of a substance. For two objects of the same volume, the one with the higher density will be heavier. For two objects made of the same material, the one with the larger volume will be heavier.

Stoneware and steel are both used for baking, but they have different properties that make them suitable for different types of baked goods. Stoneware is made from clay, which is fired at high temperatures to make it resistant to liquids and durable. It is non-porous, meaning it does not absorb water or other liquids. Stoneware is also a good heat conductor and distributes heat evenly, making it suitable for baking bread and pizzas.

Steel is a metal that is also used for baking. It is a good heat conductor and has high thermal conductivity, which means it absorbs and releases heat quickly. This makes it suitable for baking flatbreads like pizza and focaccia, as it cooks the bottom crust quickly. However, steel can be too conductive for loaf breads, as it can burn the bottom of the loaf before the rest of the crust or interior is cooked.

In summary, stoneware is lighter than steel because it is made from clay, which has a lower density than metal. Stoneware and steel have different properties that make them suitable for different types of baking, but both can be used to create delicious baked goods.

Frequently asked questions