Reusing Turkey Fryer Oil: How Many Times Is Safe?

Turkey fryer oil can be reused several times, but it's important to know when it's gone bad. The number of times you can reuse it depends on the type of oil, what you're frying, and how well you've strained it. Peanut oil, for example, can be used three or four times to fry turkeys before it shows signs of deterioration. Under normal conditions, oil can be heated for up to six hours, so you can fry six items on six different occasions with a single batch of oil. However, if the oil has become dark or dirty, is smoking excessively, or has developed a rancid smell, it's time to discard it.

How to store and reuse turkey fryer oil

You can reuse oil from deep-frying a turkey, provided it was properly stored. According to the National Turkey Federation, after frying, the oil needs to be strained, filtered and cooled. Then put it in a covered container and refrigerate or freeze it so that it won't go rancid. The oil will thicken, but will return to its original consistency when reheated, and any cloudiness will clear up as well with reheating. The oil may remain in the refrigerator for several months or until signs of deterioration begin. Peanut oil, the most common oil for frying a turkey, may be used three or four times to fry turkeys before signs of deterioration begin. Watch for foaming, darkening or smoking excessively — these are all signs that your oil has gone rancid and needs to be discarded. Other signs of bad oil include a rancid smell and/or failure to bubble when food is added.

Under normal conditions, oil can be heated for up to six hours. A deep-fried turkey can cook in under an hour (three minutes per pound) so you can fry six items on six different occasions with a single batch of oil.

One person on a forum said they reuse their turkey fryer oil many times over, but they keep separate oil for fish so that everything doesn't taste like fish.

Frying oil can be reused anywhere from two times to up to eight times — it all depends on the type of oil, what you’re frying in it, how well you’ve strained it, and more. There’s no hard and fast rule for when oil is no longer suitable for frying; instead, pay attention to your oil and detect any changes. If it’s become dark or dirty; if it’s smoking before it reaches frying temperature or foaming at the top; or if it’s taken on a different smell (besides whatever foods you’ve fried in it) that is rancid or musty, then it’s probably time to dispose of it.

How to tell if turkey fryer oil has gone bad

You can reuse oil from deep-frying a turkey, but it's important to know when it has gone bad.

Peanut oil, the most common oil for frying a turkey, can be used three or four times to fry turkeys before signs of deterioration begin. However, there is no hard and fast rule for when oil is no longer suitable for frying, so it's important to pay attention to the oil and detect any changes.

Oil that has gone bad will have a rancid, fishy odour. It may also appear cloudy or opaque rather than clear gold. Other signs of bad oil include foaming, darkening or smoking excessively. Oil that has separated into layers has also gone bad.

To prevent oil from going bad, keep moisture out by drying food thoroughly and not overfilling the fryer. Any water can cause splatter and quicker spoilage. Discard the oil after six total hours of cooking time.

How many times you can reuse turkey fryer oil

You can reuse oil from deep-frying a turkey, but it's important to store it properly. After frying, the oil needs to be strained, filtered and cooled. Then put it in a covered container and refrigerate or freeze it so that it won't go rancid. The oil will thicken, but will return to its original consistency when reheated, and any cloudiness will clear up as well.

Peanut oil, the most common oil for frying a turkey, may be used three or four times to fry turkeys before signs of deterioration begin. Watch out for foaming, darkening or smoking excessively — these are all signs that your oil has gone rancid and needs to be discarded. Other signs of bad oil include a rancid smell and/or failure to bubble when food is added.

Under normal conditions, oil can be heated for up to six hours. A deep-fried turkey can cook in under an hour (three minutes per pound) so you can fry six items on six different occasions with a single batch of oil.

There’s no hard and fast rule for when oil is no longer suitable for frying; instead, pay attention to your oil and detect any changes. If it’s become dark or dirty; if it’s smoking before it reaches frying temperature or foaming at the top; or if it’s taken on a different smell, then it’s probably time to dispose of it.

What to fry in turkey fryer oil

You can reuse oil from deep-frying a turkey, provided it was properly stored. The National Turkey Federation recommends that after frying, the oil needs to be strained, filtered and cooled. Then put it in a covered container and refrigerate or freeze it so that it won't go rancid. The oil will thicken, but will return to its original consistency when reheated, and any cloudiness will clear up as well with reheating. The oil may remain in the refrigerator for several months or until signs of deterioration begin.

Peanut oil, the most common oil for frying a turkey, may be used three or four times to fry turkeys before signs of deterioration begin. However, frying oil can be reused anywhere from two to eight times, depending on the type of oil, what you're frying in it, and how well you've strained it.

Some foods that can be fried in a turkey fryer include chicken wings, french fries, onion rings, corn dogs, and fish. However, it's recommended to use separate oil for fish, as the flavour can be overpowering.

It's important to watch for signs that your oil has gone rancid and needs to be discarded. These signs include foaming, darkening, or smoking excessively. Other signs of bad oil include a rancid smell and/or failure to bubble when food is added.

How much oil is needed to fry a turkey

Peanut oil is the most common oil for frying a turkey, and it can be reused three or four times before it shows signs of deterioration. However, frying oil can be reused anywhere from two to eight times, depending on the type of oil, what you're frying, and how well you've strained it. Watch out for foaming, darkening, or smoking excessively, as these are signs that your oil has gone rancid and needs to be discarded.

The amount of oil needed to fry a turkey depends on the size of the bird and the pot you're using. A good rule of thumb is that for every pound of meat, you'll need about a third of a gallon of oil. So, for a 12-14 pound turkey, you'll need around 3-4 gallons of oil. If you're using a 29qt pot, this amount of oil should be sufficient. However, it's always a good idea to check the "Max Fill Line" on your turkey frying pot to ensure you don't overfill it.

To know the exact amount of oil needed, you can place the turkey in the pot and fill it with water. Then, remove the turkey and measure the water. This will give you the precise amount of oil required to successfully fry your turkey.

It's important to note that the temperature of the oil is crucial when frying a turkey. Bring the oil to 400 degrees F, but do not let it exceed this temperature as it can be dangerous and catch fire. Keep the oil covered when heating, and ensure your turkey is fully thawed before frying.

Frequently asked questions