Copper Pans: How Much Is Enough?

Copper cookware is highly prized for its ability to conduct heat quickly and evenly, making it a powerful tool in the kitchen. However, it is not cheap and requires careful maintenance. Copper is reactive and can be toxic if it comes into direct contact with certain food acids, so copper pans are usually lined with a non-reactive metal such as tin, stainless steel, nickel, or silver. The thickness of the copper also matters, with thicker copper offering unique benefits for cooking. For example, a thin copper pan (2mm or less) heats up and cools down quickly, making it ideal for delicate sauces, while a thicker copper pan (2.5mm or more) changes temperature more slowly and retains heat better for tasks like browning meat and sautéing vegetables.

Copper is safe to cook with as long as it's lined with a non-reactive metal

Copper is a beautiful metal that has been used to make tools for around 10,000 years. It is also an excellent conductor of heat, making it a popular choice for cookware. However, copper is a reactive metal, and large amounts of it can leach into food and be poisonous. For this reason, copper cookware is usually lined with a non-reactive metal such as tin, nickel, or stainless steel.

Tin is a traditional lining for copper pots. It is chemically bonded with copper and doesn't react with acids. It is also relatively non-stick. However, it has a low melting point of around 450°F, so it can wear through. In the US, few chefs use copper lined with tin, but it is common in France.

Another option is to line copper cookware with stainless steel. This is a more modern approach, as stainless steel is more durable than tin. However, stainless steel does not bond well with copper, and the layers have to be mechanically forced together. If a stainless steel-lined copper pan is left over heat, it can delaminate and explode. Stainless steel also doesn't conduct heat as well as tin, so it tends to dull the magic of the copper.

A third option is to use copper cookware with a core, plate, or layer of stainless steel. This is designed to combine convenience and conductivity. However, the results are debatable, and you may end up paying over $100 more for a very thin layer of copper.

In conclusion, copper cookware is safe to use as long as it is lined with a non-reactive metal such as tin or stainless steel. The type of lining you choose will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Tin is a better conductor of heat and is relatively non-stick, but it has a low melting point. Stainless steel is more durable but doesn't conduct heat as well and can be more expensive.

Copper is a good conductor of heat, warming quickly and evenly

Copper pans are desirable for their ability to heat up quickly and distribute heat evenly, avoiding burnt spots and scalding. This is due to the high number of free electrons in copper, which are responsible for conducting heat. Copper's atomic structure is also more compact and dense, allowing for better contact between atoms and efficient heat transfer.

The thickness of copper pans is important for optimal heat distribution. Pans should be 2.5 to 3mm thick, which is thick enough for even heating but thin enough to maintain the copper's rapid response to heat.

Copper is also relatively affordable and aesthetically pleasing, making it a popular choice for cookware. However, it requires a lining as it is reactive and can leach into food. Linings can be made of non-reactive metals such as nickel, tin, or stainless steel.

Overall, copper's unique properties make it a superior material for heat conduction compared to other metals, which is why it is commonly used in cookware and electrical applications.

Copper pans are best at a thickness of 2.5 to 3mm

Copper pans of 2.5 to 3mm thickness strike a balance between weight and performance. They are rugged enough for the cooktop and oven but not too heavy to move around. Copper that is less than 2mm thick is considered light-duty copper, which is better suited for display or serving food at the table. On the other hand, copper that is more than 3mm thick is what some call "emotional cooking and collecting copper". These pieces feel good to own and use, but they are not necessarily better for cooking.

The ideal thickness for copper cookware depends on what you are cooking. For a frying pan, thicker is better as they are usually used to sear food. For a saucepan or saucier, a thinner gauge copper cookware is preferable as it will heat up liquids quickly and be extremely responsive when making sauces.

Copper pans are more expensive than other types of pans

Copper pans are significantly more expensive than other types of pans. This is due to a few factors. Firstly, copper is a more expensive metal than steel, which is used in other types of pans. Additionally, the manufacturing process for copper pans may be more costly, as fewer plants produce copper pans compared to those that produce stainless steel pans.

Another reason for the high price of copper pans is their superior performance in cooking. Copper is renowned for its exceptional ability to conduct heat and electricity, a feature not found in other types of metals used for pans. This quality makes copper an advantageous material for cooking, as it heats up quickly and evenly, resulting in uniform cooking without burnt spots or scalding. The even heating of copper pans also allows for better searing, as the heat remains consistent even when cold food is added to the pan.

The thickness of copper pans is another factor that contributes to their high price. For optimal performance, copper cookware should be between 2.5 to 3mm thick. A thicker copper pan provides better heat responsiveness and distribution. However, thicker copper also means a heavier pan, making it more challenging to use. As a result, copper pans with optimal thickness come at a higher price.

The lining of copper pans is another cost consideration. Copper is reactive, and cooking acidic foods can leach copper into the food, which can be harmful if ingested in large amounts. Therefore, most copper cookware is lined with a non-reactive metal such as nickel, tin, or stainless steel. Tin was traditionally used as a lining due to its non-reactivity and non-stick properties. However, tin has a low melting point, and modern copper pans often use stainless steel lining instead. Stainless steel is more durable but has poorer adhesive properties, and food is more likely to stick to it.

In conclusion, copper pans are more expensive than other types of pans due to the higher cost of the metal, the manufacturing process, their superior performance in cooking, the thickness of the copper, and the cost of lining the pans with non-reactive metals. While copper pans may be pricier, their even heating, responsiveness, and aesthetic appeal make them a desirable choice for cooks who value quality and performance in their cookware.

Copper pans are heavier than other types of pans

The weight of copper pans can make them difficult to manage for some people. Some copper pans can weigh 15 pounds or more when empty, and restaurant-grade pieces can weigh as much as 40 pounds.

However, the weight of copper pans also has benefits. Copper pans are heavy enough to sit firmly on the cooktop, reducing the risk of accidents. And despite their weight, copper pans are not too heavy to lift when transferring them on and off the heat or from the cooktop to the oven.

The weight of copper pans is also related to their thickness. Antique French copper pans were routinely made to be 3mm thick, and sometimes approached 4mm or even 5mm. Today, consumer-grade copper pans typically top out at 2.5mm thick, while a handful of artisan coppersmiths make copper pans that are 3mm thick.

The thickness of copper pans affects their cooking properties. Thinner copper pans (2mm or less) heat up and cool down quickly, which can be useful for delicate sauces. Thicker copper pans (2.5mm or more) change temperature more slowly and retain heat better, which is ideal for browning meat and sautéing vegetables.

Overall, while copper pans are heavier than other types of pans, their weight can provide stability and has benefits for cooking.

Frequently asked questions