Greenpan's Ceramic Coating: Safe Or Not?

GreenPan is a ceramic non-stick cookware company that markets itself as a healthier alternative to traditional non-stick cookware. The brand advertises its products as healthy ceramic non-stick and claims that they are free of harmful chemicals and toxins such as PFAS, PFOA, lead, and cadmium. However, there have been lawsuits and accusations against GreenPan for allegedly misrepresenting and greenwashing their products.

In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against The Cookware Company, the parent company of GreenPan, by a consumer who claimed she was misled by GreenPan's advertising and spent more money on a pan that was promised to be healthier and more environmentally friendly. The lawsuit pointed out several toxins present in GreenPan's Thermolon™ coating, including silane, aluminum oxide, tetraethoxysilane, methyltrimethoxysilane, and potassium titanate.

While GreenPan has maintained that their products are safe and non-toxic, the lack of transparency about the specific materials and chemical compounds used in their non-stick coating has raised concerns. The company has stopped releasing test reports since 2020, making it challenging to verify the safety of their products independently.

Some users have also reported issues with the performance and durability of GreenPan products, noting that the non-stick coating starts to deteriorate over time, causing food to stick and making it difficult to clean.

Overall, while GreenPan may offer a potentially safer alternative to traditional non-stick cookware, the lack of transparency and conflicting reports about the safety and performance of their products leave consumers with doubts about their reliability.

GreenPan's Thermolon coating

The Thermolon coating was introduced in 2007 as the first PTFE-free, nonstick cookware coating. Traditional nonstick coatings are made from plastic and contain chemicals such as PTFE (polytetrafluoroethylene) and PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid), which are toxic and can lead to serious health conditions. GreenPan's Thermolon coating, on the other hand, is made from inorganic ingredients and is safe to use at high temperatures without releasing toxic fumes.

While GreenPan's Thermolon coating has been tested and certified as safe by third-party labs, the company has faced scrutiny and lawsuits over its marketing claims. In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against GreenPan's parent company, The Cookware Company, alleging that the Thermolon coating contained several toxins, including silane, aluminum oxide, tetraethoxysilane, methyltrimethoxysilane, and potassium titanate. The lawsuit was dismissed, but it raised concerns about the accuracy of GreenPan's advertising and the lack of transparency about the Thermolon coating's composition.

Overall, GreenPan's Thermolon coating offers a safer and more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional nonstick coatings. However, the company's lack of transparency about the coating's composition and the ongoing debates about its marketing claims leave some doubts about its safety.

GreenPan's safety claims

GreenPan's Thermolon coating is made from Silicon Dioxide (or silica), which is derived from sand. The company claims that its coating is free from harmful chemicals such as PFAS (or PTFE, also known as Teflon), PFOA, lead, and cadmium.

However, GreenPan has faced scrutiny and lawsuits over its safety claims. In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against GreenPan's parent company, The Cookware Company, alleging that its products contained toxins despite marketing claims. The lawsuit was dismissed, but it brought attention to the lack of transparency around Thermolon's ingredients and testing.

While GreenPan provides test reports showing that its products are free from certain toxins, critics argue that the testing is not comprehensive and does not cover all potential toxins. There are also concerns about the safety of the Sol-Gel process used to create the Thermolon coating, as well as the possible presence of PTFE or other PFAS in the final product.

GreenPan maintains that its products are safe, non-toxic, and free from harmful chemicals. The company's website provides care instructions and FAQs to help customers maintain the performance and longevity of their GreenPan products.

GreenPan's manufacturing

GreenPan is a cookware company that markets itself as a healthier alternative to traditional non-stick cookware. The brand describes its products as "healthy ceramic non-stick" that can keep consumers safe from "toxic conventional non-stick pans." The company was founded in 2007 by Jan Helskens and Wim De Veirman, who developed GreenPan after learning how toxic conventional non-stick pans can be.

The GreenPan factory is located in Jiangmen, China, and the company states that it has full control over manufacturing practices and procedures. They also reassure customers that there is no child labour in their factory. The factory is currently 30% solar-powered and has an in-house wastewater management system, reduced carbon dioxide emissions, and uses recycled aluminium.

The GreenPan coating, Thermolon, is made in South Korea. It is a trademarked material described as "sand-derived" and "manufactured without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium." Thermolon has been certified by third-party testing labs as conforming to international regular food contact standards set by the US FDA and EU regulators. However, GreenPan has faced scrutiny and lawsuits over its marketing claims, with critics arguing that the company has engaged in greenwashing by overstating the health and environmental advantages of its pans.

In 2019, a class-action lawsuit was filed against The Cookware Company, alleging that GreenPan ceramic non-stick coating contained several known toxins, even though the company advertised its cookware as "completely toxin-free." The lawsuit was dismissed in 2020, with the plaintiff, Anna Saldivar, unable to refile the case. However, it was dismissed "without prejudice" for any other consumer to bring similar claims against GreenPan.

While GreenPan has not disclosed its full list of Thermolon coating ingredients, available test reports indicate that both grey original and black diamond coatings were tested for a wide range of chemicals, with only undetectable levels of aluminium found in one of the grey original coating reports. The tests detected extractable amounts of heavy metals, but these were within recommended safety limits.

Overall, GreenPan's manufacturing process appears to be more sustainable than that of traditional non-stick cookware, and the company has taken steps to reduce its environmental impact. However, concerns remain over the transparency of Thermolon's ingredient list and the accuracy of GreenPan's marketing claims, which have led to lawsuits and criticism from consumers and watchdog groups.

GreenPan's performance

A reviewer from Hungry Huy tested three GreenPan products: the 12" Rio fry pan, the 10" Valencia Pro fry pan with lid, and the 12.5" Lima wok. They found that the fry pans heated up much faster than other non-stick pans they had tested, and that clean-up was easy. They also noted that the fry pans were completely flat, which prevented liquid ingredients from pooling at the sides. Overall, they were "very pleased" with the results and would be happy to replace their old non-stick pans with GreenPan products.

A reviewer from Leafscore tested the GreenPan GP5 Stainless, a 5-ply stainless steel, ceramic-coated non-stick pan. They found that the pan was robustly made and had a longer-lasting non-stick coating than cheaper alternatives, making it more sustainable. However, they noted that there were still questions over the toxicity and coating composition of the pan.

A reviewer from Illuminate Labs also tested GreenPan products and found that the non-stick feature was excellent, and that there was no noticeable erosion of the coating. However, they had concerns about the safety of the non-stick surface and planned to return to using a cast iron pan.

A reviewer from I Read Labels For You found that the Thermolon coating on GreenPan products dissipated over time, and that the cookware stopped being non-stick. They also noted that an odour was emitted from the pan during cooking, and that the coating came off in the dishwasher.

A reviewer from Target gave GreenPan products a positive review, stating that they had been using the products daily for two years and that they still worked well. They noted that they only hand-washed the products and used wooden utensils, and recommended letting the pan cool before washing.

Overall, GreenPan products appear to perform well as non-stick pans, with some reviewers noting that they heated up quickly and were easy to clean. However, there are some concerns about the longevity of the non-stick coating, and questions remain about the safety of the coating.

GreenPan's price

GreenPan offers a range of cookware collections in different colors, styles, and metal types. The price of GreenPan products varies depending on the collection and the number of pieces included. Here is an overview of the price ranges for different GreenPan collections:

• Valencia Pro Collection: This collection is made of anodized aluminum with a mineral Thermolon coating and a "Magneto" base for induction cooktops. The price of individual pieces from this collection can vary, but you can find sets like the 11-piece set, which typically costs around $159.99 but can be found on sale for $118.
• Venice Pro Collection: This collection features stainless steel construction with a Thermolon coating. The price of individual pieces may vary, but you can also find sets, such as the 12-piece set, which usually retails for $179.99 but can be found on sale for $131.56.
• Performance Pro Collection: This collection is made of anodized aluminum with a dark blue Thermolon coating. The price of individual pieces may vary, but sets like the 12-piece set are available and typically retail for $189.95.
• Rio Collection: This collection is similar to the Reserve collection but features a two-tone design with matching handles and exteriors. It comes in black, red, and pale green. The price of individual pieces may vary, but you can find sets like the 22-piece set, which is usually priced under $350.
• Chatham Stainless Collection: This collection is made of three-layered aluminum and stainless steel with a metal-utensil-safe coating. The price of individual pieces may vary, but sets like the 12-piece set are available and typically retail for $199.99.
• Lima Collection: This collection features hard anodized bodies that are scratch-resistant. It includes pieces like the 12" frying pan, which usually costs around $44.99 but can be found on sale for $29.25. You can also find sets, such as the 12-piece set, which typically retails for $159.99 but can be found on sale for $90.02.
• Treviso Collection: This collection is made of stainless steel with a Thermolon coating. The price of individual pieces may vary, but sets like the 12-piece set are available and usually retail for $199.99.

It's important to note that prices may fluctuate, and different retailers may offer discounts or promotions that can affect the final price. Additionally, GreenPan offers free shipping on orders over $125 and often includes free gifts with purchases.

Frequently asked questions